12 Design Mistakes to Avoid in Your Next Project
Q: I have an idea for a blog post: “Design mistakes we won’t make again.” Looking through photos of the beautiful work you’ve done, I’m tempted to repeat similar styles and purchases. But with time, did you ever regret a design choice? – Shannon
A: Great question. We’ve made plenty of design choices we’d do differently now. We’re far from experts, and a lot of what we’ve learned has come from trial and error. Doing something — even if it turns out to be the wrong something — teaches you more than staying frozen in indecision. Below are a dozen real-life lessons from our design and renovation journey, each one short, useful, and honest.

1. Buying an expensive sofa sight unseen
We learned the hard way that you should always try a sofa before committing, especially at a high price. Our first experience: a cheaper online sofa arrived feeling hard and poorly proportioned, so we spent more on a Pottery Barn sofa we’d sat on in-store. Still, even after three years we never loved it — it felt baggy and didn’t match our taste. The lesson: price doesn’t guarantee a fit for your home or your comfort. Testing a sofa in person and trusting your style beats assuming that higher cost equals better.

2. Painting bathroom trim black
Trying bold ideas is worth it, but not everything works. We painted bathroom trim black with a graphic vision in mind and quickly realized it wasn’t right. It took a couple hours to apply and a couple hours to undo — but that’s the point: experimenting helped us move toward what we actually liked. In the end, a clean white-on-white approach gave the space a spa-like feel until a full renovation could happen.

3. Leaving rooms too empty
We once had a stark, non-functional living room because we didn’t bring enough furniture in. That’s easy to remedy — slowly add pieces that create distinct zones and serve a purpose. Over time we introduced seating and a dining area off the kitchen, and the room finally started getting used.

4. Using too many different colors across the whole house
Initially we painted every room a different color of the rainbow. That approach taught us to experiment, then refine. After testing many hues, we edited the palette down to colors we truly loved: a tranquil, sea-glass–inspired scheme in our first home and a moodier, more sophisticated palette in our current house. Be bold, but curate a cohesive palette so the house feels unified.

5. Choosing undersized furniture and art
Small rooms can actually benefit from fewer, larger pieces. Too many tiny items can make a space feel cluttered. We prefer a roomy sofa, large-scale art, or a dramatic light fixture to create presence. Oversized objects add drama and balance, though practicality matters if you have small children or pets — then you can store fragile items as needed.

6. Planting grass everywhere
Grass seed is cheap and low-maintenance once established, but lawns still require mowing and regular care. We found it ate into our free time, so now we favor a more naturalized landscape: a few grassy areas for play, plus native ground covers, wildflowers, and low-maintenance plantings elsewhere. It’s better for biodiversity, looks great, and reduces yard work.

7. Overlooking thrift stores and classifieds
Some of our favorite furnishings came from Craigslist and thrift shops — often for under $30. Secondhand shopping let us score big pieces without the big-box price. Since moving, we’ve found dining chairs and other treasures at great prices. If you want style on a budget, hunting secondhand is essential for unique, affordable finds.

8. Not building more ourselves
DIY projects felt intimidating at first, but we now see how achievable they are. John has built desks, shelves, book ledges, and a long console — all cost-effective and satisfying. Building together adds personality and value to a home, and the process of creating furniture can be as rewarding as the finished piece.

9. Buying matchy-matchy furniture
Rooms feel richer when you mix wood tones, fabrics, and finishes. We avoid making everything the exact same color or style. A mix of painted pieces, natural woods, and varied upholstery creates visual interest and a collected look that evolves over time.

10. Purchasing items that don’t coordinate with the rest of the house
Buying accessories that don’t fit your established style leads to clutter and wasted money. Think about how a new piece will work with what you already own before you buy. If something doesn’t play well with the rest of your home, it usually ends up donated or sold.
11. Using traditional chemical floor finishes
We refinished floors with oil-based stain and polyurethane once, and it produced strong odors and headaches that lingered for weeks. Now we prefer greener methods: water-based stains and eco-friendly sealants with low VOCs. They’re safer for the family and just as effective.

12. Buying temporary fixtures “just for now”
It’s tempting to fill a gap with a cheap interim item, like the small ceiling fixture we once used to replace an old fan. Often it’s worth waiting and saving for a long-term piece you truly love. That said, inexpensive interim solutions can work if they buy you time to make a considered investment later.

All of these “mistakes” are subjective — what reads as an oops for us might be someone else’s proud design choice. The point is to try things, learn, and refine your personal style. Mistakes are part of the process. They teach you what you love and what you don’t, and they help you make better choices in future projects. Happy experimenting!
Update – Want to know where we sourced something in our house or which paint colors we used? Click the image below.









