Objectales

Popular

1938 Lake Michigan Cottage Renovation Reveals Timeless Charm

featured 54670

Before we get to an impressive cottage renovation from Erin, a quick note: Sherry recently posted a charming Easter DIY project she made for Clara over on Young House Life, so you can hop over there for the full details (there’s a preview image below):

img 54670 1

Now, back to Erin’s dramatic home makeover. Sherry and I have often dreamed about taking the roof off a house and raising it a few feet to create more headroom, so we were thrilled to discover a real-life example that did exactly that. This story from a couple living near Lake Michigan checks off several renovation goals: fixing a leaking roof, redesigning the roofline, adding living space, and reworking the upstairs into comfortable, functional bedrooms. Here’s Erin’s account of their cottage renovation:

Hi John and Sherry! We fell in love with our 1938 cottage near Lake Michigan in Wisconsin the moment we saw it in 2002. It had charm, but it had a few major shortcomings—most notably low headroom in the bedrooms and a roof that leaked.

We began by addressing the roof, which was poorly designed and destined to leak. Fixing that led to a full redesign of the roof, a few additions, and ultimately removing the top half of the house and resetting it higher to create usable upstairs space.

Out back, they added a deck with cable railings—a nod to their sailing background, since cable railings resemble sailboat lifelines. Erin also handled much of the landscaping herself: she laid the stone walkway to the detached garage, built mini retaining walls around garden beds, and designed and planted the gardens. It’s her proudest DIY achievement so far.

The upstairs transformation is dramatic. What had been two cramped bedrooms with very low, slanted ceilings became two well-proportioned bedrooms. One bedroom now includes a walk-in closet, and they also added an extra bathroom—an upgrade they quickly learned was essential after living eight years without a bathroom on the same floor as the bedrooms.

In the master bedroom, the custom built-ins were the best decision. They provide so much organized storage that dressers aren’t needed, and a small walk-in closet complements the layout. Erin installed bamboo flooring throughout the bedrooms and handled most of the painting in the house (she left the cathedral living room ceilings to professionals to avoid risking injury).

The new upstairs bathroom is compact—only 8 by 8 feet—but they fit a 5 by 3 foot shower and generous storage into the space. Like the bedroom built-ins, the bathroom cabinets were designed by Erin and built to her specifications. The upstairs hallway opens to the living room below, creating a bright, airy feel and an opportunity for a small gallery wall inspired by projects we’ve shared. One cherished find from demolition is a board stamped “Put here July 11, 1938,” which they kept as a historic memento. The bathroom door was salvaged from Erin’s grandparents’ house, adding sentimental value.

We loved our cottage before the renovation, but after these thoughtful updates we couldn’t imagine wanting to live anywhere else. The combination of a redesigned roof, improved headroom, functional built-ins, a new bathroom, tasteful floors, and careful landscaping turned a charming but impractical house into a comfortable, well-organized home.

If this inspires you, Erin has documented more of her cottage renovation and other projects on her blog. Pick your favorite detail from this redesign—mine is the original board from 1938, and Sherry’s favorite is the deck and backyard, which she says feels a bit like a bed-and-breakfast. Thanks to Erin for sharing this lovely home transformation and the practical DIY ideas that came with it.