How to Find Emotional Closure After a Breakup
The Charming “Bed & Breakfast” Next Door: A Missed House That Turned Out to Be a Blessing
You probably remember us mentioning the little “bed & breakfast” house around the corner. We’ve admired it for years—not just for its in-ground pool, tennis court, and picnic area, but for its exceptionally charming exterior. It always caught our eye. Here’s a photo we took during a snowstorm last year:

When Sherry and I began house hunting this fall, we joked about knocking on the owners’ door and asking to buy it. We daydreamed about it more than we probably should have. But before we could work up the nerve to actually approach them, we discovered someone else had already bought the property—privately, without a “for sale” sign or any public listing. It was one of those classic real-estate heartaches: the dream house was gone before we even had a chance.
So when the new owners introduced themselves at our moving sale last month, it was a strange mix of emotions. On the one hand, it was a little bittersweet—mainly because they ended up buying nearly $100 worth of patio furniture and rugs from us. On the other hand, they were incredibly friendly and genuinely excited about the house, so that softened the blow. They were also kind enough to invite us over for a quick tour, which let us finally see the interior of the home we’d been ogling from the sidewalk for years.
We all know how celebrities can seem smaller in person than in photos, and this was a similar moment. The house, despite its gorgeous exterior, didn’t match the towering expectations we’d built up in our heads. That turned out to be a relief. Seeing the inside made our decision to pursue a different house feel even more right—our future home checks more boxes for what we need right now.
Don’t misunderstand us: the house was a great find for the right buyers. It has a ton of makeover potential and, as “before” photos go, it’s probably uglier than our new place ever was. There were elements like florid wallpaper, outdated blue carpeting, tired light fixtures, and red laminate countertops—classic remnants of an earlier era that are begging for renovation. The new owners seemed to appreciate that potential; they were already stripping wallpaper and painting during our visit. It’s clear they’re DIY enthusiasts who plan to make big changes, and that was a comforting thought: the house will be loved and updated by people who care about it.
After the tour, we walked away with closure. The house wasn’t the right fit for our family: it lacked the open floor plan, single-level layout, and growing-family-friendly features we need at this stage. Practical considerations mattered, too—maintaining a large lawn, pool, and a private tennis court would be a significant time and energy commitment, especially for parents of a six-month-old. When you add up the upkeep and the layout limitations, it’s easy to see why the timing wasn’t right for us.
Knowing what the interior looked like and seeing the new owners already hard at work made the whole experience feel resolved. Instead of dwelling on what might have been, we feel genuinely glad that the house has owners with big plans and a willingness to renovate. We’ll still call it “the bed & breakfast” because that name captures the house’s charm and history better than any wistful nickname like “the one that got away.”
This chapter closed in the best possible way: we got our answers, we avoided a potentially unsuitable purchase, and the house will be transformed by people who seem excited to make it their own. That’s a win all around.
Pssst—We announced this week’s giveaway winner. Click here to see if it’s you.








