Shower Curtain Fail Caught on Camera
Not Every Decor Find Is a Home Run: Our Shower Curtain Try
We like to share both our wins and our small missteps, so here’s a short tale of a decor experiment that didn’t quite land. It wasn’t a dramatic disaster—more of a “not bad” fail—but it’s worth sharing because these little lessons help sharpen design instincts.
We were at HomeGoods hunting for a few finishing touches for the guest bathroom—night tables, rugs, pillows—and stumbled on a shower curtain that seemed perfect for just $12. A modern pattern, the right gray-and-yellow palette to play off the vintage tile, and a sale price that made it an easy impulse purchase. We took it home and hung it up right away.

At first glance it looked promising: a contemporary pattern that helped wake up the old yellow tile and give the bathroom a fresher vibe. But after a minute we noticed the overall effect felt busy. The floor pattern—sort of a Scrabble-like, grid layout—paired with the gridded wall and the semi-small-scale modern floral pattern on the curtain created too much visual “noise.”

In short: the mix of several competing patterns at similar scales made the room feel cluttered rather than cohesive. It was an honest lesson in pattern scale and balance—how a beautiful piece can still overwhelm a space if the surrounding elements are already busy.

We removed the curtain, packed it back up, and returned it. Returning an item is part of the process; not every purchase will be a perfect fit. On the upside, we did pick up a couple of pillows for the bedroom while we were out—those were winners. For the guest bathroom, though, we decided to step back and reassess rather than force something that didn’t belong.
If you’re dealing with lots of tile, gridded walls, or patterned flooring, here are a few design tips we considered while making our decision:
- Prioritize scale: If the floor or walls already have small repeated patterns, opt for a plain or large-scale pattern on your curtain. Small-scale patterns across multiple surfaces create visual clutter.
- Choose texture over print: A solid curtain with a tactile weave—linen, waffle knit, or a subtle slub texture—adds interest without competing with tile or wall patterns.
- Tone-on-tone patterns: If you want pattern, go for wide, muted stripes or tone-on-tone designs that read more like texture from a distance.
- Use negative space: Let one surface carry the visual weight. A simple, calm curtain can balance a busy floor and allow architectural details to shine.
- Consider hardware and length: Simple hooks, a clean rod, and the right curtain length can make a solid or subtle curtain feel tailored and intentional.
We’re in no rush to replace the curtain—there are no overnight guests on the calendar—so we’ll take our time. Options include hunting for a plain white or soft gray waffle-knit curtain, looking for a subtle large-scale pattern, or trying a DIY solution. Stenciling a simple motif, dyeing a canvas curtain for a soft ombré, or adding a hand-painted border are all possibilities we might explore. If we do DIY, we’ll document every step and share the results.
Psst—want to see something we don’t regret buying? We posted about it this week, and there’s another Clara video in that post, because yes, we’re those people.








