How to Compare Countertop Options and Choose the Right One
We’re making steady progress on the kitchen (we wish we could share updates daily, but we’re doing this in real time). Our latest big decision: choosing the new countertops. After weeks of weighing options—from concrete and granite to quartz, Corian, recycled glass, and butcher block—we finally settled on the best choice for our kitchen, family, and budget.

Concrete was high on our wish list and we pinned countless tutorials. But after talking with professionals who pour concrete countertops for a living, concrete turned out to be impractical for our layout. Our new peninsula will have two sides with a double 12″ overhang on a 3 x 5′ surface, which means a thicker, heavier slab would be required. That created two major problems:
- Our cabinets can’t support the extra weight without costly reinforcement.
- Our floor structure isn’t built to carry that load safely.
We briefly explored concrete “slipcovers” that coat a substrate with a thin concrete layer, but those had more downsides than benefits for our situation. We’ll probably still experiment with concrete in another project—perhaps a long outdoor dining table—but for the kitchen we needed a lighter, more budget-friendly solution.

With concrete off the table, we visited local kitchen showrooms and big-box stores to compare materials, prices, and installation options. We’d splurged on granite in our last kitchen and loved how it looked and performed, but that was a smaller space and the cost back then was about $3,700 after a promotion. This renovation has roughly twice the countertop area because of the added peninsula, so repeating that spend wasn’t realistic—using the same granite would have been over $7,000.


We considered butcher block—affordable, warm, and stainable to a deep chocolate tone—but with another dark wood surface nearby, it felt like too much wood in the same area. Plus we like the easy-to-clean, sleek surface that stone provides. We also sampled quartz brands, solid surface options like Corian, and eco-friendly choices such as recycled glass. To help decide, we brought lots of samples home to compare under our kitchen’s light and alongside our paint, appliances, and backsplash.

- Top left: LG Viatera quartz in “Geneva” (Lowe’s)
- Bottom left: Caesarstone quartz in “Pebble” (local kitchen shop)
- Right: Silestone quartz in “River Blanco” (local kitchen shop)

- Top left: Cambria quartz in “Torquay” (local kitchen shop)
- Bottom left: Cambria quartz in “Sussex” (local kitchen shop)
- Top right: Allen & Roth quartz in “Alloy” (Lowe’s)
- Bottom right: Cambria quartz in “New Quay” (local kitchen shop)
We also brought home a stack of white solid-surface samples (Corian’s Glacier White on top, plus options by LG Hi-Macs and Allen & Roth) to see how they played with our backsplash and shelving.

Recycled glass and other eco-friendly counters were beautiful, but they were outside our budget. That said, we’re keeping other green choices—like cork floors and reusing cabinetry where possible—to balance the overall environmental impact of the renovation.
We fell in love with one quartz option—Silestone in River Blanco—but it came in at more than $5,000 just for the counter material. For cost and practical reasons we pivoted to a solid surface option that gave us the clean look we wanted without the price tag. Our final pick: Glacier White Corian.


Why Corian? Several practical reasons made it the best fit for our kitchen renovation:
- Cost-effective: Corian is significantly less expensive than many quartz or natural stone options. At the store we priced it around $38 per square foot, compared to many quartz or granite options that were $80–$100 per square foot.
- Proven durability: We’ve seen it in real kitchens and heard positive long-term feedback from family members who have used Glacier White for years without major issues.
- Nonporous and easy care: Corian resists stains because it’s nonporous, and it’s designed to resist mold, mildew, and bacteria—features that matter in a busy family kitchen.
- Lighter weight: Solid surface is much lighter than concrete or granite, so existing cabinets and floor joists can support it without expensive reinforcement.
- Seamless appearance: When installed correctly, Corian can create long stretches of countertop without visible seams—ideal for a clean, bright look.
- Reflects light: The bright white surface helps bounce light around a windowless kitchen and pairs well with colorful backsplash tiles and open shelving.
We understand the worry that an all-white kitchen might look too plain, but many inspirational kitchens we love use white countertops with white or light cabinets to create a classic, airy backdrop. Our gray-green penny tile backsplash will provide contrast and personality, and colorful items on our open shelves will stand out beautifully against the white counters.
We’re also considering a subtle cabinet color—perhaps a soft taupe-gray—to add depth while keeping the overall palette calm and cohesive. We’ll share final photos once everything is installed.
How about you? Have you chosen Corian, quartz, granite, concrete, or butcher block for your kitchen countertops? We’d love to hear what worked for your space, budget, and lifestyle.
P.S. We announced this week’s giveaway winner—check our site to see if you’re the lucky recipient.








