Objectales

Popular

How to Choose the Right Siding Color for Your Home

featured 41901

We painted our house—well, we painted a few small test swatches. The original cream color wasn’t terrible, but it didn’t do the trim any favors since everything was nearly the same shade. We’ve admired several neighboring homes with gray hardboard siding and brick, and wanted to see if a mid-tone gray would make our house look more cohesive: one unified home rather than a brick base with a big cream box above.

To choose a direction, we held up about 25 swatches against the brick, paying attention to the mortar’s cool gray undertones. From those we narrowed the field to three colors that seemed most harmonious. Then we grabbed three small paint pots from Lowe’s and painted test squares right above the brick so we could observe each option where the siding would meet the masonry. (Yes, I wore my shirt inside out while painting—no shame.)

img 41901 1

The winner?

img 41901 2

The swatch on the right won our vote. It’s a warm, taupe-gray that shares undertones with the brick and especially the mortar, so the transition between siding and brick reads more intentional and cohesive. Because it’s mid-tone, it won’t compete with our existing black roof, the yellow front door we love, or the bright white trim we plan to add.

img 41901 3

The color is Flagstone by Martha Stewart; we’ll have it color-matched to a quality exterior paint, ideally with primer built in. The middle swatch was Mushroom by Martha Stewart—too dark for our plan—and the left swatch was Bedford Gray by Martha Stewart, which leaned icy and blue in comparison. Photos don’t capture true color perfectly, but in person Flagstone hit the balance we were looking for: not too cool, not too dark, and not too light.

We considered a darker gray, which can be stunning with crisp white trim, but a deep charcoal felt like it might overpower our small ranch. With a mid-tone gray on the siding, the black roof can serve as the primary dark element while the white trim becomes the bright accent—creating contrast without overwhelming the facade.

img 41901 4

That said, our timeline is a little out of order. We still need to demo the scalloped trim on the porch and rebuild the columns so they read chunky and square. If we paint the siding first and then remove the scallops, we risk chipping paint that will require touch-ups. So the plan is to demo the scallops and frame the columns first, then paint the siding Flagstone gray and finish with bright white trim around windows and the yellow door.

We’re juggling this exterior refresh alongside a kitchen remodel, so we’re keeping an eye on the forecast and hoping to complete the siding and trim before it gets too cold for exterior painting. I can’t help picturing the finished look: gray hardboard siding that picks up the mortar undertones, crisp white trim that pops, and a sunny yellow door as a cheerful focal point. If it doesn’t land exactly as imagined, we have gallons of the current paint in the basement—repainting is always an option.

Have you ever painted your house exterior or trimmed your siding? Did you try multiple test swatches before committing to a full color change? Painting an entire facade can feel nerve-wracking, but test patches make the decision much easier. We were surprisingly decisive this time and excited to move forward—now we’re crossing our fingers that fall holds out a little longer so we can get the job done.