How to Paint and Reupholster a Stool
This is another project John wanted me to call “Stool Boom” — here’s why John likes that name. A while back I transformed a stool that, oddly enough, arrived at my door unannounced. I’ll explain the mysterious mail situation in a moment, but first I’ll walk you through how the makeover happened.
Imagine an old, beaten-up stool painted in a faded periwinkle blue, riddled with nails and nail holes and topped with a piece of wood that was beginning to rot. It needed a little love and a simple, budget-friendly plan.

The first practical step was removing the old nails. I used the back of a hammer to pull out each nail and clear away the obvious hardware so the surface was ready for repair and paint. Taking the time to remove rusty nails and smooth any splintered areas is important when you want a clean finish.

Next I primed the wood and painted the stool a rich navy. I used a $3 test pot of Benjamin Moore’s Santa Monica Blue for this job — on-screen photos made the color look almost electric, but in real life it reads as a deep navy. I applied two coats and let each dry thoroughly before moving on to the upholstery portion.

For padding and fabric I rummaged around and used extra loft batting I already had (leftover from a previous project) and a piece of fabric I liked. Why reuse supplies? Because I’m thrifty, and also because this wasn’t my stool — so I didn’t want to splurge. Up to that point I’d spent only $3 on paint.
To give the seat a finished, tailored look I bought two small boxes of decorative nail heads for $1.79 each. Decorative nails are an inexpensive, high-impact detail that crisply finish upholstery projects.

Here’s how I assembled the top: cut the batting and fabric so they extended about two inches beyond the stool top on all sides, then pulled the excess down and folded it under to create a clean edge. I used the decorative nail heads to secure the fabric and batting along the sides. To keep the spacing consistent, I tapped the nail heads about two inches apart and used a two-inch piece of cardboard as a spacer while working my way around. After roughly thirty taps the first side was finished.

I repeated the process around the remaining three sides until the top looked neat and evenly nailed. The resulting stool was compact, cozy, and surprisingly polished for the time and money invested. Total cost: $6.58. Photos can sometimes misrepresent color, but in person the finish is a rich, subdued navy rather than an overly bright blue.

Here’s a side view that captures the final silhouette a little better than my original before photos did:

After finishing it, I spent a moment admiring the little transformation — I hugged it, kissed it (yes, more than once), and then sent it off with a little pang of separation anxiety. Turns out the stool wasn’t just for me: it was part of a winter feature for Do It Yourself magazine. The publication had organized a surprise-makeover series where a few bloggers each received an unexpected item in the mail to refurbish and reimagine.

The feature included a variety of talented bloggers and makers who each put their own stamp on whatever arrived. I loved seeing the creative range — for example, one blogger turned a stacked table into a charming cake stand. In the magazine’s layout, my stool makeover was styled with yarn and other craft items to fit the editorial spread, which was a fun surprise since we don’t keep much yarn ourselves.

The fabric I used might look familiar if you follow our other projects — it’s the same print we used for Clara’s weekly photo series. The pattern suggests flowing water, which made it perfect for a whimsical children’s portrait where it looks like the little bean is swimming.

We still had plenty of that fabric left after making Clara’s quilt and a birthday banner, so it made sense to use the leftovers on the surprise stool. It’s a great reminder that small scraps from larger projects can be repurposed into a quick, attractive makeover.
If you’re thinking of trying your own small-scale furniture update, here are a few tips: remove old hardware and clean the surface first, use a good primer before painting, choose a test pot of paint for low-cost color trials, add batting for a comfortable seat, and finish upholstery with decorative nail heads for a neat, professional look. These simple steps keep DIY stool refinishing affordable and approachable.
What furniture have you updated lately? Any painting or reupholstering projects on your bench? Do your kids ever end up playing on the new fabric? If it brings them joy, that’s a win. And on a final note — we might be biased — but Clara singing a medley of songs remains one of the sweetest things we’ve ever recorded. That girl really loves to sing.








