Objectales

Popular

Deck Failed Inspection? How to Fix Common Violations

featured 48056

#FAIL

I wish that hashtag referred to a playful Internet meme, but this time it describes the outcome of our deck footing inspection. We had hoped for a quick thumbs-up and instead got a fail. Cue the DIY anthem: “you take the good, you take the bad…”

Here’s what happened. We booked an inspector to check the six holes we’d dug for footings. I expected he’d confirm the locations and depths were correct—simple, straightforward, and quick. We even went the extra mile and temporarily attached some ledger boards so he could inspect those as well. I wanted any issues flagged early, before we completed the whole deck (in our county the second inspection comes after the deck is finished), so catching anything now seemed sensible.

img 48056 1

He arrived and, within moments, my hopes sank. He shook his head, said “we’ve got some problems here,” and started taking notes. Sherry, who was snapping photos from inside, captured my not-so-happy face from the guest room window.

img 48056 3

Once he explained the issues (after a silence that had me sweating), the problems made sense. First, I’d missed two small but critical letters on a county diagram: “P.T.” The diagram indicated the rim board where I’d attached the ledger board on the siding side needs to be pressure-treated wood. Ours was not.

img 48056 4

Although we had installed the required waterproof flashing behind the ledger, the inspector said that to attach a ledger on that side we’d have to either replace the rim board with pressure-treated lumber—something that would involve disturbing the house structure—or lower the deck about two feet and bolt into the masonry foundation instead.

img 48056 5

But that siding-side ledger wasn’t the only issue. On the brick side of the house, the inspector told me the brick veneer isn’t sound enough to support the deck load. I thought I’d addressed that by using long screws that would pass through the rim board for added hold, but the county regulations didn’t accept that solution.

img 48056 6

He even drew a diagram on the ledger to show why it’s unsafe: an air gap between the brick and the house prevents the load from transferring properly. The inspector’s recommendation, again, was to lower the ledger to bear on masonry foundation about two feet down—or consider an alternative approach.

img 48056 7

The alternative was to build a free-standing deck supported entirely by posts in the ground. That option appealed to us: we didn’t want a deck two feet lower than the doorway, which would complicate everyday use with extra steps and tripping hazards. Choosing a free-standing design required revising our plan, digging more holes, and passing the footing inspection after the changes.

For a few minutes I felt like all our progress had been reversed. I took a breath, asked the inspector a few more questions, thanked him, and watched him hand over the official failed inspection notice. Charming.

img 48056 8

img 48056 9

Sherry overheard everything and gave me a reality check: failing an inspection wasn’t the worst outcome. Many people fail one or more inspections in our county; it’s strict. It was better to discover problems now rather than after assembling the entire deck and having to dismantle it later. Her perspective helped me regroup: this is a fixable setback and a learning opportunity to blog about.

img 48056 10

Next, the inspector suggested I meet with the reviewer who approved our original permit and have him draw a new plan for a free-standing deck. That made sense—having the same people who will approve the plans help produce them should reduce future surprises. He kept the new footing count minimal (seven posts) and tried to reuse as many of the materials we’d already bought as possible. Best of all, he said our ledger boards could still function as rim boards with flashing, while the new posts would carry the deck’s weight.

So the updated plan is essentially our original layout plus seven posts and girders to convert it to a free-standing deck. The reviewer did a quick redraw and worked with our existing purchases where possible, minimizing added cost and effort.

img 48056 13

The meeting also opened a helpful line of communication with the building department—I’ve already called the reviewer with follow-up questions. After regrouping, we scheduled another footing inspection once we dig the new holes and prepare the updated plan. My dad took the news well, which helped.

img 48056 14

So that’s the state of the project: more holes to dig, a revised freestanding design, and a hopeful return to the inspector for approval. We’ll wait to buy any additional materials until the footing inspection passes. Fingers crossed—next week we’ll be singing a different tune: “The hills are alive with the sound of an approved footing inspection!”

We’ll keep you posted on this DIY roller-coaster. In the meantime, share your own failed inspection or home-improvement fiasco stories—especially the ones with happy endings. Sherry reminded me that DIY isn’t always smooth, but the results are usually worth the setbacks. I’m keeping my eye on the prize: a new deck for many family gatherings, and the satisfaction of building it ourselves.