How to Paint a Faux Inlay Pattern on Furniture

I’ll spoil the suspense up front and start with the after photo: this is a simple, affordable thrift-store table makeover that anyone can tackle. It’s a deceptively easy transformation that brings a worn Moroccan-style side table back to life while keeping the warm wood character intact.

Nearly two years ago I rescued a $25 Moroccan table from a thrift shop. We liked the warm reddish-brown tone and the interlocking shapes on the top, so at first we simply lived with it. After cleaning it I avoided rushing into repairs—placing decorative items over cracked and water-stained areas was an easy temporary fix.

Over time the tabletop suffered more wear. Some of the little wood pieces loosened and even popped out—turns out it makes a fun puzzle for a curious toddler. Eventually the damage reached a point where refinishing felt overdue. We considered painting it, inspired by some bold, colorful versions we’d seen, but ultimately wanted to keep the wood look if possible. The plan became: sand, add wood filler where needed, then stain and reassess.

We used a wood putty similar to one that had worked well on previously refinished pieces in our home. After the putty dried and we sanded the patched areas, we applied Minwax Red Mahogany stain to match the existing tone. Two coats later it was obvious the puttied spots weren’t accepting stain the same way the original wood did. The repaired areas remained lighter and more noticeable than I wanted.

I stepped away from the project for a while—sometimes a pause helps your brain find a fix. Back at the garage after a trip to the hardware store I remembered a dark stain marker we use for touch-ups on dark furniture. I tried it on the putty areas and, to my relief, the marker darkened them enough to blend much better with the surrounding wood. It didn’t make them vanish completely, but it made a measurable difference.

With the putty less obvious, I still wanted a decorative solution to distract the eye and celebrate the table’s Moroccan character. Rather than paint the entire piece, I decided to add a few hand-drawn inlay-inspired details: a central star motif and corner accents connected with flowing vines and leaves. The goal was decorative interest that would draw attention away from imperfections while preserving most of the wood surface.

For control I used an oil-based Sharpie paint pen, which works well on stained surfaces and reduces bleed-through compared with water-based pens. I created a cardboard stencil for the seven-pointed stars (seven is our favorite number and Moroccan patterns often include stars with five to eight points), traced the shape, and cut it out. Tracing the stencil onto the tabletop and filling it in took several passes to achieve solid coverage. In hindsight choosing a slightly smaller stencil than the desired final size is a good trick, because the traced outline tends to expand the shape a bit.

The vines were drawn freehand. I practiced a few wavy lines and added alternating leaves to turn squiggles into simple organic vines. If you’re nervous about freehand, practicing with a marker on paper first helps build confidence—this is an approachable technique for most DIYers. Once the stars and vines were in place I refined the stars with an extra coat of paint pen to make them appear more uniform and crisp. The white detailing created contrast and successfully shifted focus away from the puttied areas.

To decorate the table sides I laid the table on its side and repeated the star-and-vine motif on each panel—one star near the top, one in the middle, and one by the bottom—connecting them with hand-drawn leafy lines. The vines usually required only one coat, while the stars needed a second pass for solidity. When the design felt balanced and dry, I planned to seal everything with a clear, low-VOC finish to protect the paint and the stained surface.

The entire process—from sanding and filling to staining and hand-drawn detailing—took a few hours, with the decorative stenciling and freehand work adding a couple more. It’s a bolder move than a simple re-stain, but it’s reversible: if we want a different look later we can sand and re-stain or opt for a full paint job.

Considering authentic mother-of-pearl inlay tables can sell for hundreds or thousands of dollars, this $25 thrift-store revamp is an excellent low-cost alternative that retains warm wood tones while introducing a Moroccan-inspired vibe. We used materials we already had on hand, but even if you had to buy a small supply list—wood putty, stain, a stain marker, and a paint pen—you’d still spend very little compared with buying a new piece.

Right now the table fits nicely in the nursery, surrounded by other wood accents. It’s not a neutral choice for every room, but it’s playful, practical, and not permanent. If the look wears out on us down the line, we can always resurface or repaint the piece. This project shows that with a little patience, some creative thinking, and a steady hand, a thrift-store score can be transformed into a charming, custom accent.