Objectales

Popular

Tile a Marble Herringbone Fireplace: Step-by-Step Guide

featured 56593

With our fireplace refacing plan finalized and supplies ready, it was time to start with step one: tile. This post covers every detail from surface preparation and cutting to setting tile and grouting, so you can follow along through the whole process.

herringbone tiling tutorial diy grouting

To clarify the plan, I highlighted the areas that would be tiled. The tiled border is only about 7 inches wide because the remaining brick will be framed with wood and MDF, which will overlap the tile slightly — so the tile had to go first.

fireplace area highlighted for tiling

Before you begin, check local code to ensure the wood surround won’t be too close to the firebox. In our area the requirement is at least 6 inches of tile before the wood surround can begin. And no, the tile color wasn’t going to be “grellow.”

fireplace ready for cement board

We chose a marble subway tile that was available for around $5 per square foot. It offered the look we wanted without an intimidating price tag.

marble subway tile

Before installing tile we needed a smooth, stable substrate. We used 1/4″ cement board, cutting it with the score-and-snap method to create strips. Heavy-duty masonry screws and a masonry drill bit held the cement board in place. It was a dusty job and much easier with two people—one to hold the board and one to drill.

cement board installation

We cleared everything from the mantel before drilling. It’s worth removing decorations and fragile items so dust and vibration don’t send anything crashing. Safety and avoiding broken keepsakes are both good motivators.

cleared mantel during tiling prep

We also removed the old wood top as part of demo before tiling. For the hearth, instead of removing the entire old surface, we adhered cement board over it using heavy-duty construction adhesive and weighted the pieces overnight with storage ottomans. Afterwards we added a few screws in the corners for reinforcement.

cement board on hearth

Because we had previously added a cork floor over an older linoleum and left an asbestos liner undisturbed, adding cement board and tile directly over the existing hearth actually restored the level and alignment rather than creating a raised edge.

With the cement board installed, the fireplace was ready for tile, though we took care to protect the cork floor with rosin paper before we started mixing thinset and applying grout.

protecting floor with rosin paper

We laid out the tile beforehand, buying a few extra boxes to allow for breakage and to pick out any discolored or chipped tiles. That strategy paid off: we used about 90% of the tile and returned the remainder. Laying everything out also let us balance the veining so darker veins weren’t concentrated in one area.

tile layout before installation

We decided on a herringbone pattern for the hearth and a traditional brick-lay pattern for the narrow surround. With only a 7-inch band around the firebox, a herringbone pattern on the surround would have looked cramped and busy, so the simpler layout suited that smaller area better.

A 45-degree triangle square guide made angled cuts much faster. Most hearth cuts were at 45 degrees, so that tool was essential. We cut with a wet saw, which handled the marble fairly well, though the marble tiles were a bit brittle and occasionally lost a corner during cutting.

using wet saw to cut tile

With initial pieces cut, we mixed thinset and began setting tile. The basic process follows common tiling techniques: apply thinset, press tile into place, and check alignment. We relied on previously documented tiling methods and tips we’ve used before for cement board, penny tile, and subway tile installations.

setting tile with thinset

Tiling the hearth was repetitive but straightforward; the many cuts made it a time-consuming task in a small space. It took roughly four hours to complete the lower hearth area, including a lunch break. The next day, during a quiet afternoon, we finished the top portion more quickly because the cuts were mostly straight.

tiled fireplace progress

Because the outer edge will be concealed by the MDF frame of the upcoming wood surround, we didn’t need razor-sharp edges. We staggered cut pieces so we could use both halves of a cut tile, minimizing waste and reducing the number of unusable fragments.

staggered tile cuts reused

By the end of the second day the tile was fully set. The inner firebox brick will be painted a charcoal color later, and trim pieces around the hearth will finish the transition to the floor, but the tiled surface was already a dramatic improvement.

completed tile before grout

The following evening we grouted with non-sanded grout in a Snow White tone, which is actually a subtle soft gray rather than a stark white. Grouting took about 45 minutes. One person packed grout into the joints while the other followed with a slightly damp sponge to smooth joints and remove excess. The transformation from ungrouted to grouted tile is always satisfying—the grout really ties the whole look together.

grouted marble tile

After the grout cured according to the product’s instructions, we applied a tile and grout sealer. The sealing step took only about ten minutes and protects both the marble and the grout from stains and wear.

sealed marble hearth and surround

The finished re-tiled hearth and surround in white marble felt like a major upgrade after roughly seven hours of total work. The cost was reasonable given the result: supplies included cement board, adhesive, tile, and grout. A summary of costs follows.

  • Cement board (2 sheets): $16
  • Masonry screws: already owned
  • Liquid Nails Heavy Duty: $2
  • Subway tile: $5.50/sq ft, totaling $70
  • Thinset: already owned
  • Tiling tools (saw, trowel, float, etc.): already owned
  • Grout: $11
  • Tile sealer: already owned
  • TOTAL: $99 (with gift cards and leftover supplies our out-of-pocket cost was lower; without those savings this could be closer to $150)

We’re thrilled with the herringbone hearth and subway surround combination. It feels elegant and adds great visual interest without overwhelming the room. Next steps include building the surround, reconstructing the mantel, adding trim and molding, priming, painting, and then enjoying a celebratory cookie or two when the project is complete.

finished marble fireplace hearth

Have you tiled a fireplace or used a herringbone pattern on a hearth? Share your experiences or tips—tile projects are rewarding and, with a little planning and the right tools, very approachable.

*This post contains affiliate links