Oak Hardwood Flooring: Pricing and Selection Guide
Let’s talk about wood. We decided to install solid oak hardwood in the four bedrooms and the upstairs hallway because many rooms downstairs and the stairs themselves already have a medium-toned oak that matches nicely. That tone proved to be very family-friendly in our previous house, holding up well to pets and kids.
We started hunting for the right flooring by checking local classifieds for any large lots in the right tone, but didn’t find anything suitable. Then we visited Lumber Liquidators, a place we’d used successfully before for other large flooring purchases and for the cork kitchen floor in our last home. They carry a wide selection and keep underlayment and flooring tools in stock, which makes it convenient when you want a one-stop solution for a big flooring project.

Our daughter Clara made herself at home immediately—kids and wood floors are a natural fit—and we took our time looking through samples and displays. She even had fun on a small set of display stairs, which the staff joked is a rite of passage for visiting toddlers.


We took six samples to compare against the existing stair color and left them overnight so we could judge them in natural daylight. Next morning we tested the samples against the stairs in the new house to get a true read on tone and grain. To confirm the condition of the wood beneath the carpet runner, we removed the runner from the top stair. After pulling countless staples by hand, the wood underneath was in great shape and the medium brown tone matched what we hoped for—not too yellow, not too dark, and not too light. In short: Goldilocks-perfect for our home.

We favor a medium oak tone for both aesthetic and practical reasons. Dark floors tend to show every speck of dust and pet hair, while very light floors can highlight wear and scuffs more quickly. We had a similar oak tone in our last house that worked well with our furniture and household life, so that familiarity influenced our decision as well.

From our sample photos, the best match was clear: the sample in the bottom left matched the stair color and the variety of grain closest to the existing floor. It was also the same board width (2 1/4″) and thickness as the hardwood downstairs, which helped create a consistent, cohesive look throughout the house. While we liked some wider plank options, staying true to the existing visual language of the home felt right.

We had to stop ourselves from ripping all the old carpet off the stairs right then, because we’re prioritizing removing and replacing the upstairs carpet before we move. The first stair took about 20 minutes to free, which means the whole staircase will be a decent chunk of work—so we’ll return to it after the main upstairs floors are installed.

The following day we went back to Lumber Liquidators with exact square footage measurements and placed our order. We chose a solid oak called Lono Oak. It’s a 3/4″ solid oak floor (not engineered), which means it can be refinished multiple times and comes with a 25-year warranty. At the time of purchase, the list price at the store was $3.69 per square foot.

I asked for their best price and mentioned we’re repeat customers. That got us a 10% discount on the entire order, bringing the price down to $3.29 per square foot and reducing the cost of underlayment and other materials we picked up. We also chose a particular underlayment suited to our subfloor and plan to share more about that during the installation phase.
We plan to install the hardwood ourselves to save on labor costs—the store’s install estimate was around $4,000. With about 2.5 weeks before move-in, we’ve got a tight timeline to rip out carpet, paint trim and possibly doors, and lay the new floors. Painting the blue/mauve trim while the carpet is out but before flooring goes down is part of the plan, and we’re considering renting or buying a paint sprayer to speed that work up.

We left the store energized by the plan and the savings. The hardwood is ordered, the stair test confirmed the match, and the next steps are removing the old carpeting, painting the trim, and installing the new floors. We’ll share updates as we move through the process and tackle the installation ourselves.
More Flooring Projects
If you’d like to read about other flooring projects we’ve completed, here are some past posts and tutorials you can look up by title:

- Refinishing Hardwood Floors 101
- How To Install Hardwood Flooring Yourself
- How To Install Hardwood Floors Without Nails
- How To Install Click-And-Lock Cork Flooring
- How To Paint A Floor
- How To Stain A Concrete Floor
- How To Remove Carpet








