Houses We Considered Before Buying Our New Home
Back when we were house hunting in 2010, we published a series of posts that each spotlighted a different property we toured (you can see them here, here, here, here, and here). Although our search is wrapped up this time, we decided to revisit nine other houses we casually toured along the way—many of them during open houses—to share what stood out, what didn’t, and why each property ultimately wasn’t the one for us. We had fun driving around, retaking photos, and remembering the odd details (“That was the one with the phone in the bathroom!” “That was the one with deer in the backyard!”).
The Lake House: This modest home sat only a few blocks from where we live now, and the fact that it was on a lake was a huge draw. Even though it was below our budget and offered waterfront views, the lower level presented two deal-breakers: unusually low ceilings that couldn’t be feasibly raised, and the prohibitive cost of adding a bathroom to serve that lower living space. We realized a full renovation to make the layout functional would be far more expensive than the listing suggested, so we passed.

Note: As with our 2010 house-hunting photos, we respected each homeowner’s privacy when retaking images for this post—colors, angles, and filters were adjusted to obscure identifying details.
The Big Ranch: We’re big fans of ranch-style homes, and this one had a massive kitchen that felt like it could be transformed into an open, welcoming heart of the house. The kitchen opened to a large living room with a substantial fireplace—great bones if you don’t mind updating some dated finishes. The downside was that the rest of the floorplan felt fragmented, and the price was well above our target. It had potential, but not at that cost.

The Gray Shaker: This property caught our eye because it was located in our dream neighborhood and listed at an attractive price. Once inside, the exterior siding and some unusual design choices gave us pause—the gray exterior looked almost like synthetic shaker shingles—and the interior felt chopped up, with steps, odd doorways, and a segmented layout that disrupted flow. Even with a tempting price tag, it didn’t feel right.

The Quirky House: This was the most eccentric property we toured. The basement had been transformed into what we jokingly called “the HGTV room”—a finished space resembling a yacht cabin, complete with built-in seating that folded out into bunk beds for sleepovers. But the home’s odd roofline, a large stained-glass window in front, and a price nearly $100K more than the home we ultimately bought made it impractical for us. Still, it was memorable—the street name even included “Young,” which made us smile.

The Updated House: This contemporary renovation was inspiring. Although it was not in our preferred neighborhood and the price exceeded our budget, almost every inch had been updated—there was a striking fireplace in the kitchen and many thoughtful modern finishes. It was also the house with the telephone in the bathroom, which made the tour feel delightfully kitschy. We loved the style, but the cost and location didn’t align with our priorities.

The Barn: This charming home in our dream neighborhood offered a nice balance of move-in-ready spaces and areas that would benefit from light updating. It featured a graceful circle driveway, a private yard with a deck, and upstairs rooms with peaked ceilings that added character. Despite its appeal, the price exceeded what we wanted to spend, and a few awkward layout quirks made us worry the house would be harder to adapt to our needs than others we’d seen.

The Garage Theater House: The home was a bright yellow when we first saw it, which almost made us drive past on our photo rerun. It’s since been repainted and looks great. Its standout feature was an incredible backyard with a deck and pergola—perfect for entertaining. The garage had been converted into a dedicated theater room with dark walls, a large projector screen, and booming surround sound; the sellers noted it would be straightforward to convert back into a garage if desired. Priced above our range, it still felt like a standout and unsurprisingly sold.

The Pool House: Located in our favorite neighborhood, this property’s big selling point was an impressive pool and an even larger surrounding deck. It was tempting to imagine summer days out back, but the home came with higher-maintenance features—extensive siding that would eventually need replacement, a large pool to maintain, and a price that stretched beyond our budget. For us, the long-term upkeep outweighed the immediate fun.

The Double Staircase: This house was grand—too grand for our tastes—with two staircases and an overall feel that bordered on formal. It needed updates and was listed well above our price range, yet walking through it was enjoyable. We left thinking how nice it would be if a smaller, more modestly priced version of that layout existed—big in personality but easier on the budget.

Less than two weeks after touring these homes, we noticed another for-sale sign and followed it down a quiet cul-de-sac. The house we found there was the same size as our current home, comfortably within our budget (significantly cheaper than many houses we’d casually toured), and in need of a lot of love—exactly the kind of project we wanted. It became the easiest offer we ever wrote.

That experience taught us that casual walks through open houses and keeping an open mind can unexpectedly lead to finding the right home. If you’re house hunting, enjoy the process, take note of what matters most to you—location, layout, renovation potential, maintenance needs, and budget—and don’t be surprised if the perfect option turns up when you least expect it.








