Objectales

Popular

Tree Too Close to Your House? Dangers, Solutions and Costs

featured 59153

As Cher might sing, if we could turn back time, we’d definitely have planted that big oak a little farther from the house. What started as a small sapling grew into a huge tree whose roots and heavy canopy became a real threat to our foundation and roof.

img 59153 1

When the home inspector examined the roots and measured their proximity to the foundation, his conclusion was clear: the tree had to go. Even if we could somehow slow the root growth, roughly half the canopy hung directly over our house. A single broken limb in a storm could damage the new roof, and a full collapse would be far worse.

We’ve seen some severe storms in recent years, and we’ve witnessed first-hand the damage falling trees can cause. In fact, a tree fell on the house behind ours during Hurricane Irene in 2011, so we weren’t about to take any chances.

img 59153 2

img 59153 3

img 59153 4

Once we committed to removing that deck tree, we asked an arborist friend to review the property and we checked the inspector’s notes. Together they identified several other problem trees: three in the front yard and another behind the deck. Some were too close to the house, some were very large, and others showed signs of rot or hollowing at the base. Any of those conditions greatly increase collapse risk compared to a healthy tree.

img 59153 5

We’d actually used this same crew years ago at our first house to deal with a huge split tree. The company—Shady Tree Service—was run by William, who’s been great to work with over the years. He knows his stuff, and it felt a bit like catching up with an old friend; a lot has changed since that first job (he’s married with kids now, and so are we).

Tree removal is serious, skilled work. Watching the crew operate is part choreography, part physics: they calculate angles, momentum, and the trajectory of each limb, all to make sure nothing swings into the house. There’s a lot more planning behind each cut than it looks.

img 59153 6

Here’s William in the bucket taming the lower limbs of the deck tree. The care and control required to lower big pieces safely is impressive.

img 59153 7

This is the view from our guest room window—no zoom—and it makes clear just how close the tree was to the house and how precisely the crew had to work.

img 59153 8

Some of the trees were shockingly hollow. This photo doesn’t fully convey the size of the cavity—one could fit multiple family members inside. Hollow or decayed trunks are a major red flag for potential failure.

img 59153 9

img 59153 10

After the crews finished the back looked much safer—still green, but without trees hanging over the deck and roof.

img 59153 11

img 59153 12

The change in the front yard was more dramatic than we expected. We’d hoped to keep at least one of the front trees, but the safety concerns won out. Removing them has several benefits: less risk of storm damage to our new roof, reduced chance of rot spreading to siding and trim, and more sunlight reaching the lawn, which should help grass fill in.

All told, removing five trees cost several thousand dollars. Tree removal pricing depends on size, accessibility, and location; for example, a medium oak near a house in our area typically runs between $1,000 and $2,000. When you remove multiple trees, additional trees often cost less because the crew and equipment are already on site. You might pay $1,000 for one tree, but get a better total rate for five trees when bundled together.

Some tips we learned for negotiating and preparing for tree work:

  1. Get multiple estimates if you don’t already have a trusted arborist—compare services and prices.
  2. Make sure the company is licensed and insured. This is dangerous work and you want coverage if anything goes wrong.
  3. If you’re a repeat customer, mention it—companies often give discounts to loyal clients.
  4. Keep competitor coupons or flyers; some companies will honor a rival’s coupon to win the job.
  5. When the quote is given, smile and ask, “Is that your best price?” Then listen. You may be offered a discount, free stump grinding, or another perk.

This was a fun project for our daughter Clara—she loved watching the wood chipper, watching the crews up in the trees, and standing on the remaining stumps. We considered leaving part of a stump on the deck to serve as a table base, but the position would have been too close to the house to be practical.

img 59153 13

Instead, we asked the crew to cut a few thick slices to use as stepping stones and informal seats. They hauled the heavier pieces away to be chipped and recycled as mulch.

img 59153 14

Those rounds looked deceptively light, but each was extremely heavy and had to be positioned with the tractor. It was satisfying to see the finished placement.

And for a little epilogue: we’ve noticed some deer that visit our new yard, and one of them sneaked up behind me while I was taking after photos. John pointed it out and I managed to get a shot before it bolted when Burger barked. Evidently we still live in a kind of fairy-tale forest—thankfully, there are plenty of healthy trees left to keep that feel intact.

img 59153 15

img 59153 16

img 59153 17

Anyone else having trees trimmed or removed? I could watch professionals take trees down all day—the rigging systems, the careful cuts, and the choreography are oddly mesmerizing. If you’re considering tree removal or trimming, prioritize safety, hire an experienced arborist, and get a few estimates before committing.