Objectales

Popular

6th Blogiversary: How to Layer Rugs for Texture and Style

featured 59282

When a Side Gig Falls Apart: Our Unfinished Rug Collection

We’ve written a few behind-the-scenes pieces about taking on side projects—how our lighting collection came together, and what it was like to write a book—so this time we wanted to share the story of a side gig that didn’t pan out, despite months of work. We try to show the good, the bad, and the ugly here, and this was one of those experiences that felt important to share.

Without naming the company involved, a reputable rug maker that produces cotton and wool rugs reached out with an idea: “Let’s create a Young House Love rug collection.” It came at the same time we were developing our lighting line, so it seemed like a natural extension of that work. One of the reasons we accepted the lighting collaboration was that the partner agreed with our affordability values—designs priced for everyday customers. We hoped to bring the same mindset to rugs: attractive, well-made pieces at price points that felt honest to our readers and to ourselves.

img 59282 1

We were excited about designing rugs in natural fibers like cotton and wool—materials we prefer in our own home. Over many months we exchanged emails, placed calls, and shipped samples back and forth. We worked closely with the company’s designers and manufacturers, evolving sketches into renderings and renderings into physical samples. Early photos from the sampling process show how tiny Clara was at that point, a reminder of how much time had passed while we tweaked patterns, colors, and scale.

img 59282 2

Technically, things were going well. The manufacturer produced high-quality flatweave cotton rugs, and the aesthetic direction felt right. Most of our design time was spent fine-tuning color palettes and the proportions of motifs so the rugs would read well in real rooms. The challenge that gradually became unavoidable was price. We’re bargain hunters by nature (and often call ourselves cheap), and we’ve rarely paid full price for a rug. When the quotes for our designs came back much higher than we’d anticipated, it felt like a sudden halt in momentum.

img 59282 3

We kept circling the same question: how could we, in good conscience, place our name on a product we wouldn’t buy ourselves? We explored options, asked the manufacturer about cost-saving changes, and weighed where compromises could be made without compromising durability or materials. There simply wasn’t enough room to reduce the price meaningfully without lowering the quality—a compromise neither party wanted to make.

After a few difficult conversations and some sleepless nights, we mutually agreed with the company that the partnership wasn’t the right fit. Rather than force a product to market that felt misaligned with our values, we chose to step away. The company retained the right to produce the rugs at the prices they felt were appropriate, so the designs weren’t completely wasted; but for us, the relationship ended before an official collection ever launched.

Even though the collaboration didn’t reach a public debut, it was far from a total loss. We gained practical experience in product development—what it takes to move from concept to sample, how designers and manufacturers communicate, and the realistic constraints around materials and cost. The biggest lessons were clear and useful: establish target price points and minimum quality standards up front, and make sure both sides agree on those essentials before investing months of time.

Working for yourself often comes with a greater sense of accountability—effort directly impacts income—but it also teaches you to listen to your instincts. If a project feels wrong, it’s better to bow out early than to attach your name to something that doesn’t align with your expectations or values. Walking away can mean months of unpaid work, but it’s preferable to feeling like a fraud when your brand doesn’t match the product.

So that’s the backstory of one side gig that never saw the light of day. Has something similar ever happened to you—where you poured time and energy into a project and then realized it no longer matched your original intentions? How did you handle it?