Garage Bonus Room Remodel: How We Finished Our Space
Do you remember the old furniture-and-pillow hoarding space at the end of the hallway that we used to call “the storage room”? When we carved a bit of that square footage out to create our laundry room, the leftover area became more rectangular and gained easier access thanks to the new glass door we installed at the hall’s end (see that post).

If you follow us on Instagram or Facebook, you’ve probably noticed this space has been in the middle of a transformation lately.

Some background: when we moved in, the above-the-garage area was only framed and had basic HVAC, so it was never fully finished. For a few years it served as a practical storage spot for seasonal decorations, extra furniture, and an abundance of pillows. Because it wasn’t insulated or climate-controlled, it wasn’t a space we used daily, and it mostly stayed off our to-do list—until we realized how useful a proper bonus room could be as our family grew.

We don’t have many clear “before” photos because there wasn’t much that felt worth showing, but you can spot the area briefly in our house tour video and in a few laundry renovation posts. It was basically the room where you might find a single missing shoe, a box of forgotten snacks, or random household overflow—perfect for storage, but not much else.

When we originally decided to finish it, our plan was simple: electrical updates, insulation and drywall, then flooring, trim, and paint. What once felt like wasted square footage quickly became a high-priority project once our family grew and we started hosting more kids for playdates and sleepovers. With roughly 360 square feet to work with, it made sense to convert it into a functional playroom/bonus room that could handle art projects, movie nights, homework, and extra guest space when needed.

We started by bringing in an electrician to add outlets and recessed lighting—much simpler to do before drywall goes up—and hired a local window company to replace a single window with a triple window to admit far more natural light. The opening was already framed with the proper header, so the swap was straightforward, and the exterior siding here made the install easier than a brick exterior would have.

Drywalling a room this size was more than we wanted to handle ourselves, so we hired a local pro who came in with a small crew and finished the drywall, taping, and mudding in a few days. Having that work done quickly and cleanly made the rest of the renovation much easier and saved us time and frustration.

With the structure complete, the remaining tasks were finishing and flooring: priming and painting the walls and ceiling, laying hardwood, and installing trim and baseboards. We chose to continue the same oak hardwood that runs through the rest of the upstairs so the space would feel cohesive and like it had always been part of the home. We’ll layer in a large area rug to bring warmth and softness for kids to play on.
Fortunately, this room had a plywood subfloor rather than particleboard, so we were able to use a traditional nail-down hardwood installation. It was a different—and surprisingly satisfying—process compared with the floating floors we’d used elsewhere. We’ll share what we learned about that in a future post.

We painted the walls before installing the floor, matching the hallway color (Edgecomb Gray by Benjamin Moore) so the transition from hall to room feels intentional. Once baseboards and window trim were added, the space started to look like a proper finished room—one the kids were eager to use even before all the furniture arrived.

Now we’re in the process of furnishing it thoughtfully. Rather than filling the room with brand-new purchases, we’ll bring in items we already own, relocate toys from other rooms, and add a secondhand craft table for projects. We have a plan for the recessed sloped area around the window and are refinishing a Craigslist find to fit the space. The goal is to let the room evolve naturally so it matches the way our family actually uses it: art, games, movie nights, and sleepovers, with plenty of room for running around and for our dog Burger to join in the fun.

P.S. We finally put together a Shop Our House page that lists furniture, accessories, and paint colors you see around our home—if you’ve been asking for that, it’s worth a look.








