Kitchen Remodel: How to Plan a Completely New Layout
Kitchen Renovation: Reworking the Layout and Adding a Hidden Mudroom
As many of you already know—from our podcast or the Instagram post—we recently completed the largest renovation we’ve ever tackled: a full kitchen overhaul. It was a long, sometimes messy, ultimately rewarding project. We waited to share the details until we’d lived with the space long enough to call it “finished” (with the caveat that no room is ever truly done), and now we’re ready to walk through our planning, layout decisions, and the solution that made the kitchen work better for our family.

Why We Reworked the Floor Plan
Early, smaller updates—removing some upper cabinets, painting trim and paneling, swapping lights, adding open shelves, resurfacing counters, and replacing appliances—improved the room but didn’t fix deeper layout problems. As our family grew, we needed a kitchen that supported multiple people working at once, better sight lines to the living room, and smarter storage for shoes, bags, and coats near the garage door.

The original floor plan felt like a single-chef kitchen. It worked when one person handled most tasks, but it left the cook isolated from the table and living room during meals. The extra-long peninsula blocked sight lines and created an inefficient path between prep areas and where the family ate. That separation became more frustrating than we expected—especially during busy mornings when multiple small tasks and requests overlapped.

Solving the “Kitchen Jail” Problem
The wall between the kitchen and living room blocked conversation and made anyone doing dishes feel shut off from the family. We decided that removing that wall and opening the kitchen to the living room would create a much more connected, flexible space. Opening that connection was one of our primary goals when reworking the plan.

Creating a Practical Entry Storage Solution
Because our main entry from the garage opens directly into the kitchen, we’d been dealing with a jumble—shoes in a basket, coats on chairs, backpacks on counters, and a perpetually dirty path from the door. Initially we considered building a separate mudroom by adding a new wall, but that plan raised problems: tight kitchen circulation, awkward appliance placements, lost natural light, and an island too small for the four of us.

Instead we adapted a strategy we’d seen in our book work: a hidden mudroom built into floor-to-ceiling cabinetry. Closed, these cabinets blend into the kitchen; open, they reveal individual cubbies for shoes, bags, coats, and charging stations. That approach kept light and space in the kitchen while solving the storage problem right where we needed it.

Final Layout Decisions and the Island
By building mudroom function into cabinetry beside the door and opening the kitchen to the living room, we gained much more useful space and improved flow. With the kitchen essentially expanded to fill the entire room, a standard 8-foot island looked too small. We wanted a larger, continuous surface without a seam, and Cambria Quartz’s 11-foot super slabs made that possible. As a result we installed a ten-foot island (close to what we’d envisioned) that seats all four of us and includes extra base storage at each end.


What We Gained
After settling on the final plan, the renovation delivered several important improvements:
- Significantly more storage and prep space
- Main prep and sink areas positioned closer to where people eat
- A much stronger connection between kitchen and living room
- A hidden, organized mudroom cabinet directly by the entry
- An island large enough for eating, homework, and hanging out—seating all four of us
We were initially concerned the work triangle might feel too spread out, but in daily use it hasn’t been an issue. Thoughtful storage and grouping of frequently used items have made routines more efficient.
The Hidden Mudroom in Use
The “hidden mudroom” consists of two identical, full-height cabinets. The kids share the cabinet nearest the dining room (each with their own side); Sherry and I share the other. Inside each cabinet are shoe baskets, hooks for coats and bags, a top shelf for small items, and outlets for charging devices. The backs of the doors serve as personal boards for photos, calendars, and reminders. It has proved to be a major sanity-saver.


Next Steps
Next we’ll share the demo and rebuild photos—expect some intense before-and-after images showing how the room was stripped down and rebuilt. We’ll cover materials, mistakes we made and corrected, and practical tips we learned. For now, we’re enjoying not having to weave around a peninsula dozens of times each morning.
P.S. If you’re curious about paint colors, rugs, lighting, or other sources used throughout our home, we compiled that information on our Shop Our House page.








