Objectales

Popular

We Bought a House: Our Homebuying Journey

featured 79624

Don’t worry — we’re not moving into this one.

beach-house-before-john-sherry-sold-sign

As we mentioned on this week’s podcast, we recently bought a beach house. It isn’t a modern, high-end getaway — it’s almost 100 years old and easily the roughest house we’ve ever taken on. That makes it one of our most challenging and, honestly, most exciting projects yet.

If you prefer to listen to us talk about it, press play on the embedded episode below — and you can subscribe for free if you’d like.

We fell for the house’s charm and amazing location — two big reasons we decided to take on such a big project. The price also helped: it was priced noticeably lower than nearby homes because of its condition. Below are some “before” photos, starting with the front of the house.

beach-house-before-front

Where is it?

The house is in Cape Charles, VA, a small historic town on Virginia’s Eastern Shore. The Eastern Shore is the narrow peninsula separated from mainland Virginia by the Chesapeake Bay, so our drive from Richmond takes about 2.5 hours and finishes with a 17-mile crossing over the Bay.

We first discovered Cape Charles in 2013 when we were invited to be part of a tourism commercial. We loved the town immediately—its quiet streets, slow pace, and the feeling that it hadn’t been discovered by everyone yet.

beach-house-before-2013-video-shoot

Cape Charles is peaceful and family-friendly: no traffic, people getting around on foot, bikes, or golf carts, and a main strip with local shops and a family-owned ice cream place. The town faces the bay, so the water is calm and shallow — perfect for young kids, kayaking, and paddleboarding. Even on busy summer weekends, you can often find free parking close to the beach.

Why buy a house there?

We’ve been considering a vacation home or rental property for years. Both of our families grew up around rental homes, so creating our own getaway felt natural. For us this is both a fun renovation opportunity and a potential long-term investment: a place to build family traditions and, if we choose, generate rental income.

Stepping away from daily blogging didn’t erase our desire to renovate — if anything, another project proved to be something we truly wanted, not just a way to create content. That said, buying a 96-year-old house two-and-a-half hours away that needs a lot of work is not the easiest path to “content.”

beach-house-before-from-door

We had been looking at local rental prospects, but Cape Charles kept drawing us back. The town is seeing more renovations and small hospitality projects, and that momentum suggested it was the right time to buy before prices climbed higher. A local realtor showed us several options, and one unlisted “pocket” property caught our attention.

beach-house-before-entry

Why THIS house?

Many of the homes we saw were in rough condition, and location was a deciding factor for us — it’s hard to change a lot or a block. The house we purchased wasn’t on MLS or Zillow; it was a private pocket listing our realtor had been showing to buyers she thought would take on a project. It was at the top of our budget at $125,000, but the location made it worth it: three blocks from the beach, two blocks from the main shopping area, and close to the town park. The walkability and charming tree-lined street made it a clear choice.

beach-house-before-dining-room

Built in 1920, the house has solid bones and period details: porch columns and brackets, stained-glass windows, tall ceilings, an old clawfoot tub that we plan to reglaze, a beautiful old stair railing, and original wooden doors with vintage knobs and keyholes. It’s one of four near-identical houses on the block, and seeing a recently renovated neighbor sold for nearly three times our purchase price convinced us of the potential return on investment.

beach-house-before-neighbors-house

There are also little surprises to be saved, like a back staircase that other similar houses lack — and, for posterity, a stash of 1992 Pepsi bottles discovered during our walkthroughs.

beach-house-before-rotten-side

beach-house-before-upstairs-bedrooms

How will we use it?

We imagine this becoming a family tradition: summers and off-season weekends spent together, and someday New Year’s gatherings with friends. My own family spent summers at a Delaware shore house, and those memories inspired the idea of a nearby place for our growing family. The Cape Charles house will be our Petersik summer tradition and a space to host family and friends.

beach-house-upstairs-bathroom

We also plan to rent it as a vacation rental to offset maintenance and renovation costs. Cape Charles has a healthy short-term rental market — some homes command strong weekly rates in summer — so renting when we’re not using the house makes financial sense. We’re still deciding whether to use platforms like Airbnb or manage bookings another way, and we’ll share what we learn as we go.

beach-house-top-of-stairs

Will we DIY the renovation?

We’ll do some work ourselves but rely on professionals for major systems. Structural and safety items — foundation repairs, a new roof, new HVAC, and replacing old knob-and-tube wiring and plumbing — will be handled by licensed contractors. After those big items are addressed, we plan to tackle many of the finish tasks ourselves: installing cabinetry, tile, fixtures, painting, and decorating. That mix lets us control costs while ensuring the critical work is done correctly.

beach-house-before-front-bedroom

Some repair work, like foundation and HVAC updates, won’t be visually dramatic, so it may take time before you see big before-and-after transformations. We’re excited to share our renovation plans, including proposed layout changes based on tours of neighboring renovated homes, and we’ll post diagrams and updates as soon as we have them.

P.S. If you missed it, we recently posted our Annual Gift Guides for Gals, Guys, and Kids — there are still some great sales going on.