Objectales

Popular

Beach House Renovation: Gut-to-Studs Transformation

featured 80994

We’ve shared a few scattered updates about our beach house progress on social channels and our podcast, but it’s definitely time for a long, photo-filled update that lays out everything we’ve been doing — including our latest (and hopefully final) floor plans.

Things look VERY different now than when we first bought the place. (If you want to compare, check the original “before” photos and video tour.) We’ve lived the “it has to get worse before it gets better” phase in full.

img 80994 1

As the photo above shows, we removed all of the interior walls. The large “LEAVE” written on a curved wall isn’t a horror-movie warning — it’s a note the contractor left for the crew to avoid removing the lath behind the curve. Leaving it makes it easier to bend drywall around that shape later.

On a recent podcast episode we talked about the decision to pull most of the plaster and some drywall. Although we worried about tearing things apart, the inspector and our contractor agreed it was too risky to leave things mostly closed up. Opening walls to the studs was the safer, more thorough approach to find and correct hidden problems.

img 80994 2

There were two main reasons we stripped things to the studs:

1. Condition. We could have patched cracked, stained or missing plaster, but that would have been time-consuming and costly — and would have slowed down electrical, plumbing, and HVAC work as tradesmen contended with damaged old walls. Starting fresh turned out to be the more efficient option overall.

2. Hidden damage. Visible mold and serious termite damage in some exposed studs convinced the contractor that ripping things open was prudent. We’re glad we did: we found additional termite damage and several framing members that had warped or no longer did their job, all of which needed reinforcement to keep new walls from cracking later.

img 80994 3

It was painful to take the house apart, but finding those issues gave us confidence that we’re addressing problems properly. With reinforcements in place throughout the structure, the house will be straighter, more stable, and less likely to develop cracking in the future.

Taking the interior back to studs also confirmed our decision to replace the exterior siding. Opening the walls revealed large gaps between the siding and the interior — no housewrap or insulation — which explained why cold winds blew through and why older homes like this are so hard to heat. Had we only patched the siding and interior plaster, we would have missed this critical air-sealing issue. Catching it now will make the house much easier and less expensive to heat and cool long-term.

img 80994 4

On the bright side, we were able to save some of the house’s original character — the heart pine floors, old stair railings and treads, original doors and doorknobs, and much of the trim and millwork — which we’ve kept safe and plan to reinstall when the house is rebuilt.

Removing the walls uncovered a few pleasant surprises too, like a brick chimney hidden behind a faux mantle that runs through the front bedroom. It needs some repairs but we love the idea of exposing that brick to add character in both rooms.

img 80994 5

Note: our attempt to stage that chimney photo as a punch actually produced hilariously blurry outtakes. The things we do while the contractor isn’t looking…

img 80994 6

We did the bulk of the demo work with a hired contractor rather than trying to do it ourselves during short weekly visits. Old houses frequently host mold, lead paint, and asbestos, so working with professionals made the process faster and safer.

img 80994 7

Seeing the house stripped down helped us rethink our original floor plan, because some areas felt much larger once they were opened up. But before we get to the new plan, there was another bigger problem to handle: a severely rotted side of the house.

img 80994 8

Not only was the siding deteriorated and improperly enclosed years ago with wood not intended for exterior use, but the foundation under that side had been set on sand rather than solid footers. That section was sinking and effectively separating from the rest of the house.

img 80994 9

The solution was to tear that entire side off and rebuild it. We initially hoped to reinforce the existing beams, but the wood was too compromised by rot and termites, and the siding contained asbestos shingles. Structural engineers, the inspector, and our contractor all recommended starting over on that side.

img 80994 10

img 80994 11

The downstairs porch and upstairs enclosed porch were failing, with rotten framing and failing ceilings, and even the two bathrooms tucked behind those porches were water-damaged and unsafe. All of that area needed rebuilding.

img 80994 12

img 80994 13

Once the interior demo was wrapped up, we approved the reconstruction of that entire side of the house. It was surreal to arrive one day and find a chunk of the house missing, but the new foundation and rebuilt framing came together quickly.

img 80994 14

img 80994 15

Rebuilding made a huge difference. The new section is solid, level, and matches the original window and door placement required in our historic district, so the house will look original when the siding goes back on.

img 80994 16

Fast-forward a week and the contractor’s crew had most of the new foundation and framing in place. It’s already night-and-day better — no more rotted siding visible to the neighbors, and a sturdy porch and bathroom area to use while work continues.

img 80994 17

img 80994 18

Before, that area felt slanted and unstable; now it’s square and safe. We raised the floor to be level with the rest of the house and replaced termite-damaged studs with reinforced framing so everything ties together well.

img 80994 19

img 80994 20

img 80994 21

img 80994 22

With framing underway and new siding painted and ready to install, we used the opportunity to revise our floor plan. The rebuilt side felt long in person, so we rethought how to use that space. Rather than making an elongated mudroom and a separate bathroom, we turned half of the old mudroom into a bathroom and repurposed the old bathroom into an eat-in breakfast nook — a cozy gathering spot that will work great in a vacation home.

img 80994 23

img 80994 24

img 80994 25

img 80994 26

We also shifted the kitchen toward the back to sit beside the new breakfast nook. We experimented with layout tools to confirm flow and cabinetry placement, and we’re leaning toward a semi-open island with stools on one side and tile or open shelving on a triangle wall by the back door.

img 80994 27

img 80994 28

Upstairs we stole a little room from the middle bedroom to create usable closets for two bedrooms, and we reworked the rear bedroom access to preserve light while still allowing privacy. The plan is to add double-pocket doors with glass — possibly frosted — so light from the back window travels through while the doors remain functional and space-saving.

img 80994 29

img 80994 30

For now, interior framing is in progress and the new siding is about to go up. We’re excited to see that next phase and will share more photos as it comes together. No more pink siding Photoshop experiments — real, finished siding is on the way.

img 80994 32

If you want to follow the whole story from the start, we documented buying the house, an initial video tour and floor-plan ideas, our decorating inspiration, and our siding color decision across earlier posts and episodes.