Objectales

Popular

5 Creative S’mores Upgrades: Sweet and Savory Ideas

featured 116395

We love gathering around our backyard fire pit, which inevitably means lots of s’mores. While classic s’mores are always a win, experimenting with new ingredients and combinations keeps things exciting. Below are five favorite upgraded s’more ideas that are simple to pull off at your next backyard fire pit night or beach bonfire.

5 Upgrades Smores Hacks Shown On Table With Fun Ingredients

All of these upgrades still include the best part: roasting over an open flame. You won’t need to be a gourmet cook to try them—simple prep and a willingness to experiment are all it takes.

S’more Night Firepit Supplies

Before the recipes, here’s a quick overview of our fire pit setup and the supplies we keep handy for easy, relaxed s’more nights. These are practical items that make hosting simple and enjoyable.

  • Portable fire pit with a cover or lid
  • Comfortable outdoor chairs (Adirondack or similar)
  • Outdoor string lights for ambiance
  • Firewood and kindling
  • Outdoor storage box to keep firewood dry
Solo Stove firepit area with black Adirondack Chairs

We also keep a small metal caddy or storage tin with basic s’mores supplies in the kitchen so it’s easy to carry everything outside in one trip. Typical contents of our kit include:

  • Graham crackers, chocolate bars, and marshmallows
  • Small paper plates and napkins
  • A lighter or matches
  • Reusable metal roasting sticks
Smores Supply Kit In Metal Tin With Ingredients Lighter Plates Napkins And Metal Roasting Sticks

Quick cleaning tip for metal roasting sticks: soak the tips with sticky marshmallow residue in water overnight to make cleanup much easier.

Five S’more Upgrades

Ready for the fun stuff? Here are five easy ways to elevate your s’mores game:

  1. Savory s’mores
  2. Chocolate swaps
  3. Cracker swaps
  4. Adding fresh fruit or spreads
  5. Fluff dips

1. Savory S’mores

Savory s’mores are a playful mash-up of s’mores and a charcuterie board. Instead of roasting marshmallows, roast bite-sized snacking cheeses and combine them with charcuterie, crackers, and savory spreads. Hot honey is a favorite finishing touch for balance and brightness.

Upraded Savory Smores With Cheeses Bri Crackers Proscuitto Salami and Honey

Keep a simple spread with three categories: cheeses, crackers, and toppings. Offer a few choices in each to let guests mix and match.

Snacking Cheeses

  • Brie bite wheels
  • Fontina snacking pieces
  • Herb cheddar bites
  • Mini waxed cheeses like Babybel

Savory Crackers

  • Rosemary or herb crackers
  • Plain crisp crackers
  • Gluten-free options if needed

Toppings

  • Charcuterie meats such as salami or prosciutto
  • Fig jam or other fruit spreads
  • Honey or hot honey for a sweet-spicy finish
Upgraded Savory Smores With Rosemary Cracker Italian Herb Cheddar Proscuitto and Fig Jam

Babybel-style mini cheeses are a crowd-pleasing, easy-to-serve option. To keep snacking cheeses chilled while you’re outside, nest them on a shallow pan over a block of ice or use another cold setup so they stay fresh between rounds.

Roasting Babybell Cheese Over Firepit Flame for Savory Smores

Savory s’mores can serve as a casual dinner—then switch to sweet s’mores for dessert without anyone needing to go inside. Minimal kitchen time and almost no dishes make this a relaxed option for groups.

2. Chocolate Swaps

Upraded Smores With Chocolate Alternatives Like Andes Mints And Dark Reeses Peanut Butter Cup Things

A simple way to refresh a classic s’more is to swap the standard chocolate bar for other chocolate candies. Mini or thin bars are especially handy for melting evenly. Try options like mint chocolates, thin peanut butter cups, sea salt caramel squares, or kit kat pieces for new flavor profiles.

Upgraded Smores With Andes Mints and Reeses Thin Dark Peanut Butter Cup

Our vote: mint chocolates are underrated and pair surprisingly well with a toasted marshmallow and a hint of salt from a different cracker base.

3. Cracker Swaps

Upraded Smores With Graham Cracker Alternatives Like Cookies and Saltines

Swap the graham cracker for sturdier or flavored bases to dramatically change the s’more’s character. Make sure the substitute is large and strong enough to hold fillings. Here are some fun alternatives:

  • Saltines—for a perfect sweet-and-salty balance
  • Chocolate chip cookies (slim varieties work best)
  • Ritz or butter crackers for a buttery base
  • Stroopwafels for a caramelized twist
  • Pretzel thins for extra crunch and salt
  • Shortbread or butter cookies for a rich, crumbly bite
  • Oreo Thins or similar chocolate wafers for an indulgent swap
Upgraded Smores With Saltines Shortbread Cookies and Chocolate Chip Cookies

Saltines with a toasted marshmallow and mint chocolate are a standout combination—don’t be surprised if guests ask for seconds.

4. Add Fresh Fruit or Spreads

Upraded Smores With Fruits and Spreads Like Strawberries Bananas Peanut Butter and Lemon Curd

Fresh fruit adds brightness and texture. While it takes a bit more prep, the payoff is worth it. Use thin slices of strawberries, bananas, apples, peaches, nectarines, pears, or whole berries. Fruit spreads and nut butters are another easy route—spread peanut butter, Nutella, or lemon curd on your cracker before adding marshmallow or other fillings.

Upgraded Smores With Banana And Peanut Butter Strawberry Slices and Chocolate Hot Honey on Saltines

Try combinations like shortbread + fresh strawberries + toasted marshmallow for a strawberry shortcake vibe, or lemon curd + marshmallow on a salted cracker for a bright contrast.

5. Fluff Dips

Upraded Smores With Marshmallow Fluff Dips with Peaches Cookie Dough and Reeses Peanut Butter

For a different take, skip standard marshmallows and use marshmallow fluff as a dip. Toast fruit or cookie dough balls on the stick, coat them with fluff, then toast again briefly to create a crunchy, caramelized exterior while keeping the interior warm and gooey. Options to dip and toast include strawberries, peach or apple slices, pineapple chunks, edible cookie dough balls, or mini peanut butter cups.

Toasted Marshmallow Fluff With Whole Strawberry Over Firepit

After toasting, enjoy the fluff-dipped item alone or sandwich it between two crackers. A whole strawberry dipped in toasted marshmallow fluff is a surprisingly irresistible treat—crispy on the outside and warm and jammy inside.

Our Favorite Combos

Here are a few tried-and-true favorite combinations to get you started:

John’s Top 3

  • Traditional s’more with sliced strawberries on graham crackers
  • Savory s’more: fig jam, prosciutto, and fontina on a rosemary cracker
  • Lemon curd and marshmallow on saltines (no chocolate)

Sherry’s Top 3

  • Traditional s’more using mint chocolate on a buttery cracker
  • Savory s’more with hot honey, salami, and mini cheese on a buttery cracker
  • Whole strawberry dipped in toasted marshmallow fluff (no cracker)

Have fun mixing categories—cheese, crackers, toppings, chocolate swaps, and fruit all play well together. Keep a variety on hand and let guests build their favorites. Happy s’mores-ing!

Other Posts You Might Enjoy

Backyard Pool Area With Firepit And Outdoor Movie Screen

If you enjoy backyard gatherings and fire pit nights, consider exploring articles on backyard transformations, adding a pool, hosting outdoor movie nights, and creating cozy fire pit areas to expand your outdoor living space and entertaining options.