Objectales

Popular

25 Creative Holiday Gift Exchange Themes for Secret Santa

featured 117017

Every year readers ask for ideas from my family’s long-running Christmas gift exchange, a tradition we first mentioned on a podcast episode in 2016. Nearly a decade later, we’ve updated the list and organized it here so it’s easy to reference. If your family or group is stuck on what to buy this holiday season, introducing a theme can make shopping faster, cheaper, and a lot more fun.

Christmas Tree In Bedroom. Next To Fireplace With Gifts Under

How Our Gift Exchange Works

For as long as I can remember, my extended family has used a simple exchange to reduce holiday stress. Rather than buying presents for every cousin, aunt, and uncle (there were 22 of us growing up), we draw a single name at random from a hat so each person is responsible for one gift.

The basic rules are straightforward:

  1. Don’t draw the same person you had last year.
  2. Don’t draw an immediate family member (a sibling or parent).

We built rituals around the exchange. On Christmas morning we pause to watch each person open their “exchange gift,” and after dinner we fold strips of paper and draw names for the next year. Those moments are a big part of my holiday memories.

John As Kid At Chrismast Time In 1980s

As families grow, we adapt. When cousins married and had children, we shifted from individual names to family units (for example, me + my spouse + our kids = one unit). We also added smaller exchanges among siblings and between cousins. These adjustments keep the exchange manageable and help people concentrate on fewer, more meaningful gifts.

Why Holiday Gift Themes Help

At some point someone suggested adding a theme to the exchange. It instantly made things more playful and creative. Themes started simple—like “Food & Drink”—and over the years became quirkier (“What’s That Smell?”). A good theme gives givers a starting point and recipients something fun and unexpected.

Close Up Of Christmas Presents Under A Tree With Woven Tree Skirt

Think of a theme like a writing prompt: it narrows your choices, sparks ideas, and steers shopping away from the vague task of “find something Great Aunt Barb might like.” With a theme people tend to focus less on matching personal tastes and more on clever or thoughtful interpretations—so the result is often more memorable and less stressful.

20 Holiday Gift Exchange Theme Ideas

Below are twenty themes our family has enjoyed, with examples of how people interpreted them. Some of the most unusual prompts produced the funniest and most memorable gifts.

  1. Say Cheese: Photo- or cheese-themed gifts—think cheese boards in fun shapes, frames, instant cameras, or even novelty items tied to smiling and photos.
  2. Travel Junk: Souvenirs and items collected on trips: mugs, ornaments, postcards, and keepsakes from places visited that year.
  3. The Year of Granny: Gifts that recalled a beloved family member—her favorite snacks, items in her preferred colors, or something nostalgic like an automatic card shuffler she used to own.
  4. Hey Hot Stuff: Anything spicy or warming—hot sauces, spicy snacks, candles, firepit accessories, cozy socks, or blankets.
  5. The Great Outdoors: Gear and activities for nature—trail mix and snacks, National Parks guides, headlamps, portable games, or outdoor play equipment for kids.
  6. Back In The Day: Retro items and nods to the past—vintage-style board games, classic toys, or gifts that reference family history and traditions.
  7. On The Road: Road-trip essentials—activity books for kids, favorite car snacks, travel guides, atlases, or small items to make long drives more enjoyable.
  8. Out of This World: Space- and sky-themed gifts—astronomy books, star maps, novelty astronaut snacks, or alien- and planet-themed items.
  9. Magic & Mystery: Mystery boxes, international snack samplers, puzzles, or murder-mystery games that invite sleuthing and surprise.
  10. Be A Good Sport: Sports-themed gifts—team memorabilia, equipment for backyard games, or tickets and experiences related to a favorite sport.
  11. Feeling Green: Eco-friendly items or anything green—reusable goods, plant-related gifts, green-colored items, or novelty items that play on the phrase.
  12. Peace & Quiet: Gifts for rest and relaxation—candles, books, sleep masks, spa treats, or clever items that give caregivers a little downtime.
  13. Across State Lines: Local specialties from the giver’s hometown—regional treats, crafts, or items that showcase where someone lives.
  14. Outside The Box: Unusual or experiential gifts—puzzles, immersive games, items that literally come out of a box, or even symbolic “adoptions” of wildlife or charitable gifts.
  15. Book It: Books, reading accessories, or gifts related to travel and getting tickets for events or trips.
  16. What’s That Smell?: Scent-forward gifts—candles, soaps, fragrant foods, or even cheeky gag items with memorable smells.
  17. Small Business Finds: Items or gift cards from independent makers—support a local shop, artisan, or small online business you love.
  18. Trivial Pursuit: Gifts tied to trivia categories—geography, entertainment, history, or any fun fact–driven item that sparks conversation.
  19. G.O.A.T.: “Greatest of all time” picks in any category, playful interpretations of the acronym, or novelty items featuring goats or other humorous motifs.
  20. Safe & Sound: Safety-related gifts or noisy, attention-getting items—pet safety gear, survival guides, safety lights, or novelty candies and snacks that make people laugh.

How We Pick Our Gift Themes

There’s no formal process—someone suggests an idea in person or via email, and the family either votes or casually agrees. These days we often settle on the first good idea because we’ve learned what works: a strong theme leaves room for interpretation. Using a playful title instead of a literal label encourages creativity. For example, “Feeling Green” is broader and more inspiring than “Eco-Friendly.”

When you brainstorm themes, start with a simple category—food, color, travel, music—then give it a clever name to widen the possibilities. A “colorful things” theme could become “Over the Rainbow,” which opens up references to movies, sky-related items, or gold- and luck-themed gifts.

Some additional naming ideas to get you started:

  • Food & drink → “What’s Cookin’ Good Lookin’?”
  • History-related → “Time Travel”
  • Music → “Loud & Clear”
  • Travel → “Pack Your Bags!”
  • Toys & games → “Press Play”

More Holiday Gift Ideas

2025 Young House Love Holiday Gift Guides Banner

If a theme leaves you stumped, it’s easy to bend a great idea into almost any prompt. For more inspiration, check the titles of annual holiday gift guides from recent years (for example: 2025 Holiday Gift Ideas, 2024 Holiday Gift Guides, 2023 Holiday Gift Guides, and earlier editions). Use those lists to find concrete items that fit your chosen theme, or to spark a clever twist that will make your family exchange memorable.