Objectales

Popular

Are Phase 1 Projects Worth the Time and Money?

featured 61515

Q: You’re spending time, effort, and some money on a “temporary” solution for your bathroom. Why not just do the full gut job now? Is staging a Phase 1 update really cost-effective in the long run? — Karen

A: Great question. We get asked this a lot, and it’s worth unpacking. On one hand we love saving money; on the other we want our home to feel comfortable and lived-in. Over the years we’ve found that a phased approach—doing smaller, inexpensive updates now and saving for a full renovation later—often gives the best balance of function, aesthetics, and cost-effectiveness.

When you move into an older home, the impulse is often to “freeze” a problem room until you can afford a complete overhaul. That’s tempting, but a modest Phase 1 refresh can make living in the space much more pleasant while you plan and save for a bigger project. Small investments—paint, a new mirror, improved lighting, or a simple floor update—usually cost little and can be reused or repurposed later. Even better, these trial changes help you learn what you really like and don’t like in the space, which can prevent costly mistakes during a full renovation.

Take our current bathroom makeover as an example, where we planned a Phase 1 budget of roughly $100–$200.

img 61515 1

We couldn’t stand the old carpet in that bathroom any longer, so replacing it and applying a few inexpensive upgrades made far more sense than living with something that made us groan for months or years. A few cans of paint and a new mirror instantly improved the room’s feel—and those pieces can often be repurposed in another space later. (This image was a photoshopped rendering of our plans; we hope to have the floors stenciled shortly.)

img 61515 2

Why not gut immediately? Early on, we learned that living in a space for a while helps you identify real problems you won’t notice right away. In our first house we lived with the original kitchen for a year and realized closing off a door would free up 70% more counter space. Had we renovated immediately, we would have upgraded surfaces but kept the cramped layout. That insight came from living with the room and experimenting with smaller changes first.

img 61515 3

Early on in that house we did a Phase 1 update: painted the cabinets and installed peel-and-stick tile on the floors, along with updating a few appliances that we later reused in the full remodel. The weekend work cost us roughly $150 for supplies, but during that time we had a fresher, more functional-feeling kitchen—perfect for hosting family and friends while we saved for the ultimate renovation.

img 61515 4

When we finally completed the full kitchen renovation, we were glad we hadn’t rushed into it. The planning time allowed us to arrive at a much more functional, beautiful result that aligned with how we actually lived in the space.

img 61515 5

We used the same staged approach in our full bathroom at that first house. Initially, we removed the carpeting, re-caulked, painted, and added lighting and accessories—affordable fixes that made the room livable and enjoyable for years. Up close, however, some tiles were cracked and beyond repair, so when the time came for a gut job we rebuilt the room from the studs for about $1,800—new walls, trim, marble tile floor, tiled tub/shower to the ceiling, a custom vanity, and more. Because we had lived with and refined the space, we knew exactly what we wanted from the major renovation.

img 61515 10

Our multi-phase strategy has served us well for years and will continue to guide updates in our current home. We plan to stay here long-term, so we’d rather pause, experiment, and invest in features we truly love than rush into costly choices we may regret.

Experimenting in a room—physically trying paint colors, window treatments, and layout tweaks—helps you learn what actually works. For example, an early attempt with a painted windowsill and a blue pashmina didn’t suit us, and that discovery helped steer later decisions. Those small course corrections are valuable learning experiences that reduce the risk of expensive errors during a full renovation.

img 61515 12

Sometimes a modest Phase 1 makeover is all you need. We transformed a guest bathroom for about $51—paint, a window treatment, art, and a few small removals—and the space felt brand new. Other times a Phase 1 update helps you pinpoint what still needs a full redo, so you can save and plan more confidently.

img 61515 13

For our hall bathroom we spent about $168 framing a mirror, adding a shelf, and brightening the decor. The tile was in good shape, so we were able to work with what was already there and achieve a fresh, updated look without a gut job.

img 61515 17

Bottom line: Phase 1 updates are a low-risk way to improve comfort and usability while you plan and save for a major renovation. They can save money, teach you what you really want, and sometimes eliminate the need for a full gut job altogether. If a small update gives you the results you want, you’ll be glad you didn’t rush. If it doesn’t, you’ll be better informed when you take on Phase 2.

How do you approach problem rooms? Do you freeze them until you can afford a full renovation, or do you sprinkle in affordable updates as you go? We’d love to hear what works for you—everyone’s path is different, and a thoughtful, phased approach can often be the most rewarding.

ShopOurHouseBannerSHORT