Objectales

Popular

Compare Kitchen Rugs: Styles, Materials, Durability

featured 47533

Kitchen Rug Hunt: How We Tested Rugs to Find the Right One

Our kitchen rugs have been with us for years. They were $34 each from The Company Store way back (maybe 2008) and have lived in both our first house’s kitchen and a spare bedroom. They’re durable and neutral, but in the new kitchen they feel a little too small and their honey-oak tones clash with the soft avocado walls. Replacing them—finding a new kitchen rug or rugs—has been on our to-do list for months.

img 47533 1

We finally tackled the rug issue on a recent stop at HomeGoods. Sherry found several 5 x 7′ flat-weave rugs priced at $49 each. We saw options we liked, so we brought a bunch home for what Sherry called our “kitchen rug fashion show.” Quick note: the rugs in the photos weren’t perfectly arranged or smoothed out—we plopped them down, gauged how they looked in the room, and snapped pictures.

img 47533 2

My first pick was a bold black-and-white stripe. I thought the contrast would ground the space and tie the areas together, but in person the high-contrast stripes demanded too much attention and felt visually aggressive.

img 47533 3

We experimented by using only part of the rug in the cooking area, because we were leaning toward having a single rug on the fireplace side to define the living spot. Even with that adjustment the black-and-white pattern still felt chaotic, and the orientation issues—one rug running lengthwise in the kitchen and width-wise by the fireplace—made the idea of two rugs impractical.

img 47533 4

img 47533 5

Next we tried a softer gray-on-white stripe. I wasn’t ready to abandon stripes entirely, and this one did echo the gray backsplash on the other side of the room. Still, the large stripe pattern remained too high-contrast for the space and came across as a bit cheap in person, so stripes were officially out.

img 47533 6

img 47533 7

Sherry’s favorite pick was an ikat-like diamond pattern featuring several of our preferred colors. The darker tones seemed promising because they wouldn’t fight with the dark floors, and the rug paired nicely with the dining room curtains.

img 47533 8

img 47533 9

In practice the ikat pattern proved too large-scale and distracting. The colors read a bit circus-like in real life—even if photos make it look better—so we ended up passing on that one too, despite finding a matching runner for the laundry room.

img 47533 10

After returning the HomeGoods haul, we dug through our stash of rugs that aren’t currently in use—stored in the playroom—just to see if any would work. We tried a Pottery Barn rug that had been in our office, but it felt too light and the off-white looked dirty next to the room’s white counters and cabinets.

img 47533 11

img 47533 12

We also tried an older Pottery Barn “Clara” rug from our den. We still love the rug itself, but the honey-wheat tones clashed with the avocado walls, much like our original Company Store jute rugs. (The wall color reads subtly green in person; monitor displays can vary.)

img 47533 13

Next we tested our favorite yellow Moorish-pattern rug from the guest room. This one was more promising: the pattern felt sophisticated without being high-contrast, and it didn’t demand attention the way some larger patterns did.

img 47533 14

img 47533 15

Unfortunately the yellow warmed too orange against the walls, which have cool green undertones. Even though we like yellow accents elsewhere in the room, the shade didn’t harmonize with the avocado paint. At this point we started to agree that a light, subtle, smaller-scale pattern in gray would be the most natural choice. Gray wouldn’t compete with the walls, it would tie into the backsplash, and it would help carry color across the fireplace side of the room.

img 47533 17

For now the yellow rug is temporarily in the kitchen, but we know it’s not the long-term answer. The rug we liked best based on our refined criteria is currently on order, so we’re hopeful. Once it arrives we’ll post photos and let you know whether it’s the one that finally ties the space together.

How was your weekend? Any rug shopping or decorating projects? We managed to spend time with family—four kids under three may sound chaotic, but it was lovely to have everyone together.