Conceal Damaged Tile with Trim for a Seamless Finish
Sometimes I get impulsive and start demo projects without a clear plan for what comes next. One afternoon I found myself staring at the bathroom towel racks in the hallway for the five-hundredth time, and the more I looked, the more ridiculous that off-center towel bar under the window seemed. Who needs so many towel bars anyway? And who thought it was a good idea to place one so low and so far left that it poked into the shower curtain’s space? There was room for a neat little hand towel ring by the sink that would have made more sense.

I decided to deal with that annoying half-under-the-window towel bar first. I picked up a flat-head screwdriver and a hammer and carefully chipped away at the mounting. Tap, tap—

—and then came the moment I dreaded. The holders popped off easily, but they weren’t surface-mounted as I’d hoped. They were inset into the tile, so I ended up with two visible holes where the hardware had been. Ugh.

I briefly panicked and pictured the worst—ruining original mid-century tile that we’d planned to work with. After a few deep breaths (and a weird nausea trick I learned during pregnancy), I started thinking through fixes. One option was to Dremel out the damaged tiles and replace them, but that would take time and finding matching vintage tile can be difficult. Then I noticed something else about the window trim: there was trim along the sides and top but not across the bottom.

Adding a short piece of white wood trim along the bottom of the window would balance the look and cover one of the two tile holes. For the other hole, we planned to hang a long, ceiling-mounted shower curtain—one of our favorite extra-long 95-inch curtains—that would drape across that spot whether it was open or closed. It’s not a permanent tile repair, but it’s a perfectly fine interim solution until we find a matching replacement.
I shuffled down the hall, doing my best “I had a moment” face and asked John for help. He didn’t scold me. Instead he got to work fixing it while I held the baby and offered up some strategically flattering commentary to keep morale high. John started by removing the little faux trim (the trim that looks like shoe molding) under the sill by prying it loose with a flat-head screwdriver.

He then cut a scrap piece of trim to match the other windows in the house. The shape was simple—straight down the sides with small 45-degree cuts at the bottom corners. He used a miter box for the angled cuts and attached the new bottom trim with small finish nails driven at an angle toward the sill. To sink the nails neatly without damaging the trim, he used a metal nail punch so the hammer wouldn’t leave dents.

About twenty minutes and zero dollars later, the evidence of my impulsive demo job was gone. I even painted the new trim with leftover trim paint we had tucked away in the basement, and it blended in well with the existing window frame. The end result felt balanced and finished—the bottom trim looks like it was always meant to be there.


Also worth noting: John remembered to set the white balance on the camera for one of the shots, so the bright whites in the bathroom look accurate. Sometimes I get so caught up in demo energy that I forget basic photo settings, so I appreciated the more faithful color in his picture.

In retrospect, the little tile incident wasn’t all bad. The bottom window trim actually improves the look, so that change is staying. Hiding the other hole with a ceiling-mounted shower curtain is a practical short-term fix until we source a matching tile to replace the damaged pieces. Most importantly, the offending off-center towel bar is gone—no more awkward towels brushing the toilet paper holder when I walk by in the hall.
I’ll take this as a win for spontaneous DIY—learn fast, fix smarter, and let small mistakes lead to better design choices. Hooray for controlled chaos.
Psst—if you’re curious about the little silver nozzle next to the toilet tank, we’ve written about a simple toilet upgrade in another post.
Pssst—Clara’s first birthday is coming up in less than two months, and we’re starting to plan a small DIY celebration. We’re sharing some early ideas and picking up tips on parenting sites, so we’ll report back once we firm up the plan.








