Convert a Balcony into a Deck: Demolition and Build Guide
Removing an Old Rotting Balcony to Make Way for a New Deck
Deck plans completed? Check. Permit acquired? Check. Materials scheduled to arrive this week? Check. There was just one thing standing between us and the start of the project: an old rotting balcony that needed to come down.

I started out methodically: laid out tools (crowbar, sledgehammer, power drill), set up a ladder to reach the railing easily, put on some music, and had Sherry inside watching Clara but ready to help or take photos. The plan was to carefully pry off boards and study how the old balcony had been built so I could avoid repeating mistakes when we build the new deck.
That careful approach didn’t last long. Instead of a slow, controlled teardown, my demo technique quickly turned into repetitive pulling and pushing on the railing until the whole outer edge began to twist away from the two ledger boards attached to the house. Because those ledger boards were scheduled for removal anyway, the railing rubbing against them wasn’t a concern.

Before long the entire assembly flipped over and detached from the house. The photo below shows the underside of the balcony floor—the top of the railing had rolled over to the ground.

Once the main structure was out of the way—which took about 15 minutes and no special tools—my focus shifted to removing the boards that attached the balcony to the house. One ledger board was bolted into the brick on one side…

…while the other appeared to be simply nailed to the siding. From what I’ve learned, nailing a ledger to siding is not best practice. Ideally you remove the siding in the ledger area and fasten the ledger directly to the home’s rim board. If those terms sound unfamiliar, there are helpful diagrams that clarify deck components and how they connect.

Another thing I’ll do differently when building the new deck is install metal flashing between the ledger board and the house to prevent water intrusion and rot. The previous installation had no flashing, and as a result both the ledger and a strip of the siding were rotted. I cleared away the damaged siding and exposed the rim board of the house so we can attach the new ledger properly and install flashing.

Fortunately, the new deck will be positioned where a lower strip of good siding currently exists, which will be removed during construction. That means we can reuse that sound siding to patch the small rotten section above the missing strip. Reusing material that must come out anyway is a small win—and adding metal flashing will help prevent future rot.
Here’s a progress shot we shared earlier in the week.

The joist closest to the house was simply sitting in a metal hanger, so a few taps with a rubber mallet popped it loose. The other joist came down with the railing. No dramatic sledgehammer theatrics required for that part.
To free the ledger that was bolted into the brick I used a wrench to loosen the hex nuts. The old installer hadn’t used flashing, and the ledger board showed its age. Once the ledger came off, the anchor bolts remained embedded in the brick. I left them in place for now—if they can’t be reused I’ll remove them when the new materials arrive and use their locations as a reference for installing the new hardware properly.


With the balcony removed, the backyard now features a “sliding door to nowhere”—a temporary oddity until the new deck goes in. Materials should arrive within a few days, and my dad, who built the deck on the house where I grew up, will be coming by later in the week to help get construction started. I hope he doesn’t mind that we demoed without him!

We’ll tackle the deck in stages over the next few weeks and share each step along the way with photos and details. Our goal is to avoid the mistakes from the previous installation—proper ledger attachment, flashing to prevent rot, and careful fastening—so this new deck will be safe, durable, and built to last. Have you demolished anything recently or discovered unexpected rot or construction shortcuts in an old structure? We’d love to hear demolition stories and lessons learned.








