DIY Marble Fireplace Makeover for $200: Before and After
Fireplace Makeover Complete: DIY Marble Herringbone Tile and Built-Out Mantel
We can officially call this one finished. After laying marble herringbone tile and building a custom surround, the fireplace makeover is complete — and it transformed the whole room.

To recap briefly: we planned the refacing, installed marble subway-style tiles in a herringbone pattern, and then built out a tailored wood surround to frame everything. A quick reminder: fireplace code and clearances vary by location and by whether a fireplace is wood-burning or has a gas insert, so always check local requirements before beginning a project like this.

Our fireplace is currently non-working (we’re considering a future gas insert or even a double-sided option), so this phase of the project only required primer and paint after the tile and framing were finished.

The painting process was straightforward: we primed using supplies we already had, then applied Benjamin Moore Cloud Cover across the surround to match nearby cabinetry. We refreshed the firebox with its original color, Benjamin Moore Temptation. Important note: if your fireplace is functional, use a high-heat paint designed for fireplaces.
After giving the paint a couple of days to cure, we rehung artwork and accessories and called the project done. The result is a more substantial, intentional focal point — the herringbone marble tile plus the built-out surround gives the hearth a custom, elevated look.

Update: Several readers asked whether we considered widening the tiled hearth to match the full width of the built-out surround. We did, but the visible gap is covered by a thin strip of shoe molding that runs around our cabinets, so it didn’t justify ripping up the cork floor. If it bothers us later, we may paint the brown floor trim white to visually widen the hearth.
Before and after shots highlight the impact:

And here’s what the fireplace looked like when we first bought the house back in 2010 — a helpful reminder of how much a fireplace update can change a space:

Because we used many supplies we already owned, the only new costs were the tile and the framing materials. We’ve previously shared the tiling and build-out budgets, but here’s the consolidated breakdown for clarity:
- Cement board (2 sheets): $16
- Masonry screws: already owned
- Liquid Nails Heavy Duty: $2
- Subway tile (herringbone marble): $5.50/sq ft, totaling $70
- Thinset: already owned
- Tiling tools (saw, trowel, float, etc): already owned
- Grout: $11
- Tile sealer: already owned
- MDF frame: $35
- Mantel top: $17
- Crown, baseboard, & decorative trim: $22.75
- 1 x 2″ boxes: $24
- TOTAL: $197.75 (after gift cards from family we spent $147.75; without owned supplies this could be closer to $250)

The updated surround reads much more expensive than the actual outlay. The marble herringbone tile combined with the custom-built trim creates texture and depth that photos struggle to fully capture, especially with light-colored tile and surround blending together.

To hide the exposed cement board edge around the firebox, we glued a small rounded trim piece from our scrap pile in place before grouting, then painted it to match the surround. For a working wood-burning fireplace you would want to use a fire-safe tile edge or metal trim designed for high heat.

We love the new look and how it balances with the penny-tile feature wall on the other side of the kitchen. The herringbone marble fireplace now stands toe-to-toe with that wall in terms of style and visual weight, which makes the whole room feel more cohesive and thoughtfully designed.

That’s the update — a practical, stylish DIY that redesigned the focal point of our kitchen without breaking the bank. Next up: porch and carport projects as soon as the weather warms. Are you working on any tiling, trim work, or painting projects right now? If you want the full step-by-step from the start, you can read our planning, tiling, and build-out posts linked throughout this article.








