Objectales

Popular

DIY or Hire? How to Decide What to Outsource

img 51295 1

We often get asked, “Should we DIY or hire a pro?” so we wanted to walk through our decision-making process using our new French doors as an example. These doors lead out to the deck and replacing the old sliding doors ended up being the perfect project to explain how we weigh time, cost, and sanity.

img 51295 1

Tomorrow we’ll share more before-and-after photos and details on why we chose French doors, how the screens work now, and how they look both open and closed once we paint them (most exterior doors come primed but unpainted). For now, here’s the backstory: our home inspection warned us that the old sliding doors to the balcony—later turned into a deck—needed full replacement.

img 51295 2

The sliders were jammed, the screen didn’t work, and there wasn’t even a proper lock. We had been using a floor bar and an alarm sensor mounted on the door just to feel secure.

img 51295 3

They were also seriously rotten and well beyond salvageable—gross and unsafe.

img 51295 4

When we made an offer on the house, we factored in the cost of replacement doors—estimating $1,000–$2,000 in case there was hidden rot or a non-standard opening. Now that the deck is finished and furnished, it felt like the right moment to replace the faulty sliders, especially since we use that exit frequently.

img 51295 5

With a lot going on—book promotion, planning talks, travel, and juggling family life—we had to decide whether to spend time and energy on this ourselves or hire a professional. Our first step was to hunt for a used French door at salvage yards and thrift stores, hoping to match the clean, single-pane look we have on the laundry room door (we like the big glass and simple lines).

img 51295 6

We couldn’t find a secondhand match in the exact size and style, so we requested quotes from several vendors. The total bids (door plus install) we received were:

  1. $1,200 from a national window and door chain
  2. $3,200 from a local specialist (a higher-end option)
  3. $730 from a big-box retailer
  4. $830 from another big-box retailer (but they didn’t carry the exact style we wanted)

The products were similar in quality—many offered low-e glass, comparable hardware, and similar manufacturing standards—so price and convenience became key factors. We then checked which vendors allowed DIY installation without voiding the warranty:

  1. This vendor required professional installation to keep the warranty valid.
  2. This vendor also required pro installation for warranty coverage.
  3. This option would cost about $350 for the door alone, saving roughly $380 versus paying for installation.
  4. This option would cost about $450 without installation, saving a similar amount but lacking the exact door style we wanted.

After weighing cost, convenience, and product match, the big-box retailer with the $730 install price became the best fit. The door matched our existing laundry room door (same manufacturer and style), and the total was well under our original estimate.

At that point the choice came down to saving roughly $380 by installing it ourselves versus using our allotted budget to have it installed while we focused on other projects. Given our packed schedule and the many ongoing renovations, DIY would have meant stretching the install over several evenings, leaving the house less secure for a few days. We decided to hire the installation team to get it done promptly and correctly.

img 51295 7

Although we typically DIY most of our renovations—decks, kitchens, bathrooms, built-ins—there are times when hiring a pro makes more sense. For us, those situations usually involve one or more of these factors:

  • The expense was already budgeted or saved for.
  • We had no interest in tackling the job ourselves (rare, but it happens).
  • Life and other projects made it impractical to do the work at that time.

Honestly, the middle point often decides it for us: if we’re excited about a project, we’ll DIY it. If not, and the money is earmarked, we’ll hire someone. For example, we happily hired pros to re-roof our first house after hearing many cautionary tales from friends.

Our installer initially guessed the job would take two hours, but unforeseen complications extended the work to five hours with an extra trip to the hardware store. We were grateful for a flat installation fee—if we had tried to manage that on our own, it could have easily taken much longer and been far more frustrating.

img 51295 8

We’re relieved it wasn’t us wrestling with unexpected issues. The installer—who hangs many doors a week—still hit delays, so it was wise to let a pro handle it.

img 51295 9

Ultimately, the new French doors are absolutely worth it. They improve safety, function, and the look of our home, and we’re thrilled with the result.

img 51295 10

Update: A few readers asked how the ordering process worked with the big-box retailer. You give them a rough measurement, go to the store to review options, and pay a nominal fee (credited toward installation) for an official in-home measurement. A few days after that appointment they scheduled the installation—simple and straightforward.

What about you? What percentage of home projects do you DIY, and are there tasks you’ll never tackle yourself? We know skilled contractors who still outsource certain jobs because everyone has different strengths and preferences when it comes to home renovation.