First Home vs Current Home: What Changed in One Year
Q: I recently found an old post where you compared your first house to your current one, and it seemed like you preferred the first in some ways since you had completed more renovations there. Now that you’ve had more time in the new house and made updates, would you revisit that comparison? — Sarah
A: Great idea — it’s the perfect time to revisit this comparison of our first house versus our current house. We originally did a fun side-by-side over a year ago after someone suggested it, and since then we’ve lived in the new house for longer and made more progress. Comparing the two is a little unfair — we spent over four years finishing our first home and we’ve only been in this one for 20 months — but after years of trial and error we’re more confident about design choices, so some decisions come faster now. Below is an updated room-by-room look, with images for reference and a winner declared for each space.
The Front Yard, First House:

The Front Yard, Current House:

Winner: The first house. Our current yard has come a long way from the overgrown lot we inherited, but we still love the mature, finished landscaping we created at our first house. The first property had years of careful planting and shaping invested in it, so it remains ahead for now.
The Front Porch, First House:

The Front Porch, Current House:

Winner: Tie. We loved the painted stripes and hanging ferns of the first porch and the cheerful color of the current door. Both have charm; the current porch needs a few more finishing touches (column trim, staining) so for now they’re even.
The Living Room, First House:

The Living Room, Current House:

Winner: Current house. The living room in our new house functions as a true family space. Even though we still plan upgrades like a new media stand, the layout feels comfortable and used every day, which matters more than a formal unused room.
The Kitchen, First House:

The Kitchen, Current House:

Winner: Current house. The newer kitchen’s open plan and larger scale make it the heart of the home. With multiple openings to adjacent rooms, it feels connected to family life and is comfortable for cooking, playing, and working.
The Hallway, First House:

The Hallway, Current House:

Winner: Current house. The wide, light-filled hallway with a gallery of family frames feels welcoming and intentional — a great circulation space that showcases photos and personality.
The Spare Bedroom, First House:

The Spare Bedroom, Second House:

Winner: The first house. The tidy spare room with simple furnishings felt calmer. Our current spare room has taken on multiple functions and is more cluttered for now, so the neatness of the first one wins.
The Nursery (Formerly The Third Bedroom), First House:


The Nursery, Current House:



Winner: Current house (narrow call). The original nursery was deeply sentimental — it’s where we brought Clara home. Still, the current nursery’s larger closet that functions as a reading nook gives it the edge. We plan further refinements like crown molding and ceiling paint.
Our Bedroom, First House:


Our Bedroom, Current House:


Winner: Current house. Our new bedroom is the coziest we’ve had — dark, moody paint and a fresh layout make it restful. Built-ins from the first house will always be beloved, but the current layout and the convenience of a walk-in closet and attached bathroom win on comfort and function.
The Main Bathroom (hall), First House:

Our Bathroom (attached), Current House:

Winner: First house. The full renovation we did on the first house’s main bathroom was a big source of pride — the design details felt polished and complete. The current ensuite works well, but it hasn’t reached that same finished feeling yet.
The Office/Guest Bedroom/Playroom, First House:


The Office & Guest Bedroom (now separate rooms), Current House:


Winner: Current house. Separating the office and guest bedroom has made both spaces far more functional. The dedicated office with built-in desk lets us work without interruptions, and guests have a cheerful, private room with its own bath.
The Den, First House:

Winner: The first house. We miss the cozy den from our first home — a space that felt intimate and perfect for cuddling and quiet moments. Our current home prioritizes a larger open living area, which is great, but that small den holds a lot of sentimental value.
Dining Room, Current House:

Winner: Current house. We adore the built-ins, the dark teal paint, and the window treatments. Also, our first house didn’t have a true dining room, so the current room is a big upgrade for hosting and everyday meals.
The Laundry Area, First House:

Laundry Area, Current House:

Winner: Current house. The new laundry space feels brighter and happier even though it’s narrow. It avoids the clutter-prone layout we had before and feels more pleasant for routine chores.
The Hall Bathroom, First House:

Hall Bathroom, Current House:

Winner: The first house. The patterned stripes, chandelier, and pedestal sink made that hall bathroom memorable. The current hall bath is more functional (with a tub for Clara’s baths), but the charm of the first wins until we give the new one the same attention.
The Sunroom, First House:

The Sunroom, Current House:

Winner: First house. The sunroom at our first home had a character and finish we loved. Our current sunroom has potential and plenty on the to-do list, so it might catch up in time.
The Patio, First House:

The Patio, Current House:

Winner: Current house. The patio is larger, shaded, and more comfortable. We built much of it ourselves, and that sense of ownership makes it especially satisfying.
The Deck, Current House:

Winner: Current house. We didn’t have a deck in our first home, and this new one was built by John and furnished by us. It’s a great outdoor extension of the living space and we’re excited to continue improving it.
The Basement, First House:

The Basement, Current House:

Winner: First house. We invested far more time finishing the basement in our first home, so it’s the more polished, functional space at the moment. The current basement has potential once we tackle the clutter and finish projects.
The Backyard, First House:

The Backyard, Current House:

Winner: First house. We miss the flat grassy area surrounded by woods at our first property. With time and landscaping, we hope to create a similarly inviting lawn space at our current home.
Final tally: the current house edges ahead by a narrow margin. This round’s score is roughly 10–8 in favor of the current house (last time it was closer). It’s been fun to see how our style has evolved — we’re taking more risks with color and contrast while still appreciating the softer, tone-on-tone aesthetic we loved before. A lot remains on the project list at the current house, so these outcomes could shift as we complete renovations and add finishing touches.
P.S. For a room-by-room source list and paint colors from our first and second homes, check the separate source lists we shared previously.








