Objectales

Popular

First House vs Current Home: A Before-and-After Comparison

featured 39758

Last Friday, on this post a reader suggested a fun idea: “I love your videos and it’s crazy to see the difference in YHL style from the first house to this house! If you wanted to do a side-by-side of rooms past and present, I wouldn’t hate it :)” – Sarah

We liked the idea, too. So here it is: a room-by-room face-off — first house versus current house. Fair warning: the comparison is a little uneven. We lived four and a half years in the first house and completed many projects there; we’ve only been in the current house for eight months and many rooms are still works in progress. Think finished versus in-progress and cut the newer house some slack. Many of the current-house photos came from our House Tour page, so you’ll notice a “progress” label on some images. Ready? Let’s go.

The Front Yard, First House:

img 39758 1

The Front Yard, Current House:

img 39758 2

Winner: The first house. This was straightforward — we invested years turning the front yard into something we loved. The current yard still needs a lot of work from other angles, so for curb appeal the first house wins for now.

The Front Porch, First House:

img 39758 3

The Front Porch, Current House:

img 39758 4

Winner: The first house. We loved the hanging ferns and the tan-and-cream striped porch floor. The second house has a front door we adore (yellow has our heart), but the porch still needs updates like boxed columns, a stained floor, and a few finishing touches.

The Living Room, First House:

img 39758 5

The Living Room, Current House:

img 39758 6

Winner: Our current house. Even unfinished, the new living room is where we actually live — we relax on the huge sofa, play on the rug with the kiddo, and sometimes eat by the big window. The first house’s formal living room was rarely used, so the current space feels more practical and comfortable for daily life.

The Kitchen, First House:

img 39758 7

The Kitchen, Current House:

img 39758 8

img 39758 9

Winner: Tie. The first kitchen charmed us with its granite counters and bright white cabinets but was small. The current kitchen offers more space, a fireplace, and room for an eat-in area — and it has real potential once we open it up, update appliances, and finish planned improvements. So the older kitchen wins for style, the new one for space and promise.

The Hallway, First House:

img 39758 10

The Hallway, Current House:

img 39758 11

Winner: Current house. The wide, light-filled hallway and the family gallery of frames make this space warm and welcoming — a real improvement.

The Spare Bedroom, First House:

img 39758 12

The Spare Bedroom, Second House:

img 39758 13

Winner: The first house. The tidy spare room with a daybed and desk felt calmer; the current spare room still flirts with playroom chaos until we finish organizing it.

The Nursery (Formerly The Third Bedroom), First House:

img 39758 14

img 39758 15

The Nursery, Current House:

img 39758 16

img 39758 17

img 39758 18

Winner: Current house. But it was close. We adored the nursery we brought Clara home to — it was sentimental and special — but the new room’s larger closet, now a cozy reading nook, gives the current nursery the edge.

The Master Bedroom, First House:

img 39758 19

img 39758 20

The Master Bedroom, Current House:

img 39758 21

img 39758 22

img 39758 23

Winner: Current house. Even at about 20% done, the master bedroom already feels special: a big chandelier, mirror placement that excites us, a walk-in closet, and an attached bathroom. We’ll always cherish the built-ins we created in the first house, but the new layout is a clear upgrade.

The Master Bathroom (located in the hall), First House:

img 39758 24

The Master Bathroom (actually attached to our bedroom this time), Current House:

img 39758 25

Winner: First house. The bathroom renovation in our first home was a full gut job we loved. The new master bath is untouched so far (hello bisque toilet), and while we expect to favor it once it’s finished, the first bathroom still wins on craftsmanship and charm.

The Office/Guest Bedroom/Playroom, First House:

img 39758 26

img 39758 27

The Office & Guest Bedroom (which are now separate rooms), Current House:

img 39758 28

img 39758 29

Winner: Current house. The first house’s multifunctional space was creative and useful but small. The current home gives us a separate office and a cheerful guest room with its own bath, which is more practical for both work and hosting, even if the office still needs cosmetic work.

The Den, First House:

img 39758 30

Winner: The first house. We miss that cozy den. The current house doesn’t have a separate den, and our first den remains one of our favorite rooms for relaxing and rug hunting memories.

Dining Room, Current House:

img 39758 31

Winner: Current house. We adore the curtains and the dark teal paint behind the built-ins. Plus, the first house didn’t have a formal dining room anymore after we repurposed it, so the new dining space is a clear win for family gatherings.

The Laundry Area, First House:

img 39758 32

Laundry Area, Current House:

img 39758 33

Winner: The current house. The new laundry space feels brighter and happier. It’s narrower and lacks a folding surface, but we don’t accidentally use it as a clutter zone the way we once did, and folding laundry on the sofa while watching TV has become oddly enjoyable.

The Hall Bathroom, First House:

img 39758 34

Hall Bathroom, Current House:

img 39758 35

Winner: First house (with a caveat). The stripes, glass chandelier, pedestal sink, and pocket door gave the first bathroom a lot of charm. The new hall bath wins for function because it has a tub Clara uses, but in terms of original character the first bathroom still tugs at our heartstrings.

The Sunroom, First House:

img 39758 36

The Sunroom, Current House:

img 39758 37

Winner: First house, hands down. The sunroom at the first house felt finished and inviting. The current one has potential, and we have a long list of improvements, but for now the original sunroom still leads.

The Patio, First House:

img 39758 38

The Patio, Current House:

img 39758 39

Winner: Current house. The patio at our new place is roomier, cozier, and shaded. We’re proud we built much of it ourselves, too — a rewarding DIY win.

The Basement, First House:

img 39758 40

The Basement, Current House:

img 39758 41

Winner: First house. We spent more time finishing the first basement, so it’s more complete. The current basement has potential and will likely evolve as we tackle it.

The Backyard, First House:

img 39758 42

The Backyard, Current House:

img 39758 43

Winner: First house. We miss the flat grassy area surrounded by woods, but we’re optimistic about shaping the current yard into something equally lovely over time.

So that’s the roundup: by our count it ended up about 9 to 8 in favor of the first house — but that could change as we complete more projects here. This comparison was a fun way to see how our style has evolved: we bring elements from our old house into the new one, but we also find fresh directions and solutions based on different layouts and needs. Have you ever compared photos of a current home with a previous one? It’s interesting to notice what you keep, what you change, and how your taste grows with each space.

Psst — You can find a full source list for almost every item and paint color in our first house here. We’re still compiling one for the current house.