You might think I’m being dramatic. Me? Dramatic? Yes. But this time, I’m not exaggerating. Our freshly refinished heart pine floors have completely changed how finished the house feels. It’s one of those updates that makes everything look intentional and cared for. We dropped by this past Saturday to check them out and honestly, we were doing a lot of happy pacing (while wearing socks so we wouldn’t scuff the newly sealed surface).
To remind you how far this room came, here’s a photo from just after the drywall went up a few months ago:
And here’s the same room from when we bought the house last October—yeah, in the words of Pepe Le Pew: “Le Yikes.” It was a true before-and-after moment, and seeing the floors now makes the transformation feel huge.
We were so excited we shot an updated tour while we were there. The video shares a lot of details—our reasoning for the gray trim downstairs, what’s next on the to-do list, and one silly mistake we made in the bathroom—so if you want all the context, check out the tour. If you’re reading in a feed reader, you may need to click through to see the video on the main post.
Besides refinishing the pine already in the house, there were plenty of repairs and missing sections that needed to be pieced in so everything would look cohesive. We handed this job to professionals who could match and patch the old floor so the new work reads like it’s always been part of the house. They even sourced reclaimed pine from another old home and used it for some of the patches, which helped everything blend together.
One thing we learned after sanding: pine behaves differently than oak. Even after sanding down pine, some discolorations from sun exposure or old rugs can remain because the changes penetrate deeper into the grain. Oak often sands out clean, but pine holds those marks. It surprised us initially, but we’re embracing the imperfections—they’re part of a 100-year-old floor’s character. And once furniture, rugs, and cabinets are in place, those variations will become much less noticeable.
People have asked about stain color, but we didn’t use any stain. We chose a satin water-based clear coat after patching and sanding—five coats, actually—so the finish will be durable. The clear coat lets the natural color of the pine show through and keeps the look authentic. We chose water-based for its improved formulas: it’s less odorous than oil-based alternatives and still very durable and beautiful. Satin offers a gentle sheen that’s reflective without being overly glossy, which we prefer for floors.
We also rescued the original upstairs doors. They’re heart pine like the floors but had been darkened and dulled by an old stain-and-wax finish that felt heavy and sticky. After debating several paint colors, we opted to have them professionally stripped and sealed to restore their original look. The result is stunning—the doors now sit beautifully alongside the newly redone floors.
Back to the floors—there are so many views that really hit me. The upstairs landing in particular looks incredible; it’s astonishing how much the simple act of refinishing the floors changes the whole feel of a space.
When we first bought the house, the ceiling was falling apart and the floors were painted dark maroon upstairs, so we never even saw the original wood. Bringing it back has been incredibly satisfying.
One of my new favorite angles is the upstairs hallway we added. Previously, two rooms were laid out in a railroad configuration with no central hall or second bathroom. Creating that hallway was a major functional upgrade, and the refinished floors make it look polished and intentional.
Other rooms have their own quirks—there are still a few faint marks where rugs or beds once sat, but those will be hidden once furniture and rugs are in place. We’ve also been sharing light fixture selections; the fixtures and clear soft-white LED bulbs we picked will complement the warm natural tones of the pine.
Some features, like the pocket doors in the back bedroom, were charming but not functional in their original state. We tried sealing them clear to keep their aged look, but they flaked when used, so we stripped, primed, and painted them in the same shade we used on the tub for a cohesive pop of color.
Overall, refinishing these floors has been one of the most dramatic and rewarding updates in this beach house renovation. It’s brought warmth, cohesion, and authenticity back to the spaces. We’re getting so close to moving furniture in and finishing the kitchen, and we’ll share those updates as they happen. The takeaway: refinishing floors can truly transform a home—and sometimes a little drama is well deserved.
More Hardwood Floor Refinishing Projects
If you’d like to read more about specific hardwood-floor refinishing projects, here are a few posts covering different challenges and solutions, including matching original hardwoods to new flooring and restoring century-old pine:
- Refinishing Mid-Century Oak Floors in our first house
- Matching New & Old Hardwood Floors in our third house
- Repairing Historic Oak & Pine Floors in our duplex
- Clear Sealing Our Refinished Floors in our Florida house
*This post contains affiliate links*