Help Meghan Decide: Share Ideas and Suggestions
You all amazed me again. I was blown away by the 500+ creative ideas—and some impressive Photoshop edits—that you contributed for Jamie’s design challenge last week. Group brainstorming is unbeatable, and Jamie is thrilled with the many directions she can explore. Now let’s turn to Meghan’s master bathroom dilemma and explore practical, budget-friendly ways to soften and style that oversized tub.
Meet my giant Scar Face bathtub. My husband and I bought our 1987 home a little over a year ago and have been steadily renovating, but this spot still stumps me: the master bathroom. I walk in, I scratch my head, and I walk back out more confused than before. Any ideas to make the tub area more attractive and functional? We can’t afford to rip the tub out right now, so I need solutions that work with what’s there. — Meghan

I spent some time imagining options and testing a few concepts in Photoshop. My first idea was to frame the tub with built-in shelving to create balance, introduce storage, and draw attention to the pretty stained-glass window behind it. Adding white bookcases on either side gives the whole area height and symmetry, and beefing up the window trim helps everything feel intentional and proportionate.

For color, consider painting the bookcase backs a soft blue-gray to echo the stained glass and the walls a warm sand tone to tie in with the tub and flooring. On the shelves, prioritize attractive, bathroom-friendly storage and styling that also serves a purpose:
- Fluffy extra towels, rolled or folded.
- Textured baskets to hide toiletries and reduce visual clutter.
- Clear glass jars filled with sea sponges, loofahs, or decorative items like sea glass.
- Pretty bottles of bubble bath, bath salts, or bath oils.
- A small stack of magazines or a waterproof reading option for bathtub downtime.
- Candles (real or battery-operated) for a spa-like atmosphere.
- Beachy keepsakes like jars of sand, shells, or labeled vacation mementos.
To break up the heavy tan tone of the tub surround and steps, cover the front of the tub and the risers with a clean white finish. Three good options that are budget-friendly and bathroom-appropriate are:
- White subway tile for a classic, clean look.
- White beadboard made for damp environments, which adds cottage charm.
- White horizontal planks or bathroom-grade shiplap to add texture and a fresh farmhouse vibe.
These materials can be applied as thin panels or tiles under the step lip using bathroom-rated adhesive or, for tile, a proper thinset and grout. Choose white or a low-contrast grout so the ribs and texture of the tub don’t visually compete with the new surface.
For a moodier option, try darker, richer tones behind the shelving—something like a deep green on the bookcase backs with a soft blue on the walls and a muted putty color on the tub surround. Using the stained-glass window as your palette source can make the whole arrangement feel cohesive and intentional.

If replacing the tub isn’t an option, look into tub reglazing (also called refinishing). A local reglazing pro can tell you whether the tub’s material will accept a new finish and what colors are feasible—reglazing is often a far cheaper alternative to replacement. Even if reglazing isn’t possible, swapping out the tub’s faucets and hardware for updated finishes like brushed nickel, chrome, or oil-rubbed bronze makes a noticeable difference.
Another strong approach is to build the entire nook into a unified built-in, with shelving across the back wall as well as flanking units. This creates a tailored, custom look, and you can design shelf depths so towels and bulk items sit on side shelves while narrower back shelves hold candles, soaps, and decorative accents.

If you’re worried about steam and condensation, consider glass-front cabinet doors for an elevated look and extra protection for items on the shelves. Other small touches that can enhance the space:
- Paint the window trim a deep charcoal to make the stained glass pop and create a focal point.
- Consider a subtle glass mosaic or small tile behind the window for added texture and light-catching detail.
- Keep accessories in a restrained neutral palette to avoid a cluttered appearance; consistency in texture and color will read as intentional and calming.
Those are several practical directions Meghan could take to soften, style, and add storage to her master bathroom without replacing the tub. I can’t wait to see what she chooses—and to hear the community’s ideas.
Have a tricky spot in your home? Send at least three photos of the space, a quick floor plan sketch, and a short description of the issue to [email protected] for consideration.








