Lately we’ve received a ton of questions about our rugs: where we find them, which materials and designs we prefer, how to clean and care for them, and what price ranges we aim for. The truth is rugs are complicated, and they can be expensive. They’re one of those things that’s easy to get wrong, which makes people hesitant to try again. If you’ve ever felt discouraged after a rug purchase didn’t pan out, you’re not alone.
We’ve made most of the rug-buying mistakes possible over the last ten years of homeownership—too small, too cheap, too trendy, wrong materials, and so on—so we want to share what we’ve learned. Think of this as friendly guidance from people who’ve been on the Rugs-R-Hard Express and lived to tell the tale.
Choosing a Rug Size
We like big rugs. Generally speaking, the bigger the better. You don’t want a rug that literally touches the baseboards, but a generously sized rug can make a room feel more expansive and cohesive, while a rug that’s too small can make a space feel choppy. In most rooms you can almost go wall-to-wall—just leave a foot or two of border. Large rugs help a room feel polished and complete.
In open-concept or very large rooms, a wall-to-wall rug may be impractical, so use a rug to connect furniture and define functional zones. For example, a 9 x 12 rug in a living area can anchor the sofa, chairs, and tables so the seating feels intentional rather than floating. In open plans, area rugs are crucial for visually delineating spaces.
Choosing a Rug Design
We’ve used solid-colored rugs, but over time we’ve learned that patterned rugs usually work best for our lifestyle. Pattern adds visual interest and does a great job hiding wear—crumbs, pet hair, and everyday messes are less noticeable on patterned surfaces.
We’ve invested in several large traditional Persian and Turkish rugs for high-traffic areas like the living room, bonus room, and dining room. Their intricate patterns and rich colors are forgiving and versatile; they can layer into many spaces without feeling overbearing. Though highly patterned rugs might seem demanding, in practice they almost act as a neutral because they pair well with many different furnishings. Just avoid placing them next to heavily patterned sofas or curtains to prevent visual competition.
We also like smaller-scale geometric patterns. Tight, high-contrast repeats disguise crumbs and spills better than large-scale motifs. In kitchens, for instance, a durable sisal runner with a dense diamond pattern has outperformed light, subtly patterned cheap rugs that quickly looked dingy. Material and quality matter, too—more on that below.
When choosing patterns, we usually gravitate toward all-over repeating designs in small to medium scale. Big central medallions or large asymmetrical graphics can be harder to arrange furniture around and may date faster. Collecting photos of rugs you like—either from stores or online—and reviewing them together on your phone or a mood board helps reveal consistent preferences and makes choosing easier.
Choosing a Rug Material
We prefer 100% natural materials: thick wool rugs for plushness, cotton flatweaves (paired with a rug pad), and natural fibers like sisal for runners. We try to avoid mixed-fiber rugs composed of several synthetics because in our experience they don’t hold up as well. Mixed fibers can be a sign of lower quality materials—olefin, acrylic, and polypropylene often feel less pleasant underfoot and can fade or unravel over time. Those options are fine for budget or outdoor rugs, but for indoor living areas we lean toward natural fibers.
Natural materials offer two main advantages: feel and durability. Wool is plush, cotton can be soft and sometimes machine-washable, and the right jute or sisal can be surprisingly comfortable. Natural fibers also tend to be easier to clean and longer lasting—our antique wool rugs have held up for decades. We’ve successfully removed stains from wool, cotton, and jute rugs, which gives us confidence placing higher-quality rugs even in food-prone rooms like the dining area.
Rug Cleaning & Care
We care for cotton and wool similarly: regular vacuuming, spot cleaning with water, and occasional use of a mild soap such as Dr. Bronner’s or a gentle dish soap for tougher spots. Dabbing rather than rubbing lifts stains more effectively. For natural fiber runners like sisal, shaking outside, hosing off, and sun-drying can work well. Small tools like stain-lifting pens can also be surprisingly effective on ink or marker incidents.
Where We Shop for Rugs
There are endless rug sources: local shops, online retailers, big-box stores, boutiques, and marketplaces. We try not to buy everything from a single retailer to avoid a catalog-like, one-note look in our home. Our favorite finds often come from a local rug shop where you can see many styles and sizes in person and sometimes negotiate a price. Many specialty shops allow you to take a rug home overnight to try it in your space, which is invaluable for avoiding ill-fitting purchases.
When we can’t see a rug in person, established retailers and online marketplaces still offer plenty of options. HomeGoods and similar stores can be excellent for bargains if you have the patience to hunt. Larger retailers often have consistent styles and return policies that make online purchases less risky. If you find a rug you like online, search broadly—sometimes the same item appears at different sellers with varying prices or shipping options.
What We Spend on Rugs
Big rugs cost more. Our strategy has been to buy well once, so we don’t have to replace rugs repeatedly. We’d rather invest in a quality rug that lasts than keep buying inexpensive, short-lived options. Negotiation helps when shopping locally—simply asking “Is that your best price?” can yield discounts. If negotiating isn’t possible, look for online discount codes, seasonal sales, or free-shipping offers to reduce cost.
We’ve been willing to spend more on rugs that we love because they stay in our home for years. Mistake rugs from earlier homes taught us what to avoid and funded better purchases later. Still, we always look for deals and negotiate where possible.
Rugs Over Carpet
Placing a rug over wall-to-wall carpet can be a great move. A rug can add pattern, texture, and visual interest to an expanse of plain carpet. When layering over existing carpeting, choose a rug that blends with the background if you want the room to feel open and cohesive. A rug that clashes too sharply can make the space feel like a floating island.
Current Favorites
To help narrow things down, we keep a running list of current favorites in a range of sizes, patterns, and price points. Depending on your needs—durability for high-traffic areas, softness for bedrooms, or easy-clean materials for kitchens—there are reliable options across traditional and contemporary styles.
Rugs can be delightfully complicated, but with some patience—measuring carefully, choosing patterns and materials that suit your lifestyle, testing options in your space, and investing when it counts—you can find pieces that transform a room and stand the test of time.
Psst. If you’re interested in the paint colors and furniture sources used in our house, we keep a separate page with those details.
*This post contains affiliate links*