How to Paint a Ceiling Darker and Give It a Glossy Finish
Today we wrapped up a quick foyer-ceiling refresh that a bunch of you noticed in the background of yesterday’s post, so here are the full details. We actually tackled this project right before our big kitchen paint job, but that one jumped the queue because it was more dramatic. The foyer is a small, manageable space, so instead of avoiding the ceiling like we usually do, I rolled it while Sherry cut in around the edges — two coats and we were done.

For a little context: the foyer had freshly painted walls but an older, yellowed ceiling that made the whole entry feel unfinished. We decided to paint the ceiling one shade darker than the walls to add depth and to complement the existing palette. We used leftover Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter (eggshell) from a nearby bathroom project, while the walls remain Edgecomb Gray — both popular greige choices that play nicely together.

Visually, the darker ceiling gives the foyer a more intentional, layered look. In person you can clearly see the contrast between the Revere Pewter ceiling and the Edgecomb Gray walls, but it doesn’t feel oppressive — more like a subtle, tailored finish that helps the light and trim read better. Photographs can vary; sometimes the ceiling reads a touch darker or grayer than it does to the eye, so try to judge paint samples in the actual space at different times of day.

One practical note: we normally use flat paint on ceilings because it hides imperfections, but we had eggshell left over from the bathroom. The slight sheen of eggshell actually softens the foyer and reflects window light in a pleasant way, helping the space feel a little more luminous despite the darker tone. That said, sheen can make surface flaws more noticeable, so eggshell works best when the ceiling is in good condition — which ours fortunately was.

We debated whether this one experience would send us off the flat-ceiling train forever. The short answer: probably not. When we choose paint specifically for a ceiling in a room where the surface might show imperfections — like a child’s room or an older ceiling — we’ll likely stick to flat finishes to minimize texture and seam visibility. Interestingly, we later realized we also used eggshell on Clara’s ceiling, but the light and color there read much more matte, so the sheen can be very context-dependent.

We’re fans of non-white ceilings in many spaces — they can add personality and dimension, and colors like muted blues or greiges work especially well in entryways and sunrooms. That said, in some areas such as a busy two-tone kitchen with detailed paneling, a plain white ceiling still makes sense to keep the room feeling open and balanced.

Our Favorite Paint Colors
If you’re deciding on a paint color for your next project, here are some posts where we break down our go-to shades and how they behave in real rooms:
- The 12 Best White Paint Colors
- Benjamin Moore Edgecomb Gray
- Benjamin Moore Simply White
- Sherwin-Williams Pure White
- Sherwin-Williams Extra White
Psst — want to know where we sourced something in our house? Click the button below to shop items from our home.








