Objectales

Popular

How to Pick the Right Gray Paint Color for Any Room

featured 32389

Choosing a paint color can feel simple—until you need one gray to flow through several major spaces. We wanted the same color on the future dining room, the main hallway, and the living room to create continuity, and suddenly I was overthinking every swatch. Sherry had a field day teasing my indecision. One minute I’d be sold on a sample, the next I’d be ready to toss it out the door.

Part of my hesitation comes from a childhood mistake: I once painted my middle school bedroom a dark gray because I liked the name (something like “Cannonball” or “Cannon Smoke”). It read cold and prison-like, and only a bright red Looney Tunes rug and Tasmanian Devil pillows kept it from feeling completely bleak. That solution won’t cut it this time—these rooms are much more visible and central in our home.

To calm my paint paralysis, I persuaded Sherry—who was much more decisive and kept saying “let’s just pick one and do it”—to let me buy paint testers. She often recommends testing to readers who are nervous about committing to a color, so she agreed to a trial run. We narrowed our search to three Benjamin Moore grays, each mixed into Olympic Premium No-VOC samplers from Lowe’s (they were about $2.50 each). From left to right we tested Collingwood, Grey Owl, and Moonshine.

testing three Benjamin Moore gray paint options mixed in Olympic paint test cans - Collingswood Grey Owl and Moonshine

We painted a single coat of each directly on the wall, feathering the edges by hand so the test patches wouldn’t leave obvious raised squares when we repaint. A brush coat gave surprisingly good coverage, which made it easy to judge each color’s undertone without too much fuss.

Here are the three samples in the future dining room, arranged in the same order: Collingwood on top, Grey Owl in the middle, and Moonshine on the bottom.

test areas of three Benjamin Moore gray paint colors applies to an area of white wall

Because lighting varies across a house, Sherry painted additional test swatches in the family room—one cluster near the TV and another set beside the large window. Seeing the colors in different parts of the room helped us judge how natural daylight and interior light would affect the undertones.

picking the perfect gray paint color by painting three test swatches onto the wall, Collingswood Grey Owl and Moonshine

…and beside the window where the daylight is stronger and cooler.

three Benjamin Moore gray paint options painted as test squares on a white wall with wood trim

One of the main benefits of using tester pots is being able to watch a color across different lighting conditions and times of day. You can do this with small swatches, but a full painted patch makes it much easier to judge how the color reads from across the room and whether it coordinates with trim, furniture, and textiles.

We also observed the samples at night under our warmer artificial lighting. The evening light nudged the undertones, so it was important to see how each swatch behaved after sunset.

testing gray paint swatch colors on the wall during nighttime light

three Benjmain Moore gray paint color swatches on a white wall at night time in artificial light

testing paint colors on a wall during night time when artificial light is used instead of natural light

After living with the samples for a few days, I finally conceded that Sherry was right—Moonshine, the bottom swatch in our lineup, was our favorite. It reads as a clean, true gray with a slightly silvery quality that feels refined without being cold. It’s dark enough to make white moldings pop, yet neutral enough to sit quietly behind bold curtains, art, and accessories.

Collingwood almost won us over, but it leaned warm and tan—too close to the Glidden Sand White we used in a previous house. We like Sand White, but this time we wanted a cooler, more clearly gray tone, so Collingwood was out. Grey Owl read more green/blue in our light, and that pushed it away from the neutral gray we were aiming for; it risked looking like a muddy blue-gray depending on the hour and the room.

Now that Moonshine is our pick, we’re gearing up to paint both large rooms and the connecting hallway. We’ve already started, but with a baby and blog duties in play, it may take a few days to finish. We’ll share photos once the job is complete.

Have you used the paint tester method to choose a gray or another color? Did the samples confirm what you expected or send you in a different direction? How long did you leave your test patches up before committing? Ours stayed for nearly a week, and I can easily see how those patches could linger for much longer if you’re still undecided.