Objectales

Popular

How to Plan and Buy Materials for a Fireplace Makeover

featured 56500

Fresh paint in the kitchen has given us a new perspective on the room and inspired us to take the fireplace to the next level. We’ve talked before about expanding the mantel and retiling the painted-over tile hearth, and now that the rest of the space feels more finished, it’s time to give this side some attention.

img 56500 1

Since moving in the fireplace has already seen improvements—we removed the old stove and gave the brick a fresh coat of paint—but compared to the shiny penny-tile wall on the other side of the kitchen, this area still feels unfinished. We want to create a more substantial, architectural focal point: a built-out mantel, framed side columns and a tile surround that will tie the room together.

img 56500 2

We’ve been collecting inspiration for a while. A few multi-stage fireplace makeovers we love have influenced our thinking about refacing—building an attractive shell over the existing fireplace to add depth and detail. The idea is to combine wood framing and trim with a tile surround around the firebox so the final result reads as a cohesive, designed element rather than an afterthought.

img 56500 3

We’ve also been drawn to pages that showcase tile-infused mantels, which gave us confidence that tile would be a great way to link both sides of the kitchen. With the other wall covered in penny tile, a complementary tile treatment around the fireplace should balance the space without matching it exactly.

img 56500 4

After measuring and sketching, we worked out a to-scale plan so proportions and details would be right. The drawing shows a mostly wooden build with a slightly shaded inner frame: that shaded area will become a sleek tile surround for the firebox. The plan is straightforward, but careful planning helps ensure the finished look feels intentional.

img 56500 5

We considered several tile directions—more penny tile, a luminous sea-glass mosaic, and classic marble subway tile. Ultimately we chose marble subway tile because it’s timeless and pairs nicely with the gray penny tile already in the kitchen. We wanted a neutral, enduring choice rather than something that might feel dated later.

img 56500 6

To give the classic marble subway tile a fresh twist, we’re installing it in a herringbone pattern around the firebox. That pattern will add visual interest and a bit of unexpected sophistication without overwhelming the room.

Thankfully, gift cards helped make this choice economical: the marble subway tile was affordably priced, so our tile cost ended up being very reasonable. That allowed us to allocate more budget toward the woodwork and trim that will define the mantel and surround.

img 56500 8

Tile is only a part of the transformation. Most of the project is carpentry—building out the base, constructing the mantel, framing the side columns and adding trim details. We’ve planned for high-impact moldings and a clean, classic profile that complements the kitchen’s existing finishes.

img 56500 9

We’ve already gathered all the materials: tile, backerboard, boards for the base and mantel, 1×2 pine pieces for decorative detailing, trim, masonry screws and the tiling supplies leftover from previous projects. Having the right tools and materials on hand makes the build process smoother and keeps the project moving.

img 56500 10

The brick hearth had previously been painted—a textured, smashed-tile-mosaic look under a coat of white—so we’re excited to cover that up with a clean tile surround and crisp woodwork. The new mantel and tile will modernize the hearth and create a cohesive focal point in the kitchen.

img 56500 11

We’re already underway and planning to share the entire step-by-step process, from framing to tiling and finishing. If everything goes to plan, we’ll return with a completed tile update and detailed photos of the finished mantel.

img 56500 12

What projects have you been sketching or planning lately? Are you starting a tile project or putting gift cards toward home improvements this season?

P.S. There was a little Clara celebration at school this week—so here’s a quick snapshot of how that went (and yes, Sherry let her hair down for the occasion).