Objectales

Popular

How to Replace a Broken Penny Tile

featured 45277

Tweakity-tweak-tweak. That was the small correction we made in our kitchen last night. After taping things off, mock-arranging them in photos, and drilling through tile to install metal brackets, we thought we had the spacing right. We chose the layout because the studs fell in those spots, and keeping equal spacing across the hood seemed like it would create visual balance on an otherwise asymmetrical wall.

  • Functionally, the brackets lined up with the wall studs
  • We assumed equal spacing on both sides of the hood would make the wall look balanced

But as we lived with it and added other updates—new lighting, a dishwasher, artwork and new flooring—we noticed something off. At first it showed up only in photos, then in real life: the eight brackets on the left side of the hood felt crowded.

img 45277 1

Several readers had even suggested that six brackets would look better on that side, but we were too excited and a little impulsive after transforming a dark, dated room to stop and rethink the design. It took living with the arrangement for our eyes to adjust, then one day we realized we should have chosen fewer brackets. It was that classic what-was-I-thinking moment—like ignoring a friend’s advice about outfit choices and finally admitting they were right.

One advantage of working on older houses is that most things can evolve: paint gets refreshed, furniture is rearranged, and hardware can be moved. We’ve repainted rooms more than once in our previous home and made plenty of tweaks as we went along. The takeaway? If at first you don’t love a design choice, it’s often easier than you think to revise it. Keep moving pieces around until a space feels right.

Here’s the kitchen after our bracket redux. The arrangement is simpler and cleaner, and we like how the center bracket aligns with the counter line—it keeps the composition intentional and balanced. (Note: the middle bracket sits exactly between the other two; any apparent shift is due to the camera angle.)

img 45277 2

So how did we fix the fact that we had drilled eight holes through tile on the left side? It wasn’t complicated.

First we cleared the shelves—those small black dots you see are removable 3M Velcro pieces holding a lightweight frame. Then we unscrewed the shelves from the brackets and lifted the brackets off the wall screws. In the photo you can see the two screws for each bracket, like tiny colons on the wall.

img 45277 3

img 45277 4

We measured and drilled two new holes for the center bracket using a tile drill bit. Because these new holes didn’t land on studs, we installed heavy-duty anchors to support the brackets. The outer bracket screws still go into studs, so with the combination of studs and strong anchors each shelf is very secure.

Next came removing the tiles that had permanent holes. I chiseled them out myself in a few minutes using a flat-head screwdriver and a hammer, tapping the screwdriver into the grout around each tile to loosen it and then prying the tile out. Often only one of the two screws for each bracket had gone into a tile while the other hit grout, which meant we only had to remove the tile where the hole existed and later refill grout for the smaller holes.

img 45277 5

img 45277 6

With the old tiles removed, we applied tile adhesive and pressed replacement tiles into place. After that we mixed a small batch of grout to fill the joints around the new tiles and to cover the smaller holes that had been in the grout lines.

img 45277 7

img 45277 8

Ta-daaa—the two extra brackets are gone and the wall looks like it always did. The grout was still drying in the photos, but once it cured you couldn’t tell we’d replaced tiles or moved brackets. Best part: the whole fix cost us nothing in materials since we used leftover tiles and grout. Score.

img 45277 9

img 45277 10

img 45277 11

img 45277 12

The lesson: even careful planning, mockups and measurements don’t always predict how a design will feel in everyday use. Most home projects are iterative—move, test, tweak, and repeat. Treat renovations like experiments with many lives; you’ll learn what works and what doesn’t along the way, and the improvements will get closer to perfect each time.

What projects have you reworked after living with them a while? Have you ever removed and replaced tile yourself? It’s oddly satisfying to chisel out an old tile and see the change happen.