Objectales

Popular

How to Replace a Door Knocker and Doorbell

featured 59483

Updating Our Door Knocker and Doorbell: A Simple DIY Refresh

We promised an update about hunting for a new door knocker and doorbell, so here’s the follow-up. This isn’t about the other kind of knockers — just our front-door hardware. Our original knocker was charming but clearly aged, and it even had the previous owner’s last name etched into it (I blurred it out in photos to be considerate).

img 59483 1

At first we assumed the engraving meant the knocker was beyond saving, so we started shopping for something unique and substantial. Our first stop was our local hardware store, Pleasant’s Hardware, which had playful, animal-inspired designs that Clara adored. The problem was the price—some pieces were around $188, which felt steep for what we wanted.

img 59483 2

Next we visited an architectural salvage shop that’s always full of interesting finds. They had a few great options, including a chunky ring-style knocker we loved, but prices there were also higher than expected (that ring was about $185). It made us realize just how much a door knocker can cost when it’s the real deal.

img 59483 3

We checked the big-box stores—Lowe’s and Home Depot—which had budget-friendly options. The problem was they offered the same basic urn-style knocker we already had, only smaller and less distinctive. Choosing one would have meant new holes in the door for no real gain in character.

img 59483 4

Online shops like Restoration Hardware and Anthropologie had some interesting and slightly more affordable designs—around $50 or so—but those options were much smaller than our original knocker and risked looking undersized on our tall facade.

img 59483 5

Feeling worn out from knocker hunting, we reconsidered keeping our existing piece. A salesperson at the salvage store had suggested having the engraving professionally buffed out, but before spending money we decided to try a DIY approach. My Dremel had sanding attachments that seemed suited to the job.

img 59483 6

We removed the knocker from the door and I started with a coarse sanding pad attached to the Dremel to remove the old engraving. It took a few careful passes to get the letters mostly gone. I paused a couple of times, worried I’d overdo it, but Sherry reminded me that a fresh coat of paint would hide any imperfections.

img 59483 7

After removing the bulk of the engraving with low-grit sanding, I switched to higher-grit pads to smooth the surface and reduce visible scratches. The sanding left faint patterns but also revealed a warm gold undertone that hinted at the knocker’s original finish.

img 59483 8

If we had wanted a polished-gold look and the patience to detail every groove, we could have pursued that finish. Instead, we chose to paint the knocker to match the darker hardware elsewhere on the porch. Sherry used Rust-Oleum Universal All-Surface spray paint in an oil-rubbed bronze tone, applying three light, mist-like coats to build coverage without drips.

img 59483 9

Once the paint dried, the de-personalized knocker felt right at home on our freshly painted blue door. The new darker finish ties in nicely with the door hardware and other black accents on the porch, and the area I sanded blends in with the rest of the surface.

img 59483 10

Here’s a detail shot with the door slightly open to show the smooth finish without as much reflection.

img 59483 12

We also refreshed the doorbell. We liked its shape, but previous over-painting had obscured its details. Using the same oil-rubbed bronze spray, Sherry covered the bell while protecting the button with a small piece of sticky tack (poster putty). That method kept the button clean and was much easier than trying to cut a tiny circle of painter’s tape.

img 59483 13

img 59483 14

All told, a single $7 can of spray paint allowed us to update both the knocker and the doorbell, turning two tired, painted-over pieces into cohesive, understated accents. The darker finish helps them stand out against the blue door while matching the black planters and the trim around the doormat.

img 59483 15

Next up: dealing with that crooked, bug-infested porch light. Small projects, big impact.

Update: Our home didn’t come with a wired doorbell, so we installed a wireless video doorbell. It was simple and quick—an easy upgrade if you’re considering a modern doorbell solution.

Psst—Clara’s at it again, being all funny and cute over here.