Objectales

Popular

How to Replace a Toilet: Step-by-Step Guide

featured 45891

First, sorry for another post featuring toilets, but I’m genuinely excited to share our new white toilet. The almond-colored one that came with the house never looked as fresh as we wanted—no matter how much we cleaned it, it always read “beige” instead of “sparkling.” A crisp white toilet brightens the room, feels truer to our mid-century style, complements the newly painted trim and shower curtain, and simply looks cleaner. We were practically giddy the night before toilet shopping.

Old almond toilet

The almond Kohler we removed actually wasn’t cheap—according to the Kohler site it retails for over $1,300. It’s a high-end fixture, but its color and space-age shape didn’t suit our taste. We’d been dreaming of a traditional white model since we moved in 15 months ago, and honestly, our behinds aren’t discerning enough to notice the differences between a thousand-dollar toilet and a much cheaper one.

Toilet side view

Before buying a replacement we rechecked the measurements, especially the rough-in (the distance from the wall to the floor bolts) and the clearance for the door. Our rough-in measured about 11.5″, close to the standard 12″, but since the existing toilet was listed as 12″ we felt another 12″ model would fit. Because the room is small we avoided an elongated bowl, which would have interfered with the door swing. We considered changing the door to swing outward, but that would block the sink niche and disrupt the visual balance we like with the chandelier centered over the sink.

Removing old toilet

I’ll skip step-by-step installation photos—I’ve covered that process before—but here’s the obligatory shot of the old one coming out. Since it’s a one-piece unit, it was heavier to carry out than the two-piece toilets we normally deal with.

Old commode out

After removing the old unit we cleaned the flange area. Thankfully the rust and residue wiped away easily and the floor was ready for the new installation.

Toilet flange outline

Cleaned installation area

We chose an $88 Glacier Bay model from Home Depot. It met our measurements, has a solid flush rating, uses less water (potentially lowering bills), and a number of readers had good experiences with Glacier Bay. We plan to add a dual-flush conversion kit to conserve even more water once we’re sure everything is running smoothly.

New Glacier Bay toilet parts

The toilet included most of the necessary hardware, but because our flange sits down a bit into the tile we needed an extra-thick wax ring kit. It was an inexpensive extra purchase and made the seal solid.

Preparing wax ring

One helpful tip a few readers had suggested was sliding drinking straws over the bolts to guide the bowl into place. That trick worked great and made lining up the holes much easier—especially when Sherry offered the timely directional advice.

Straws on bolts

Aligning toilet bowl

Once installed, there was a moment when sunlight hit the bowl perfectly and it almost looked like a glowing portal—an oddly satisfying sight. We let the new Glacier Bay run for a few days to ensure there were no issues before converting it to dual flush.

Sunlit toilet bowl

New white toilet installed

The new white toilet helps shift focus away from the beige tile and toward the room’s white accents like the curtain, trim, door, and light switch covers. It also matches the other white toilets in our home and feels more appropriate for a mid-century ranch. The fixture is slightly taller, which is more comfortable for taller users, and even my shorter half noticed it feels less “squatty.”

Toilet and trim

Overall the room is coming together. We’ve made progress but still have a few tasks left to complete the refresh. Some views emphasize details beyond the toilet—the mirror, light, and art all help tie the space together.

Bathroom progress

Alternate bathroom angle

Bathroom details

Our updated to-do list:

  • paint the walls for contrast
  • replace the ceiling light
  • paint the cream trim white
  • hang bathroom-friendly art
  • sell the old toilet and install a classic white one
  • add a privacy solution to the window
  • trim the bottom of the door so a rug or bathmat fits and install a door stop
  • consider replacing the border tile in a later phase
  • reposition the blue pendant to center it over the window
  • replace the floor tile down the road to break up the expanse

Mood board

We’ve listed the almond Kohler on Craigslist. It’s gently used and, given its original price, we figured we’d try to recoup a little of the replacement cost—someone offered $60, so it should find a new home soon. Now that the toilet swap is done, we’re moving on to the next items on the list. Have you swapped out beige or almond fixtures for white or stainless in your home? We’d love to hear about your experiences and any other toilet tips.

Psst — to follow the rest of this bathroom refresh, see the earlier planning and progress posts in our project series.