How to Sell a Kohler Toilet on Craigslist Quickly
Remember the almond toilet that came with our master bedroom (which we recently switched out for a taller, cleaner-looking white model)? For a while the old almond toilet—oddly appearing white in the photo below—just sat in our entryway. That felt strange, but there was a plan.

Selling the Old Toilet and Donating the Proceeds
When John discovered the toilet was a Kohler that originally retailed for over $1,300, he thought we might recoup something by listing it on Craigslist. You’d be surprised what people buy there, and a few days later we sold it—for $80. A lovely family (a father with two boys and a baby girl) came to pick it up after work. It felt surprisingly satisfying to pass something still serviceable on to a new home. Our daughter Clara waved goodbye with us and announced, “I go in car too!” which made the whole moment even sweeter.
At first we thought of the $80 as a modest credit toward our new toilet (which cost $88). A few days later we learned about a local family that Habitat for Humanity is assisting: a single mother named Chevelle who is expecting a new house for her family of six. For a $100 donation, Habitat can provide a toilet for the new home.

We decided to put our $80 Craigslist profit plus $20 of our own money toward that $100 donation. Habitat for Humanity does great work, so supporting them felt like a meaningful next step for our old toilet. If you’re moved to help, consider donating to your local Habitat affiliate.
Bathroom Door Problems: Why We Needed to Trim It

Earlier we mentioned that the bottom of our bathroom door needed to be trimmed. It couldn’t open fully because it rubbed against an air vent in the floor. Aside from being annoying, the tight fit made it impossible to use even a thin bath mat—the door would wad it up and push it, leaving puddles of bathwater on the floor outside the tub. Clean or not, stepping into a puddle or wearing wet socks into the bathroom is unpleasant.

How We Trimmed the Door (DIY)

We finally tackled the door this week. The process was straightforward: first we removed the door by unscrewing the hinge screws, taking care to support it so it didn’t slam down. Two people made this much safer and easier.

We carried the door out to the patio and set it on the table saw. John held the door against the fence while I fed it slowly into the blade to get a clean cut along the bottom. Safety matters: have a second person to help and use appropriate guards and clamps. After trimming, I sanded the raw edge to remove splinters and smooth the surface—doing this before rehanging the door makes the sanding much easier.

We removed roughly a third to a half inch from the bottom so the door would clear both the vent and the future bath mat. Once the cut and sanding were finished, we rehung the door using the original hinge screws and checked the swing and clearance.



Success: the door now clears the vent. We’ll do a few paint touch-ups along the bottom edge where the cut removed finish, but visually and functionally it’s much better.

I also installed a small doorstop on the bottom right edge so the towel hooks on the back of the door won’t slam into the artwork on the adjacent wall.

Where the Bathroom Project Stands
Here’s our current bathroom to-do list:
Paint the walls to add contrastReplace the ceiling lightPaint the cream trim whiteHang bathroom-friendly artSell the old toilet and replace it with a classic white modelAdd privacy to the windowReplace the cluttered shower caddyRemove the door to shave the bottom and add a doorstop- Finally get a bath mat
- Consider replacing the border tile around the room (phase 2)
- Move the pendant light to be centered in front of the window (phase 2)
- Replace some of the floor tile to add visual interest (definitely phase 2)
John and I are still deciding whether to tackle the border tile and light relocation now or wait until phase two. If we pause those items we’ll share a full budget breakdown for Phase One. In the meantime, the door trim fix already improved daily life: no more puddles at our feet and a door that finally swings freely.
Have you ever sold a secondhand toilet, bought a new one, or trimmed a door for better clearance? We’d love to hear about your experiences and any tips you learned along the way.
To follow this bathroom refresh from the beginning, check out the planning post, the painting post, the light-swapping post, the art and trim-painting post, the toilet-updating post, and the window frosting and shampoo wrangling post in our archives.








