How We Downsized Our Home: What We Kept
Settle in—this is a deep dive. If you enjoy long, detailed reflections about moving and home life, grab a cup of coffee. Today we’ll cover:
- Key lessons we learned while downsizing over the past few years
- Which pieces from our larger home made the cut and continue to work in our smaller house
- Why some items adapted well and others didn’t
- Practical packing and moving advice based on hindsight
This post started when we noticed, while sitting downstairs, that several pieces in the room had been bought specifically for this smaller space after we moved. The loveseat, the chairs, and the coffee table were all selected to fit this compact sitting area and evolved into place over time.

By contrast, the rug, the tray, decorative vases and planters, many pieces of art, and a nearby bookcase moved with us from our previous home. That raised questions: three years into downsizing, how much of our former furniture and decor still feels essential? Which items have lasted a decade or more, and why did some pieces adapt better to a smaller home?

We wish we could have packed only pieces that would have been a perfect fit in the new house, but downsizing rarely comes with a crystal ball. We had room dimensions and plans, yet nothing replaces actually landing in a space and trying layouts to see what truly works.
There’s nothing wrong with buying new items that fit a smaller home—especially when you go from a 3,150 sq ft house with many rooms to a 1,400 sq ft house with far fewer rooms. We sold a lot of our previous home’s furniture with the house because we knew not everything would work in the new footprint. Some things moved and fit immediately; others worked temporarily and were later sold or donated when a better long-term solution was found.
Our last house’s bonus room, for example, was mostly sold to the new owners. We kept a few pieces that we could adapt elsewhere, and you can often tell which items were meant to stay because they’re versatile, classic, or compact.

Downsizing is a balance between keeping the things that make you happiest and ensuring those items function well in a smaller space. Our decisions about what to bring were based on a few pragmatic factors:
- Measurements—some items simply wouldn’t fit.
- Previous use—if we hadn’t used it in the last house, we didn’t bring it.
- Educated guesses—there’s always some uncertainty when moving.
- Function—practical concerns, such as whether a rug would trap sand in a beach house.
- Gut feeling—sometimes you know you’ll regret letting something go.
- Sentiment—meaningful items earned a place even in a smaller home.
There’s no perfect formula, but that framework guided our choices as we loaded the moving pod. Looking back, what stuck around and why is revealing. Many lessons become obvious with hindsight, and we’ll share the most useful takeaways after describing what ended up staying.

One universal piece of advice for any homeowner: let your new home evolve. Our downsized house came together over time through trial and error. When we first moved in, the sitting area looked chaotic, and we used what we had until better solutions emerged.

Pieces moved around until we found the best arrangement. Some, like the bookcases, eventually found a permanent home upstairs where they felt made for the space. Others shifted room to room until we realized they weren’t serving us and donated or sold them.

We discovered narrower, taller dressers (three drawers, not wide six-drawer ones) work best in smaller rooms and can double as nightstands. The loveseat we added downstairs is another example: we didn’t need one in our old, larger house, but it fits this space perfectly now.
The Upstairs Family Room
If we’d been upstairs the day we started thinking about what “came with us,” the reaction would have been different—our upstairs family room retained almost everything from the previous home. It’s the largest living area here, so naturally it can accommodate more pieces from a larger house.

This large room absorbed the functions of three separate spaces from our old house: the office, a family room, and the kids’ art area. That multifunctional approach made the space work far better than forcing single-use rooms in a smaller footprint.
Our Previous Home’s Office
We recreated our old office setup—our Parsons desk flanked by two shelving units—without needing an entire dedicated room. The desk, a wedding gift from 2007, has proven to be timeless and durable. Small adjustments, like removing the desk’s rear legs so the top sits on the window ledge, added five inches of clearance and improved flow.

We also moved smaller versatile pieces, like a neutral cowhide rug, because they’re compact, adaptable, and work with multiple styles—an easy way to ground a room without creating awkward layout conflicts.

Our Previous Home’s Family Room
The upstairs TV area retained anchor pieces from our old family room—our sofa, lamps, and soft accents transferred easily. We combined items from several rooms to create a cohesive new family area, including small side tables, woven mirrors, and ottomans that moved between spaces.

Neutral, well-sized rugs and adaptable decor proved invaluable—the right rug can fit virtually any room and last for years.
Our Previous Home’s Art Room
Our kids’ art and homework area transitioned into the family room by downsizing one drawer base and swapping in a longer countertop. We kept chairs for a while, then replaced them with slimmer armless models that tuck in without scuffing the tabletop. Small, useful items—lamps, letterboards, frames, baskets, and our printer—were easy to integrate and made the new space feel personal immediately.

Our Outside Spaces
Porches and decks can absorb larger furniture from a prior home, and ours did. The hanging egg chair, outdoor sofa, vintage metal chairs, and trusty blue drum stool all found new outdoor homes. Outdoor spaces are often overlooked in packing plans, but having enough patio furniture can be a real advantage.


Our Bedroom
One of the largest pieces we kept is a blue inlay dresser that originally lived in our beach house. It’s a treasured secondhand find that now sits in a corner of our bedroom that was once intended for a second bathroom. For now, that renovation is on hold—the dresser serves as storage and is even a candidate to become a future vanity if we decide to add a bathroom.

We purposely keep fewer dressers—three in the whole house—so each one is special and multifunctional. Narrower dressers that can double as nightstands are especially valuable in a smaller home.

The Bathroom
A large capiz mirror that used to hang in our foyer now serves above the bathroom vanity and sees daily use. It stayed because we had a perfect spot for it and because we genuinely love it—two simple but powerful reasons to keep something during a move. Small decorative objects and art that mattered to us also made the trip and helped the house feel familiar right away.

The Kids’ Rooms
We brought personal favorites—books, toys, and meaningful decor—plus larger furniture like a gold mirror that works above a desk and doubles as a vanity. The inlay dresser moved rooms and functions over the years and ultimately proved its worth as versatile storage and bedside tables in our daughter’s room. Our son’s room relies on built-in small-space solutions and repurposed rugs and baskets from the previous house.

Many small but essential kitchen and household items—silverware, plates, cookware, a toaster, and tools—also came with us. Those everyday items matter more than extra decorative pieces when you live in a smaller home.

What We Learned About Packing For A Move / Downsizing
1. Know the big spaces that need big pieces
In hindsight, we packed a few large items that didn’t have long-term homes in the new house. Those pieces helped initially but were later sold or donated. Conversely, we could have prioritized additional outdoor furniture for the many porches and decks here. Before you move, think about which large spaces you’ll actually furnish.

2. Bring the little things you love
Small items—art, lamps, plants, framed photos—make a new house feel like home quickly. If it’s small and meaningful, bring it. If not, be ruthless about leaving filler objects behind.

3. Stay flexible and embrace evolution
Don’t lock items into the function they had in your old home. A decorative shelf can become kitchen storage; a dresser can become a vanity. Flexibility lets more pieces survive the move and reduces the need to buy replacements.

4. Think cohesively
Keeping a cohesive aesthetic—light woods, neutral tones, inlay, capiz, brass, pastels, and plants—creates flexibility. If everything feels like it belongs together, you can move pieces between rooms without creating visual friction.

5. Be patient
Downsizing is a process, not a one-day event. It took us years to refine layouts and find long-term solutions. Give yourself time to experiment and adapt. We rarely regretted the things we donated because we kept what we truly used and loved.

A surprisingly durable move MVP for us has been simple white Ikea planters—practical, long-lasting, and incredibly versatile. Small, trusted pieces like that can anchor a new home.

If you worry about missing an item later—say a rarely used appliance—remember that replacements are usually easy and inexpensive. It’s better to have space filled with things you use regularly than cabinets full of items you don’t.
We can’t even remember many items we donated after downsizing. If you don’t use something regularly when it’s time to move, put it in the donate/sell pile. You’ll likely never miss it.

We hope this overview helps or at least entertains. Downsizing has given us more time for beach and pool life, less house maintenance, and a home that better reflects what we love and use. If you want to dig deeper into our journey, we’ve shared more photos and reflections elsewhere on our site and in our podcast.
*This post contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.








