Kitchen Brain Dump: Meal Planning, Pantry & Recipe Ideas
Kitchen Brainstorm: Considering a Banquette Instead of an Island
We’ve been juggling a few projects lately: updating the blog design, continuing our $6 cabinet makeover, tackling yard work, a bedroom refresh, and scheming the next phase of the kitchen. While we save for new appliances (a proper wall oven and a microwave that don’t clash with our plans), we reconnected with an old friend and kitchen pro to get fresh ideas.
That friend is Nancy Kulik — the designer who helped plan our first kitchen renovation through Home Depot. We didn’t lean on her for style that time because we already knew we wanted white cabinets and light, marble-like counters, but her space planning advice was invaluable. She helped us decide where to tuck in a dishwasher, relocate the fridge, and build in a microwave so the finished kitchen would function much better. Lesson learned: experienced designers understand how people use kitchens, and professional input can transform a DIY plan into something far more useful.
We kept in touch with Nancy over the past three years, and when we showed her a current, to-scale kitchen floor plan and a few photos, she offered straightforward feedback and a concept we hadn’t considered. Before I get to that, a quick recap of the space: the eat-in part of the kitchen currently has a small dining table in front of a fireplace. We’ve long planned to replace that table with a built-in island after opening a wide doorway to the dining room, but the fireplace location complicates centering any island on that wall.

We originally imagined a large round dining table in the dining room with a smaller island in the kitchen, so two tables wouldn’t awkwardly line up across the new wide doorway. We also hope to paint the cabinets white, replace our mixed white/bisque/black appliances with stainless steel, keep the existing granite counters while refreshing the backsplash, and remove the fluorescent lights and the oversized ceiling fan. The floors are another open question: hardwood may run under part of the kitchen but our joists won’t support heavy tile, so we’re weighing options from lightweight cork to resilient sheet flooring.

Back to our meeting with Nancy: she noticed a critical mismatch between our earlier whole-house floor plan and the actual kitchen — the fireplace sits nearly in the corner of the room, very close to the hallway door. In other words, it’s off center on that wall, which makes a centered island impractical because it would either rub up against or block the doorway.

Nancy proposed an alternative: a floating L-shaped banquette that faces the fireplace and aligns with the framed wall opening. At first we hesitated — island-lovers might find the idea odd — but the more we considered it, the more its advantages became clear. An L-shaped banquette can create a cozy, defined breakfast nook that makes visual sense with an off-center fireplace in a way a centered island cannot.

Note: the sketch line that aligns the back of the banquette with the door to the living room is to show visual alignment; the banquette itself would float in the room rather than attach to the wall, preserving openness much like an island would.
We taped out Nancy’s idea on the floor. The smaller L, tucked into the bigger L, represents the bench seating facing the fireplace and the framed wall. The larger L would be built cabinetry that wraps behind the bench, providing storage and a finished look from the back — essentially acting like an island’s base cabinetry while keeping the seating oriented toward the fireplace.

We plan to match the height of the banquette and cabinetry tops to the lower kitchen cabinets so the room reads as cohesive and open. Knocking out a large, six-foot wide doorway to the dining room behind the banquette will help maintain flow; the back of the banquette will feature attractive cabinetry so the view from the dining room remains intentional and finished.

Note: the light fixtures on this side of the room will need to move regardless of whether we choose a banquette or an island. For the banquette, we’d center the light over the table rather than over the seating.
To help visualize, we tried a few table options at the taped location. A pedestal table makes sense for banquette seating because it maximizes legroom; we’re leaning toward a round or oval pedestal top in a light finish rather than a dark brown. Below are two test placements — one round pedestal and one lower square top — to illustrate scale and clearance.


We understand this concept may not immediately win everyone over. A floating banquette facing an off-center fireplace is unconventional, and photos rarely show the back of a banquette the way we need to imagine it — which makes visualization tricky. We might build a cardboard mock-up or use photo editing to better picture the finished configuration.

That odd white fireplace surround on the floor is temporary; it currently crowds the table, but when we redo the flooring and double-side the fireplace so it reads into the living room as well, it will feel less intrusive. We’re considering a gas option or leaving the fireplace inoperable so kids can safely play around it like a secret passage.

In short: we taped a new shape on the kitchen floor and are seriously entertaining a cozy banquette-style breakfast nook instead of a centered island that would never align with the fireplace. It’s an idea that solves a specific layout challenge while adding a warm, functional seat-and-storage solution. We’ll keep working through mock-ups, material decisions, and lighting relocations, and we’ll share updates as the plan evolves. For now, back to the bedroom project and the office cabinet makeover — DIY life keeps us delightfully scattered.








