Objectales

Popular

Kitchen Wall Removal: Opening Up Our Space

featured 42109

This is the week: wall-opening week (w.o.w.). We’re excited to share how it’s going and to answer a few of the questions we’ve been getting most often:

    1. How we chose a contractor
    2. How we handled permits
    3. How we planned the precise location for the opening (no one wants to demo and then wish it had shifted a few inches)

We love a good DIY project, but when it comes to structural work we’ll hire a pro. We’ve demo’d non-load-bearing walls before (like when we created a laundry nook in our first house), but cutting an 8-foot opening through a main wall that needs a heavy-duty, precisely placed header is not the time to learn on the job. Experience matters when you don’t want to compromise your home’s structural integrity.

img 42109 1

To find the right contractor we took a straightforward approach:

  • Asked friends, family and neighbors for recommendations and even posted on Facebook for local referrals.
  • Checked websites to learn more about about the ten or so candidates we considered.
  • Narrowed the list to four contractors based on reputation, experience and the recommendations we received.
  • Called all four and arranged in-person estimates, explaining up front that we were collecting multiple bids so everyone would offer their most competitive price.

All four contractors inspected the job and provided quotes within a few days. Each bid covered the same scope: remove an 8-foot section between the dining room and kitchen, install a support beam above the new opening, add floor support, reframe the doorway and threshold, build a short knee-wall for the kitchen peninsula, patch and add drywall, and install jambs and trim on both sides.

img 42109 2

Here’s how the four bids compared:

  • Contractor #1: Nearly $4,000
  • Contractor #2: Around $3,200
  • Contractor #3: $650–$1,000 (depending on materials)
  • Contractor #4: $700 if we handled drywall, jambs and trim; $950 otherwise

The range was eye-opening. All four were licensed and insured Class A contractors with extensive experience, so the differences came down to how each company priced labor, overhead and jobsite extras. For example, one bid included a port-a-potty rental and dumpster fee—items we didn’t feel were necessary for our project but are common on larger renovation quotes.

Before getting bids we already liked Contractor #3 (a father-son team who also volunteers with Habitat for Humanity) and Contractor #4 (a friend-of-a-friend with 30+ years of experience). In the end we chose Contractor #4 for a few reasons: we knew him indirectly, he brings decades of experience, his team includes a younger woman which we were excited to support, and he was open to letting us do the non-structural finishing work ourselves to save money. That $700 price for the structural work felt right compared to the higher bids.

img 42109 3

As for permits, we assumed we’d need one and planned to submit our drawing and pay the fee (permits here cost about $150 and can be issued the same day). Before going to the office we called the building department because all four contractors suggested that a plan reviewer might determine a permit wasn’t required for our specific circumstances. After explaining the project to Jay, the plan reviewer, he confirmed we didn’t need a permit. Two factors helped: our house is a single-story ranch (so the load on the wall was partial rather than carrying a second story) and there used to be a doorway in that wall decades ago, which meant some structure was already in place. Permitting rules vary by location, so check with your local municipality before assuming the same outcome.

img 42109 4

Deciding exactly where to place the opening required planning around the peninsula and appliances. We needed to build in the fridge and relocate an existing 36″ cabinet (which used to be where the stove sits) to finalize the peninsula alignment. Finding a corner cabinet at the ReStore gave us the critical reference point to see how everything would sit against that wall and where the opening should land.

We’re still sourcing an 18″ cabinet that will complete the peninsula. In the meantime we taped the footprint of that cabinet on the floor and set up four chairs to visualize the seating that will accompany the future 3′ x 5′ countertop (with a 12″ overhang at the seating sides). These mockups helped confirm walking space—about 4 feet beyond the stools—and ensured the opening lines up with the start of the peninsula. Aligning the doorway with the peninsula and the dining room’s picture window helps the new opening look intentional, as if it’s always been part of the house.

img 42109 5

We chose a half-wall rather than a full open doorway with cabinetry for several reasons:

  • It prevents the peninsula from looking like an afterthought placed in the middle of a doorway.
  • The half-wall grounds and supports the peninsula so it feels solid instead of floating between rooms.
  • We already have four base cabinets in the dining room from existing built-ins, so we don’t need extra storage on the dining-room side.
  • Adding another built-in less than three feet from the existing built-ins would feel overwhelming.
  • The half-wall creates a cleaner threshold—without it, there would be an awkward strip of cork flooring between the peninsula cabinet and the dining room floor.

img 42109 7

Below is a Google SketchUp view of the sightline through our future doorway based on the tape mockup:

img 42109 8

And here’s the full floor plan sketch to refresh the top-view layout:

img 42109 9

That’s the plan—now we’re ready for demo. We’ll post photos of the work within 48 hours if everything goes as scheduled. What’s on your to-do list this week? Anything fun planned for the weekend? Tell Sherdog about it—she’s all ears.

Psst—The groomsman photo in this post was taken by David Abel.