Objectales

Popular

Paint or Tile a Concrete Floor: Pros, Costs and Tips

featured 60638

Last time you saw our sunroom, it looked like this:

img 60638 1

Now it’s starting to look more like this:

img 60638 2

Forgive the poor iPhone photo — it was the quick snap I texted to my parents before Richmond turned into rain city yesterday — but it shows the point: we’ve made solid progress on raising the ceiling. A professional framer helped us ensure the roof structure is sound. We’ll share the full ceiling story once the electrician finishes converting the now-loose wires into junction boxes for two fans.

Today, though, the focus is the floor. Specifically, the plan for the sunroom floor.

img 60638 3

We’ve weighed several options. The simplest would be to stain or paint the existing concrete, like we did in our first house’s sunroom. It’s fast and inexpensive, and for the right concrete it can look great.

img 60638 4

At our old place we used a semi-transparent “Tuscan Yellow” stain and later painted over it in a glossy chocolate when we wanted a different look. The process is straightforward and budget-friendly — an attractive short-term update for many concrete floors.

img 60638 5

Here, though, staining wasn’t a good fit. The concrete has glue stains from the carpet we removed, so any semi-transparent stain would highlight those imperfections. Even a solid paint didn’t feel right because the brick border, charming from a distance, looks worn up close with glue residue and nail holes where the old sliders sat.

img 60638 6

We’re also concerned about traction. The concrete gets slick when wet — Clara’s feet often drip after playing at the water table or in her plastic pool, and we got tired of near slips. That pushed us toward something with more grip, like outdoor-rated patio tile.

img 60638 7

Another deciding factor: painting the existing concrete would make future tiling nearly impossible. Paint prevents thinset from bonding to concrete, so covering the slab would effectively remove the option to tile later without extremely aggressive removal. Knowing we might want a higher-end tile someday, painting felt like a short-term fix that would create long-term headaches.

So we started looking at tile.

img 60638 8

We loved the large-format porcelain tiles right away, but the cost was daunting — that particular style was $6.29 per square foot, which would push tiling our 200+ square foot sunroom well past our budget. Then we noticed a Labor Day sale with 20–25% off total purchase and discounts on tools and supplies. That helped, but the pricier tiles were still out of reach, so we hunted for alternatives.

Our criteria were simple:

  • Outdoor-friendly material — the tile pros recommended porcelain for exterior-facing areas.
  • A rough, textured surface to reduce slipping when the floor is wet.
  • Affordable enough to tile the whole room without breaking the bank.

img 60638 9

We brought home three sample tiles (one of them was only available in a different size than we wanted, so we took a substitute) and laid them in the sunroom next to the deck to see how each paired with the wood tone and how they read in sunlight. We also wanted enough contrast so the slight step up into the sunroom — about an inch — would be obvious to guests.

img 60638 10

Our favorite was Mountain Slate Iron. Its deep color and warm brown undertones complemented the deck nicely, and it didn’t wash out in bright light the way the cooler samples did. It was also the least expensive and had the most pronounced texture, which made it our top pick for grip and safety when wet. For clarity, although these samples carry names like slate or limestone, they’re all porcelain tiles designed to mimic those stones — porcelain is what the pros recommended for outdoor projects in our climate.

Choosing tile meant committing to a more permanent, higher-quality solution. It’s more work and costlier up front than painting or staining, but it solves the traction issues, hides the concrete imperfections, and elevates the space visually.

So last night we placed the order.

img 60638 11

The tiles won’t be ready for pickup until next week, and we plan to finish the ceiling — beadboard, fans, and paint — before installing anything more delicate on the floor. We’re relieved to have decided, and happy to have caught a sale: the discounts dropped our chosen tile from $3.48 per square foot to $2.61 per square foot. Clara was so excited she had to call Elmo on her toy phone right then.

img 60638 12

Okay, maybe she wasn’t thinking about grout lines or texture, but she loved the display showers and clearly enjoyed hanging out where we were deciding. That’s good enough for us — she’s already showing a little interest in the project, and we’re looking forward to sharing the finished sunroom soon.