Objectales

Popular

Second-Guessing a DIY Project? How to Fix It

featured 63489

Question: Are there any projects you wish you hadn’t tackled yourself? I’m halfway through one that isn’t going well and I’m second-guessing the decision to DIY. – Holly

Answer: We get that question a lot. Honestly, we can’t think of a finished project where we said, “I wish we had hired that out.” Still, plenty of jobs brought us to the brink while we were in the middle of them. Sometimes it’s the relief and pride of finishing; other times it’s simply forgetting the worst moments after the fact. But there have been several DIYs that turned into serious learning experiences—projects that felt overwhelming midstream and taught us how to DIY smarter next time.

Below are four of those projects that nearly broke us during the process, and the lessons each one taught us about planning, pacing, and when to hire help.

what-to-do-if-youre-second-guessing-a-diy-project

#1: The Bathroom Demo. Early on, while I still worked a full-time job and my partner was pregnant, I set aside a Saturday to remove all the tile from the only full bathroom in our first house. I underestimated the time, the effort, and the sheer mess. Removing tile in an older home meant grinding through mortar and metal mesh; it was far more grueling than I expected. I remember being exhausted, sore, and convinced it would never end.

img 63489 2

Lesson learned: Demo work can be as time-consuming and physically demanding as installation. Now we always build that effort into the schedule and budget. Renting the right tools—like a demolition hammer—makes a huge difference, and in some cases we’ll hire out just the demo to get to the fun part faster and avoid injury.

img 63489 3

#2: The Patio. We had a patio installed quickly at one house, so we figured we could handle the second ourselves. We ordered materials and three tons of gravel, but didn’t fully account for the labor of moving and spreading it. Even with delivery, hauling tons of stone by hand was brutal and slow—more back-breaking work than we expected.

img 63489 4

Lesson learned: Moving and handling materials is often the hardest part. If you can get deliveries placed exactly where you need them, or hire a few extra strong hands for heavy lifts, do it. Paying a little for help can save time, reduce injury risk, and preserve your energy for the skilled parts of the job.

img 63489 5

#3: The Deck. Building a deck was one of our longest, most pressure-filled projects. It combined heavy manual labor, unfamiliar technical challenges, structural requirements and inspections, and hot summer days. Because it took so long, there were many moments of doubt. Yet finishing that deck gave us huge confidence: it’s one of our proudest DIY accomplishments.

What made it manageable was removing time pressure. We didn’t force a tight deadline, which allowed us to work through problems without feeling crushed. Even so, it took physical tolls—at one point I fell and hurt my back, and exhaustion brought me to tears.

img 63489 6

Lesson learned: Avoid unrealistic deadlines and allow budget flexibility when possible. A small cushion in time or money turns catastrophic-feeling mistakes into solvable setbacks. And when a similar project appears in the future, you might decide a pre-existing deck is worth paying for—though building one yourself can be deeply rewarding.

img 63489 7

#4: The Hardwood Floors. Unlike the deck, this project suffered because we lost our buffer time. A house sale moved faster than expected, and we suddenly faced a tight closing date with carpet removal, fresh trim paint, and hardwood installation all due. We tried to be smart—scheduling demo time and arranging childcare—but the final push turned into long, exhausting days of laying plank after plank. It was relentless and emotionally draining; the tiredness brought us to tears more than once.

img 63489 9

Lesson learned: Even careful plans can blow up when unexpected deadlines appear. Expect at least a couple of derailments and build contingency time where you can. Remember why you chose to DIY: cost savings, learning new skills, and the satisfaction of doing it yourself. Those reasons help push you through the toughest stretches.

img 63489 10

Over time our DIY experience has taught us to be smarter about when to call a pro. There’s no shame in hiring experts for specialized or risky work—plumbing problems, complicated electrical or load-bearing structural tasks, and major landscaping or grading jobs are often best left to licensed contractors. Doing some initial prep yourself can still save money, but recognizing a task that exceeds your skill set saves time, stress, and sometimes money in the long run.

img 63489 11

PS: If you want to learn how we decide whether to DIY or hire it out, we outline our evaluation process and practical criteria in a separate post that covers planning, risk assessment, time and budget estimations, and where to draw the line between saving money and preserving your sanity.