Transform a Wrecked House into a Rental-Ready Home
Remember our friends Carey and Jordan? We “House Crashed” them earlier this year, and I still love that mudroom. This time we visited another of their projects: a renovated, fully furnished rental in the Richmond area. It’s a great example of how smart, budget-conscious choices can make a rental feel warm, polished and welcoming—plenty of ideas you can borrow for your own home.

rug / round baskets / hooks / rectangle baskets / door color: Poppy by Ben Moore
The rental is a charming ranch that the couple is using mainly as a long-term furnished rental, with occasional short-term Airbnb stays between tenants. The furnishings are an eclectic and practical mix—thrifted pieces, HomeGoods finds (like a console table), Target accessories, and a few higher-end accents such as Restoration Hardware cabinet pulls. Mixing price points makes the house look thoughtful and layered without blowing the budget.
Carey tracked down several discounted treasures in unexpected places: the Justina Blakeney–designed rug for Loloi was bought at a deep discount after a local showhouse, and some larger pieces like the marble coffee table and the sectional are CB2 items she purchased secondhand from a friend. Those small wins add a lot of polish without the retail price tag.

rug / coffee table / sofa / gold mirror/ foyer light fixture
One of the most striking things about this house is how dramatic the transformations were—often from small, inexpensive changes like new paint. The main living area now has Sherwin-Williams Agreeable Gray on the walls, carried into the foyer to create a cohesive, open feeling throughout the front of the home.

In the foyer they repainted the red front door to Caviar by Sherwin-Williams and installed a sculptural pendant from Shades of Light. The small table and lamp are HomeGoods finds, and the framed prints are local Etsy work—simple touches that add personality without a huge investment.

rug / light / art / wall color: SW Agreeable Gray / door color: SW Caviar
The kitchen reveal is especially impactful because the cabinets weren’t replaced—they were updated. Carey and Jordan hired a local carpenter to create new inset doors, then painted everything Extra White by Sherwin-Williams. Paired with Restoration Hardware hardware, a subway tile backsplash, new black granite counters, stainless appliances and a glass pendant from Pottery Barn, the entire room reads like a high-end remodel without the full demo.


To improve flow, they extended hardwood flooring into the kitchen to match the adjoining rooms and tucked a small café table for four opposite the sink to add function and charm. Those kinds of layout choices make a small rental feel intentional and livable.

Small decisions also made a big difference—removing an ornate header above the sink, installing clean shelving around the window, and swapping out a fluorescent fixture for a proper pendant created an immediately fresher, more modern kitchen.

similar rug / similar table / chairs / cabinet hardware / art prints / light over sink
They chose an outdoor rug under the kitchen table—a smart move for a rental or for families—because it’s durable and easy to clean. The colorful art nearby is from a local print company in Richmond, another example of sourcing unique pieces close to home.

The dining room went from wallpapered and dated to crisp and bold. Carey and Jordan used a deep Indigo Batik on the walls but balanced it with white curtains from Ikea, a soft white shade on the chandelier and warm wood tones in the table and sideboard. A large mirror above the sideboard reflects light and keeps the dark color from feeling heavy—an easy trick for darker rooms.


rug / metal chairs / end chairs / table / lamps / chandelier / curtains
Adjacent to the dining area is a small room with exposed brick that they turned into a cozy office and reading nook. Fun color choices—like a pink accent chair and a little blue file cabinet—make the space lively while still staying practical for a rental. Accessories like a faux fiddle leaf fig and a stack of books complete the vignette.

desk / pink chair / desk chair / file cabinet / similar rug / similar copper table / blue wall: SW North Star
The master bedroom was refreshed by removing outdated wallpaper, painting the walls Roycroft Pewter for a snug, inviting feel, and pairing the color with crisp white bedding and trim. A bench from HomeGoods, white pin-tuck bedding from West Elm and simple bedside pieces from Crate & Barrel and Target keep the room refined yet comfortable.


headboard / white bedding / night stands / black & white pillow / rug / bench: HomeGoods
The bathrooms were updated to feel crisp and classic, with thoughtful details like storage, vintage-inspired floor tile, and a rich wood vanity crafted by their carpenter. A Pottery Barn mirror and silver sconces elevate the space, while colorful rugs add pattern and warmth—small accents that make a big difference.

mirror / sconce / white hex floor tile / similar rug

Thanks to Carey and Jordan for letting us tour and photograph their rental—this house is a great example of how careful editing, smart paint choices, targeted carpentry and a mix of budget and elevated pieces can transform an older property into a desirable rental. If you’re local and interested in working with them on renovations or rental properties, you can find more on their renovation site and rental site. And if you meet Carey in town, ask for a taste of her gumbo—it’s a local favorite.
Holiday gift guides and a house tour decked out for the season are on the way—stay tuned. In the meantime, try injecting a few of these budget-friendly updates into your own space: a fresh coat of paint, strategic hardware upgrades, and a few curated secondhand finds can go a long way.
*This post contains affiliate links*








