Urban Pregnancy Myths: Truth vs Fiction
I thought it would be fun to test a few popular pregnancy myths—those old wives’ tales that claim you can predict a baby’s sex from cravings, heart rate, or the way you carry—and compare them to my own experience. I don’t expect these predictors to be scientific, but I wanted to see which ones lined up with my two pregnancies: Clara (my daughter) and the little boy on the way (due in mid‑April). Here’s what I found.
Rumor #1: If you crave sugary foods it’s a girl, and if you crave salty/savory foods, it’s a boy. This one didn’t hold up for me. The lore suggests that sweet cravings point to a girl and salty cravings to a boy, but both pregnancies involved strong salty cravings—baked potatoes became a near obsession. So in my case, cravings weren’t a reliable indicator of sex.
Rumor #2: If the baby’s heartbeat is over 140, it’s a girl. Not true for my pregnancies. Both babies had higher heart rates at various points, and the bun (my son) actually reached 170 early on while Clara’s was around 160. Heart rate varied and didn’t predict gender for me.
Rumor #3: You swell more when you’re pregnant with a girl. This one rang true for me. With Clara I experienced significant swelling—ankles and fingers were noticeably puffy by about 30 weeks, to the point where I couldn’t wear my wedding ring. With this pregnancy, now just weeks away from meeting our son, I haven’t had the same swelling issues. That said, swelling can depend on many things, so I’m treating this as a personal observation rather than a rule.
Rumor #4: You have more morning sickness with a girl. I didn’t find this to be accurate for my situation. I did have morning sickness with Clara until roughly 18 weeks, but with this pregnancy I’ve experienced nausea spread across the day—morning, afternoon, and evening—despite it being a boy. So again, morning sickness patterns didn’t clearly predict sex for me.

Rumor #5: If you dream about having a girl or boy, your dream is right. This felt true for Clara but not for this pregnancy. By about eight weeks I had repeated dreams and a persistent feeling that I was carrying a girl, and that intuition was correct. With the bun, I initially assumed it might be a girl because I experienced similar early cravings and nausea to my pregnancy with Clara, and I didn’t have any clear dreams about gender until we learned it was a boy. So dreams lined up once, but not consistently.
Rumor #6: You carry higher and wider with a girl, and lower and more in front with a boy. This one was partially accurate for me. My daughter’s pregnancy felt like a wider, more rounded belly, while this pregnancy with a son has felt more front‑facing—definitely more “out front.” That said, my son rode unusually high for much of my pregnancy until he finally dropped recently, so the “higher” versus “lower” aspect didn’t follow the expected pattern all the way through.

Rumor #7: Girls steal your beauty. This one made me laugh because it felt true in my case. My pregnancy with Clara came with more swelling, breakouts, and lackluster hair and skin. This time, while pregnant with a boy, I’ve noticed less swelling, fewer acne flare‑ups, and surprisingly shiny hair—which I jokingly describe as unrecognizable compared to the usual dry mess I was used to. Of course, beauty changes during pregnancy are highly individual and can vary with hormones, nutrition, and genetics.
Overall, these pregnancy legends provided a lot of entertainment but only occasional accuracy for me. Some matched my personal experience, others didn’t, and a few were mixed. The takeaways: cravings, heart rate, and nausea didn’t reliably predict gender in my case; swelling and my gut feelings/dreams were more telling for one pregnancy but not for both; and the way I carried showed elements of both myths depending on timing.
I’m incredibly grateful that the doctor says the baby is healthy and active. We’ll meet our son in about four weeks, and we couldn’t be more excited. If you’ve tracked any of these old wives’ tales during your pregnancy, I’d love to hear which ones were accurate for you and which turned out to be completely off the mark.








