What Our First Two Homes Taught Us About Homeownership
Q: Now that you’re in your third house, I’m sure there are things you’ve learned about budgeting, decorating, house hunting, etc. after going through the process a few times. Would you consider writing a post about what your first and second house taught you? – Alison
A: Absolutely — and here it is. Every move and renovation teaches you something new, and our first two homes definitely shaped how we approached buying and updating this third house. Stylistically we expect to land somewhere between the light, beachy feel of our first home and the bold, colorful vibe of our second. Beyond style, practical lessons about spending, layout, materials, and patience have all influenced our decisions. Below are some of the most important takeaways we carried forward, in no particular order.

Spend thoughtfully: somewhere between splurging and scrimping. With hindsight, our first house probably benefited from a few splurges we could have rethought and our second from a few places where we were too stingy. For context, we invested significantly more into the first house than the second, and that showed most clearly in our kitchens. The first kitchen renovation used higher-end materials and professional labor, while our second kitchen saved money through more DIY work and painted existing cabinets. Both approaches gave results we liked, but each taught us something: splurging on quality matters when it affects daily function, and saving on labor can free up budget for better finishes. For this third kitchen we plan to save on labor where sensible but spend more on higher-end finishes and functional components, because we intend to be here long-term.

Bring the cozy back. The main reason we moved from our first to our second house was needing more space: working from home and a new baby made our small first house feel cramped. Our second house nearly doubled our square footage, which was wonderful, but after a while we missed the compact, cozy feeling of our original living room. That longing shaped our search this time: we wanted a home with comfortable, well-scaled rooms rather than one giant open space. This house gives us the balance — comfortable living room scale, slightly larger bedrooms, and enough bathrooms so daily life flows more smoothly.

Open where it matters. We like a sense of openness and flow, but we’ve learned it doesn’t have to mean a cavernous, entirely open plan. In our first house we widened doorways and used a light, cohesive palette to create airiness. In the second, we removed a big wall between the kitchen and dining room. What we’ve always wanted — and never quite achieved until now — is a true visual and functional connection between the kitchen and living room. That connection encourages family time, makes entertaining easier, and simply suits how we live. Here, removing a wet bar and adjusting plumbing will finally let us open the two spaces in the way we’ve long admired in model homes and well-planned renovations.

Floors are essential — do them sooner rather than later. We learned the value of addressing flooring early. In our first house we replaced and refinished most of the floors before moving on to other projects, and the result transformed the whole home. In our second house we put floors off the to-do list and later regretted it. This time we prioritized refinishing and updating hardwood floors right away so the rest of the design could build on a cohesive foundation. Flooring affects every other choice you make — rug size, paint color, furniture — so getting it right early saves headaches and keeps the home feeling finished and intentional.

Make outdoor access easy. We love being outside, and awkward transitions to patios or grills made outdoor living less frequent in our previous homes. This house has a large deck directly off the main level, which feels like a natural extension of indoor living. Converting a large window bay into doors and having the deck on the same level as the first floor have already made outdoor time more accessible and integrated into daily life. Small layout choices like that can dramatically increase how often you actually use outdoor spaces.

Patience pays off. One of the biggest lessons from our first two homes is that meaningful home transformations take time. We once expected to complete major painting and a full kitchen renovation in a few months, and we were humbled to learn projects can stretch into years. Over time we learned to enjoy the process: planning thoughtfully, saving for higher-quality solutions, and letting the house evolve with lived-in character. Treating a home as a long-term project — rather than something that must be instantly finished — brings freedom to make measured, better choices.
There are more small lessons we’ve absorbed along the way, but these themes — balanced spending, cozy scale, targeted openness, prioritized flooring, seamless outdoor access, and patience — have had the biggest impact on how we buy and renovate. Now we’re curious about you: how have your past living situations, whether renting, living with roommates, staying with family, or traveling, shaped what you want in your next home?
**********************************
As a little Friday bonus, here are a few projects and discussions happening in our community, plus this week’s giveaway winners announced in the forum.
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|||
| by PrettyOrganized | by curvyfurniture | by crabandfishblog | by karazzies |
![]() |














