Objectales

Popular

What We Learned Buying Our First Mattress

featured 33331

Shopping for a mattress in person felt oddly intimidating since we’d never really done it before. Up until now our mattresses had been hand-me-downs from family, inexpensive finds from Goodwill (we picked up two daybed mattresses there long before bed-bug paranoia took over), or an organic mattress we ordered online that fit our needs without a showroom test. So heading into brick-and-mortar mattress shopping for our guest room was a new experience.

img 33331 1

We wanted to do enough research to make a wise purchase without spending weeks comparing every option. Since this mattress will primarily be for guests, we aimed for a crowd-pleasing, reliable choice rather than something ultra-luxurious. After asking for recommendations and reading a few reputable reviews, we focused our search on well-rated innerspring mattresses—classic, supportive, and less polarizing than memory foam, which some people find too warm or too different in feel.

One recommendation led us to The Original Mattress Factory. We hadn’t heard of them until a Consumer Reports article ranked them near the top, right under Tempur-Pedic. Knowing memory foam wasn’t the direction we wanted, and looking for a locally made innerspring option, we decided to check out the store that happened to be only a few miles away.

From the moment we walked in, the buying process felt refreshingly straightforward. Three things stood out immediately:

  • They carry only their own brand, and every mattress is made locally at that exact location—it’s actually a working factory.
  • The store displays cross-sections of all their mattress models (and even several competitors), letting you compare coil gauges, filler thickness, and materials visually.
  • They keep pricing consistent by not running temporary promotions. Because they manufacture and sell directly, there’s no need for frequent sales or inflated “compare at” prices, which made it easier to trust that the price we saw was fair and final.

We still visited a few other discount mattress stores and Ikea to compare. Those experiences were confusing—multiple brands, layered promotions, and unclear pricing made it hard to tell which mattress matched which sale. Ikea’s delivery timing and final price also didn’t work out. After comparing options and confirming The Original Mattress Factory’s positive reputation and business rating, we felt comfortable going back and making the purchase.

We chose a full-size Classic Luxury Firm mattress set for $379, which included the box spring. To give guests a bit more cushion without overspending, we avoided the entry-level model but also skipped the top-of-the-line pillow-top tiers. Adding a metal frame ($50), delivery ($38), and tax ($21) brought our total to $488—right under the $500 budget we set for this project. Quality control meant the mattress arrived in great shape, and Burger gave it an immediate seal of approval during testing.

img 33331 3

We picked a full-size mattress because it fits the guest room best, uses the bedding and headboard we already own, and matches what most friends and family expect in a guest bedroom. Choosing the right size saved us the extra expense of replacing sheets and accessories, and made installation straightforward.

img 33331 4

Now comes the fun part: putting the rest of the room together so it looks less like a mattress in a box and more like a welcoming guest bedroom. With the mattress decision made and the budget respected, we can focus on bedding, pillows, and styling to make guests feel at home.

P.S. We’re running a giveaway over on BabyCenter for a Flip Ultra HD video camera (the one we use for our videos). There’s also a new Clara clip featuring a tambourine—pretty entertaining. Check out the post to enter and watch the video.