What We Regret About Our Beach House Renovation
Restoring a vintage stove is rarely as simple as it looks in photos. This week we’re sharing the little quirks that photos don’t show, along with several mistakes, regrets, and missed opportunities from our beach house renovation. Which tile choice do we wish we’d placed somewhere else? Where did our exterior choices fall short? How will we correct these things going forward? And yes, we’ll explain why we’re spending money to make the house smell better—hardly glamorous, but real-life renovation stuff.
You can download this episode from Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Stitcher, TuneIn Radio, and Spotify — or listen to it below. Use this page to find any links, notes, or photos we referenced. Note: If you’re reading in a feed reader, you may have to click through to the post to see the player.
What’s New

- If you missed it, here’s the original post about finding the pink stove and why we brought it home.
- Can you spot the tiny red light that’s always on in the photo above? It’s one of those small vintage quirks you don’t notice until you live with it.

- Here’s Ol’ Pinkie right after we moved it in last October—the stove “popped” when we first plugged it in. It was a scare, but mostly fixed now. Restoring vintage appliances is rewarding, but it can be unpredictable.

Beach House Regrets
- Below is a concise list of renovation regrets and lessons learned from the beach house. The podcast episode covers each one in more detail—listen if you want the full backstory and context.
- First, the hall bathroom: we used a blue accent tile in the shower, but the tile ended up hidden behind a door because building code required the light switches on the opposite wall. In hindsight we wish we’d used that tile in the downstairs bathroom where it would be visible from the entry.

- The downstairs shower sits off the mudroom/laundry area—exactly the place where that blue tile would have been seen and appreciated by everyone walking by. Lesson learned: think about sight lines and daily circulation when choosing tile locations.

- We also debated a breakfast nook that ultimately became a pantry. It looked charming on paper, but when we evaluated functionality—storage, traffic flow, and everyday use—the pantry was the right choice. The cozy nook aesthetic was tempting, but practical needs won out.

- Thankfully we love the final walk-in pantry and the custom shelves we built to maximize storage. You can see the pantry work in more detail in our post about building pantry shelves.

- One small regret is our en-suite sink. It’s tiny—Sherry’s designer friend loved it, but we still plan to switch to a slightly larger option eventually. For now the shower and tub keep that bathroom feeling like one of our favorites.

- We included a photo of a sink from our last home that still charms us—sometimes certain fixtures work better in a smaller, vintage-tiled room than in a more open space.

- The front porch on the pink house still needs attention—boards and finishes are rough and it’s on our to-do list. The front door also needs staining; these exterior tasks are next up for a better curb appeal.

- We talk more about the side and back wooden steps in Episode #99. Another practical hiccup we faced was the original placement of electrical plugs for the washer and dryer: they were too high, which would have interfered with adding a shelf above the appliances.

- We had our electrician lower the dryer plug about six inches so it sits under the appliance lip. The other outlet was hidden by a storage cabinet. The shelves in that laundry wall simply rest in brackets, so they can be popped off to access hookups easily. Read more about the laundry room makeover for details.

- Thermostat placement is another subtle but important decision. We chose locations near corners so they wouldn’t interrupt wall art. Upstairs the thermostat is just outside the main bedroom entrance, leaving the wall free for art; downstairs it’s near the dining room light switch. Later we swapped the stock thermostats for Nest E units for better control.

- You can also spot a transition between the living and dining rooms that’s higher than we’d prefer. It hasn’t caused problems, but we wish the threshold were as flush as other doorways. Small details like this matter to the final feel of a home.
- On a high note, we love the back bedroom. Adding a wall with pocket doors felt risky, but it’s been the perfect balance of nighttime privacy and daytime light, plus it gives us a private staircase—a win for functionality and comfort.

We’re Digging
- Sherry has been loving a set of travel photo prints from 527 Photo on Etsy. The shop has hundreds of beautiful prints at modest prices—an easy way to add meaningful art to a room. The prints we liked most are linked in the original post and one is now hanging in our living room.
- For podcast recommendations, we’ve enjoyed Every Little Thing. It’s a fun, informative show with episodes that make you look at small topics in a new way—our favorites include episodes like “How Old Is Winnie the Pooh?” and quirky deep dives into everyday questions.
If you want to find something we mentioned in a past episode, check our master list of everything we’ve been digging—it groups all of our past recommendations in one place.
Finally, thanks to Universal Furniture for sponsoring the episode. There’s a live giveaway to win $5,000 in living room furniture at UniversalFurniture.com/YHL through August 13th. YHLHAP listeners have lucked out in past giveaways—good luck if you enter!
Thanks for listening and following along—these projects teach us a lot, and we’re happy to share both the wins and the lessons. Happy renovating!
*This post contains affiliate links*








