White Corian Countertop Review: Durability, Care, Cost
Merry Countermas to us!
They’re here, and they’re absolutely gorgeous.


As a reminder, the room—once affectionately called the cave—looked like this when we moved in last December:


Back to our brand-new Corian countertops. I didn’t expect them to feel so thick, heavy, and stone-like—think marble without veins. They don’t feel plastic at all. The finish is sleek with a subtle matte quality that reads like honed marble. Our installer mentioned that the white matte finish shows scratches far less than other finishes, which is a relief. Needless to say, we’re completely smitten.
Installation looked a little chaotic while it was happening, which we’re used to by now:

One of the most impressive parts of the install was how they made the seams disappear. They filled the joints between slabs with a specialized adhesive and then heated it with what looked like defibrillator wands to blend everything together:


After heating, they flash-cooled and polished the seams until they were invisible. Seriously—there’s no way to tell where the pieces joined. For that step we took Burger and Clara on a long walk while the adhesive was heated and cooled; it smelled a little funny, but it wasn’t dusty or messy, and when we returned the counters were pristine with the windows open and a fan running.
Here you can see where one seam used to run, right up this corner, before the installer did his magic. No trace left. Three cheers for seamless surfaces. And yes, that is a baguette on the counter—fancy, indeed.

Our installer walked us through how to care for the Corian, and I took notes like a nerd. Key takeaways:
- Corian is nonporous, so stains generally can’t penetrate. Most spills can be wiped or scrubbed away even if they’re not cleaned immediately.
- For stubborn discoloration—say red wine that’s been sitting a few days—a spray of about 10 ounces of water mixed with 1 ounce of bleach should lift the stain from the surface layer.
- The white color runs all the way through the material. If a spot refuses to come out, it can be lightly sanded in a circular motion with very high-grit sandpaper (around 400 grit) and then finished with a fine buffing pad. The installer even provided the sandpaper and pad, so small touch-ups are something we can handle ourselves without a full professional resurfacing.
- Our countertops come with a 10-year warranty. If anything ever cracks or needs repair, the same seam-filling technique can be used to make any damage virtually undetectable.
Hearing that John’s sister has had the same counters for five years with three kids and a big dog—with no repairs or stains—makes us even more confident. We’re not being as obsessive about protecting these as we were with our first kitchen’s granite counters. We’ve already used the kitchen more freely—spaghetti sauce has made an appearance with no disasters.
There is one downside: the new countertops make our old cabinets look a little tired by comparison.

Luckily, we plan to sand, prime, and paint the cabinets and finally replace the outdated hardware. We’ll also rebuild and trim doors where needed so everything matches the fresh counters.


That enormous 3′ x 5′ peninsula is even more impressive in person; photos don’t fully capture how big it is. It’s larger than the wood dining table we used to have. That expanse of workspace is pure joy—perfect for baking, crafting, serving appetizers, or spreading out for meal prep. The kitchen’s function has improved dramatically, and we haven’t even added stools or the wood trim that will hide the brackets on the back and side of the peninsula.

The peninsula edges are gently rounded, so there are no sharp corners to poke anyone—important in a family with very different heights.
People have asked whether we’ve been eating out while the kitchen was in progress. This time we were lucky: the fridge, stove, and dishwasher remained functional throughout the renovation, so we kept cooking at home even without counters or a sink. We improvised with plywood on the cabinets for prep space and used cutting boards and platters to avoid prepping directly on the plywood. Still, washing pots and pans in the tub was getting old, so it feels great to have a proper sink again.

The fabricators left us a small cutting board made from the sink cutout, which doubles as a trivet. While Corian shouldn’t have very hot pots placed directly on it, we’ve always used trivets and cutting boards on our old counters too, so that’s an easy habit to continue. We were very pleased with the installation crew, and overall the process went smoothly.
Before the countertops were installed we tucked a tiny time capsule behind one of the cabinets—stapled in a zip-top bag to the back of the cabinet—so it will only be discovered when the counters are removed in the future.

John wrote a short note to include inside. It reads:
Today our new countertops are being installed. We are a family of three (well, four if you count our chihuahua Hamburger). I’m John Petersik (age 30), my wife Sherry (age 29) and I moved here 11 months ago in December of 2010 with our daughter Clara (age 1.5). We write a blog about our home improvement adventures called Young House Love. If you’re reading this it means you’re probably getting new counters too. Hope you enjoy them!

It’s funny how quickly your eyes adjust—already it’s hard to remember how the tops of the cabinets used to look. Next on our to-do list: cut down and hang a cabinet for the built-in microwave, build or retrofit matching doors for the secondhand cabinets we added, prime and paint the cabinets, install a backsplash, mount the range hood and floating shelves, update lighting, lay cork flooring, install a new stainless dishwasher, add crown molding, and finish trim work. We originally hoped to wrap everything up by early January, but it may stretch into late January. We’re taking it one day at a time. And washing dishes in the sink again feels like a small but glorious victory.
UPDATE: We’re officially in love with our new countertops. See the follow-up post for more photos and thoughts.








