Objectales

Popular

Why We Chose Penny Tile for Our Kitchen Backsplash

featured 41458

Choosing the Tile: Penny Tile for Our Kitchen Wall

We finally made a decision. After one more trip to the tile store today we ordered over 50 square feet to cover the entire wall above the stove, where we’ll add open shelves and a vent hood as mentioned earlier. We spent an afternoon visiting small local shops and big-box stores to see what was available, and our best finds came from a local tile shop. Many of their beautiful options were expensive—nearly $20 per square foot—which works for a typical backsplash but would blow the budget for a full wall (50 sq ft x $20 = $1,000).

There were several styles we loved but couldn’t justify at those prices. For example, a smoky gray skinny tile was $17.99 per square foot, a moody gray glass subway tile was $18.99, a cracked glass tile reminiscent of marble and ice was $16.99, and a delicate tiny glass mosaic ran $14.99 per square foot.

img 41458 1

img 41458 2

img 41458 3

img 41458 4

Hidden in the clearance section, though, we found a soft gray penny tile with a smooth finish and clean circular shapes. It felt modern without being cold—more like a textured backdrop than a flashy wall. Best of all, it was priced at $5.59 per square foot, which made a full wall affordable (50 sq ft x $5.59 = about $279).

img 41458 5

img 41458 6

We should mention our history with this shop: we used them during a past bathroom remodel to find the right grout and supplies, and they later became a sponsor. They also offer a 10% discount to readers with the code YHL10, which brought our cost down even further.

Because this wall will be a focal point in the kitchen, we wanted something that felt like a deliberate design choice rather than a background afterthought. Choosing the penny tile lets the wall read as texture—it will layer nicely with open shelves, the range hood, cabinetry, countertops, cork floors, soft grellow walls, the fireplace, artwork, window treatments, and lighting. We’re installing the tile ourselves to save on labor, and are glad we can stay well under $300 for the tile alone.

Clara’s reaction was priceless. First she walked by and gave it a curious glance, then she reached out to pet it. She loved how smooth it felt. The tile is porcelain and non-porous, so it’s highly stain-resistant. We’ll be using stain-resistant grout and a no-maintenance sealer so the wall will be protected from kitchen splatter. From experience, sealing grout makes upkeep much easier—we didn’t clean our shower tiles for over a year after sealing them in a previous project. Reapplying sealer annually can help keep everything well protected.

img 41458 7

img 41458 8

img 41458 9

After we paid, Clara took my hand and led me straight back to the display for another petting session. She’s clearly a fan—and possibly the best tile salesperson we’ve ever had.

Before committing, we brought the sample home and looked up other kitchens with penny tile to see how it might read behind floating shelves or all the way to the ceiling. We also found examples that matched the finish we picked. Imagine this tile paired with dark cork floors, white cabinets, chunky white open shelves, and stainless appliances: it becomes a subtle texture that layers with everything else in the room instead of dominating it.

img 41458 10

img 41458 11

We staged the sample on a faux-sheepskin ottoman and paired it with our cork floor sample, a swatch of our kitchen wall color, a stainless-steel water bottle to represent appliances, and a small white ceramic tile to stand in for painted cabinets. The combination felt right—cohesive and balanced.

img 41458 12

We can’t install the tile until the cabinets, appliances, and countertops are in place, so the backsplash will be one of the last steps. We plan to do more demo and appliance moving tonight, and if everything goes smoothly we’ll share those photos soon. Progress is steady—slowly but surely. Or as Clara says when asked what a sloth sounds like: “slowly, slowly.”

Have you recently picked tile for a backsplash, floor, or bathroom? Did you visit multiple stores and compare samples before deciding? We spend much more time on choices like tile, flooring, and countertops than on paint, because those finishes are permanent and set the tone for the room. How do designers make big decisions so quickly on TV? Maybe they don’t have to live with the result—or maybe the pressure of a ticking clock helps make choices faster. Either way, we’re glad we took our time on this one.